NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2024
THE FUTURE OF AG IS HERE AT FAIRMONT ELEMENTARY
L-R: Heather Mulholland, her daughter Olivia, Christine Torosian-Klistoff
GO
On your mark, get set, GO!
The race is on to get the next field operation done and it’s you against the clock. What you need is farm equipment that will not only save time, but also reduce labor requirements and costs. Look to Andros for the industry’s leading irrigation and crop protection equipment lines, custom equipment, and recycling programs to help you run more efficiently. Time to GO with Andros.
Install, retrieve, reuse, and recycle more efficiently.
www.andros-eng.com 805-227-2801
Ag Services • Equipment Manufacturing • Research & Development
WESTERN GROWER & SHIPPER Published Since 1929 Volume XCV | Number 6
To enhance the competitiveness and profitability of Western Growers members
Dave Puglia President and CEO Western Growers davep@wga.com
Features
P. 16
Editor Michelle Rivera 949.885.4778 | mrivera@wga.com Contributors Cory Lunde 949.885.2264 | clunde@wga.com Emily Lyons 831.272.0661 | elyons@wga.com Julia Nellis 949.885.2270 | jnellis@wga.com Ann Donahue 949.302.7600 | adonahue@wga.com Kara Timmins 949.885.4786 | kmtimmins@wga.com Michael Escañuelas michael.escanuelas@gmail.com Circulation Marketing 949.885.2248 | communications@wga.com Advertising Sales Dana Davis 302.750.4662 | dana@tygermarketing.com
AG DAYS ARE HERE AGAIN AT FRESNO’S FAIRMONT ELEMENTARY
P. 20
TECH’S ROLE IN FEEDING THE WORLD
P. 23
A COMPREHENSIVE APPROACH TO SUSTAINABLE FOOD SAFETY
Articles
P. 32 WGCIT RESIDENT PROFILE NEW AGE LABS: A PARTNER IN PROGRESS
Departments
TOGETHER.
WGA.COM
4 President’s Notes 6 Agriculture & the Law 9 Advocacy | California 10 Science 12 Innovation 26 WG Member Welcome & Anniversaries
28 Inside Western Growers 30 Member Profile 34 Updates from the WGCIT 39 WG News You Can Use 44 Connections 45 Contact Us 46 Farm Dogs and Barn Cats of Western Growers
Western Grower & Shipper ISSN 0043-3799, Copyright © 2024 by the Western Grower & Shipper is published bi-monthly by Western Grower & Shipper Publishing Company, a division of Western Growers Service Corp., 6501 Irvine Center Drive, Suite 100, Irvine California 92618. Business and Editorial Offices: 6501 Irvine Center Drive, Suite 100, Irvine California 92618. Accounting and Circulation Offices: Western Grower & Shipper, 6501 Irvine Center Drive, Suite 100, Irvine California 92618. Call (949) 863-1000 to subscribe. Subscription is $25 per year. Foreign subscription is $50 per year. Single copies of issues, $2. Periodicals postage is paid in Irvine, California and at additional mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Western Grower & Shipper, PO Box 2130, Newport Beach, California 92658.
3 Western Grower & Shipper | www.wga.com November | December 2024
THINK COVID MESSED UP SUPPLY CHAINS? Wait Until California Mandates Electric-only Trucks By Dave Puglia, President and CEO
Sometimes I lazily revert to a line used by the title character in the movie “Forrest Gump” to explain whatever California policy madness has animated a family member or friend: “California is as California does.” For those who don’t know the reference, my apologies. But there’s really no rational way to explain why California’s air quality regulators – and the Newsom Administration – would knowingly put our state on the road to a supply chain calamity. Finalized by the California Air Resources Board (CARB) in October 2023, the Advanced Clean Fleets (ACF) rule mandates many businesses operating in the state transition their medium- and heavy-duty vehicles to zero-emissions by 2045. As with so many regulatory dreams, the ACF rule aims at a worthy outcome. The regulation aims to reduce greenhouse gases and improve air quality by requiring fleet owners to gradually replace their existing diesel trucks, buses and vans with battery- or hydrogen-powered vehicles over the next two decades. Furthermore, additional CARB regulations outside the scope of the ACF rule require that all new California- certified medium- and heavy-duty vehicle sales be zero emissions starting in 2036. According to American Trucking Associations President Chris Spear, the ACF rule is destructive and “sets wildly unrealistic targets and timelines that are already creating confusion on the West Coast and threaten to cause severe disruptions to our supply chain nationwide.” We learned in the early weeks of the COVID shutdowns that supply chain disruptions have enormous economic consequences, particularly for perishable products. Yet the State of California is hellbent on a repeat. Since the zero-emissions truck rule was first floated, Western Growers has been working publicly and behind the scenes – both independently and as part of larger business coalitions – to push back on the ACF rule, most recently with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). CARB must receive a waiver of preemption from the EPA under the federal Clean Air Act, which historically grants California the latitude to set its own air emissions standards. A waiver would pave the way for full implementation of the zero-emissions mandate. WG is among a host of trade organizations that oppose this waiver request. By law, EPA is required to consider, among other factors, the availability of technology and ability of fleets to comply in its determination.
Penske Truck Leasing offers a sobering analysis of the current zero emissions vehicle (ZEV) landscape: “ZEV trucks remain significantly more expensive than conventional models, and their prices continue to rise. The performance, range and payload capabilities of the current generation of ZEVs create unavoidable inefficiencies that require more vehicles for the same work.” Unfortunately, the EPA has a long track record of rubberstamping CARB waivers. This time, however, a rubber stamp would unleash an economic nightmare. In our recent comments to the EPA, we focused on the timelines, infrastructure and cost constraints of the rule. Agriculture is a transportation-dependent industry. Whether it is hauling fresh produce from the fields to coolers, processing facilities and – ultimately – the buyers or hauling the people, supplies and equipment that make such food production possible, our industry will be disproportionately impacted by the zero- emissions truck rule. Farming has hours, miles and horsepower requirements that have been shunted aside by CARB. Commercially viable and cost-effective replacement vehicles for agricultural production are still years away. Even further away is the rural electrical grid required to put charging stations for thousands of pieces of heavy equipment in place – not to mention the state’s already- strained electricity generation capacity. Beyond its impact on agriculture, the bigger picture of the zero-emissions truck rule may be this: What starts in California too often spreads to other states. Look no further than the wholesale adoption of California’s agricultural labor policies in states like Colorado. The state’s regulatory authorities are proud of this. (Sigh.) CARB has an entire webpage dedicated to tracking the number of states that have adopted California’s vehicle emissions standards in lieu of the federal requirements. (The answer is 17 states, including the WG home states of Colorado and New Mexico, and our nation’s capital.) Gov. Newsom has two more years at the helm. In that remaining time, he has many opportunities to rebalance state policies impacting economic vitality, just as he did on PAGA reform. He can direct his regulatory apparatus to pursue a reasonable compromise that considers not only California’s climate goals, but also its business climate and the realities of an interconnected global economy. I am quite certain that his successor, whoever it turns out to be, would be very grateful.
4 Western Grower & Shipper | www.wga.com November | December 2024
SERVING THE NEXT GENERATION.
That’s why American AgCredit o ers customized loans and financing programs to serve our nation’s young, beginning and small-scale farmers. GETTING STARTED IN AGRICULTURE CAN BE AN UPHILL CLIMB.
Learn more at agloan.com
Your future grows here
SCAN TO LEARN MORE
A Part of the Farm Credit System.
Equal Opportunity Lender.
MAXIMIZING EMPLOYER PROTECTIONS UNDER NEW PAGA: “ALL REASONABLE
STEPS” TO MITIGATE RISK By Jason Resnick, Senior Vice President and General Counsel
California employers have long grappled with the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA), a law that allows employees to sue on behalf of the state for labor code violations. However, recent reforms to PAGA have introduced significant opportunities for employers to mitigate their risk and reduce penalties—if they take proactive steps to ensure compliance before receiving a Labor and Workforce Development Agency (LWDA) notice or a request for records from an employee. These reforms place a premium on preparation, which means adopting a consistent cadence of compliance audits, policy reviews, employee training and corrective measures. PAGA’s New Focus on Remediation The PAGA reforms, effective July 2024, introduce a key change: penalties can be substantially reduced if employers demonstrate they’ve taken “all reasonable steps” to comply with the law before receiving an LWDA notice or employee request for records. For example, if an employer proactively conducts audits and corrects payroll or wage statement issues, penalties for any subsequent PAGA action can be reduced to 15 percent of the maximum. Even after receiving a notice, employers can reduce penalties to 30 percent if they promptly take corrective action within 60 days. This creates a powerful incentive for employers to regularly engage in compliance activities that not only meet legal standards but also document these efforts thoroughly. Employers who take these proactive steps will be better positioned to defend themselves and mitigate penalties in any future PAGA claim.
What Are “All Reasonable Steps”? Under the new law, “all reasonable steps” are determined based on the totality of circumstances, but employers should, at minimum, consider the following: • Periodic Payroll and Timekeeping Audits: Conducting regular payroll and timekeeping audits can uncover wage violations or non- compliance with meal and rest period rules. Once identified, employers should promptly collaborate with experienced employment law counsel to determine appropriate corrective action. Counsel can even conduct these audits for you. • Annual Handbook and Policy Reviews: Employers should disseminate compliant written wage and hour policies, including, for example, meal and rest period protocols and employee reimbursements. These policies should be reviewed and updated annually to reflect the most current legal standards. • Supervisor Training: Training supervisors on wage and hour laws, timekeeping and other compliance issues is essential. Supervisors are on the front lines of labor law compliance and play a critical role in avoiding violations. Documenting these training sessions will help demonstrate the employer’s ongoing commitment to compliance. • Corrective Action: Employers must be vigilant in addressing violations promptly. For example, if an internal audit reveals that meal and rest breaks are not being consistently provided, the employer should take immediate corrective A Continuous, Not One-Time Effort A key takeaway from the PAGA reforms is that these compliance activities cannot be one-time events. Employers should establish a routine cadence for audits, handbook reviews and employee training. This continuous effort demonstrates a culture of compliance and positions the employer favorably in any future PAGA action. steps, including potentially paying missed meal and rest break premium pay, retraining supervisors or adjusting work schedules.
"A key takeaway from the PAGA reforms is that these compliance activities cannot be one-time events."
6 Western Grower & Shipper | www.wga.com November | December 2024
Documentation is Key: Employers should maintain thorough records of every audit, training, policy review and corrective action taken. This documentation will be critical to showing the employer has consistently taken reasonable steps to comply with labor laws. Records of wage statement reviews, employee notices and payroll corrections should be kept for the applicable statute of limitations—up to four years for wage claims.
measures—they must be part of an ongoing strategy that embeds compliance into the day-to-day operations of the business. In a PAGA lawsuit, employers who can show they’ve consistently taken “all reasonable steps” have a powerful defense against the high penalties typically associated with such claims. By embracing this approach, employers can both mitigate their financial exposure and create a more compliant, employee-friendly workplace.
The Bottom Line: Prioritize Proactive Compliance The PAGA reforms have created a significant opportunity for employers to mitigate their risk, especially if they take proactive steps before being served with an LWDA notice or an employee’s records request. The key to unlocking these benefits lies in regularly reviewing and updating policies, conducting audits, training supervisors and documenting every action. These are not just reactive
Trusted Bankers + Tailored Solutions
You know business is about relationships. That’s what we’ve built our bank on, too. Get access to trusted advisors committed to your success plus the robust solutions you need to help you go further. We make it easy to do business with Western Alliance Bank. Customized solutions for your commercial enterprise. That’s real strength.
TRUSTED. PROVEN. RELIABLE.
Connect with us at westernalliancebank.com/plus
Western Alliance Bank, Member FDIC.
7 Western Grower & Shipper | www.wga.com November | December 2024
ENGINEERED
DESIGN SERVICES for Efficient and
Cost-Effective Farming
Irrigation Automation Save power, water and labor by making informed decisions from anywhere, anytime.
Deep Well Turbine Service, Repair, and Installation
Since 1948, Rain for Rent has proudly supported and partnered with the Agricultural Community.
®
®
A LOOK AHEAD TO 2025 By Matthew Allen, Vice President, State Government Affairs
At the time of this writing, we are awaiting Gov. Gavin Newsom’s final action on the bills that have made it to his desk for either a signature or veto. We are crossing our fingers for a few additional vetoes of legislation that would impose unnecessary challenges for our growers. That said, it has still been a very successful legislative year for us. Western Growers has successfully helped to lead wins on the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA), legislation mandating significant reforms to the California Department of Pesticide Regulation (DPR) and amendments to many bills across a variety of areas that will help mitigate the impact on California agriculture. Clearly, like our readers, our work is never done. In addition to our continued advocacy on regulatory issues, we will be gearing up later this fall to begin educating the many new California assemblymembers and senators who will be sworn into office on December 2. In December and January, our staff will dedicate much of its time to making rounds at the Capitol, meeting with new legislators and their teams. We’ll introduce them to WG, the growers we represent and the key issues vital to the continued success of our industry. Comprehensive overviews are offered on key topics, such as labor, crop protection, water, packaging, zero- emission mandates, energy policy and land use. These early discussions also assist us in better understanding the legislative goals of the new legislators. A major focus this year will be raising awareness on the need for key decision-making on scientific matters to remain at the designated agency level. A good example of this is the collaborative work WG
spearheaded this year, alongside allied organizations, on the pesticide mill assessment. Our coalition successfully negotiated improved registration timelines as well as other DPR reforms. Ensuring that science remains the key component on crop protection decision-making was the main impetus for WG’s constructive engagement. We also need to have DPR demonstrate that the registration process can and will work in a timely manner to incentivize new product registrations for use by our growers. Educating legislators not only about the issue but also about WG’s involvement is crucial. There are creative ways to address problems; we don’t always say no. It’s still way too early to decipher the types and number of bills that will be introduced next year. Indeed, there are routine instances where our proactive engagement has resulted in bill proposals being shelved entirely, often due to legislators receiving inaccurate information from bill sponsors or lacking a clear understanding of the issue. That’s why having a dedicated advocacy team that spends time in legislative offices going through the details is essential. The future is uncertain. What is certain, though, is WG’s unwavering advocacy and commitment to the issues that matter most to you as members. Just like the other departments within the WG Family of Companies, the state government affairs team is standing ready for what lies ahead. Of course, there will be challenges, but there will also be a great deal of opportunities. Here’s to a great close to 2024, and best wishes for a bright outlook in 2025 and beyond.
AGRICULTURE LAND INVESTMENT SALES ARIZONA & CALIFORNIA
Bobby Wuertz Agriculture Land Advisor bwuertz@landadvisors.com 520.251.1210
VISIT LANDADVISORS.COM
9 Western Grower & Shipper | www.wga.com November | December 2024
THE FOUR-LEGGED AG HEROES KEEPING PESTS AT BAY By Jeana Cadby, Environment and Climate Director
Dogs have over 300 million olfactory receptors, 60 times the measly five million of the average human. They can detect even the faintest scents, with precise direction. With this keen sense of smell, detector dog teams throughout California are deployed daily to identify fruits, flowers, soil and unprocessed agricultural materials that cross our borders. A single dog can clear up to 8,000 parcels a day in shipping terminals and other ports of entry to prevent the introduction of pests and diseases that could harm California’s valuable agricultural system and the farming community. The Western Growers team recently made a visit to Sacramento to learn more about how the California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA) is working to exclude pests from California and protect our local agriculture. We took this opportunity to interview Kernul, an eight year-old, 62-pound chocolate lab, and his handler Michelle King. Kernul is easily the most handsome government official we’ve ever met. He was adopted from an animal shelter in 2018 and now works full time for the CDFA
and Sacramento County, sniffing incoming packages at regional mail partners in Sacramento. Finding and training detector dogs is no easy task, yet Kernul had all the right attributes needed for a good detector dog: even temperament, solid work ethic, physical soundness and the utmost love of treats. Jackpot. According to United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) - Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS), invasive insects and plant diseases cost the U.S. an estimated $40 billion each year. The UC Riverside Center for Invasive Species Research estimates invasive species cost California more than $6.18 billion per year and can cause farmers to lose entire crops. Over the past few decades, the annual rate of detection of established populations of new species in California has been increasing. Some of this is certainly due to improved efficiency via more sophisticated detection tools, including the detector dogs program. However, increased and globalized travel and commerce has been a major contributor to incoming threats. The Invasive Species Council of California (ISCC) estimates that over 1,700 species have been identified as potential threats to California agriculture, ranging from insects, mammals and even viruses, with countless more yet to be analyzed on the horizon. We only anticipate this issue to become more pressing, and it is critical that we find ways to further protect our farmers. Enhancements in detection and trapping technology, pest and disease modeling and visualization, and public education will be critical tools to continue the fight "The UC Riverside Center for Invasive Species Research estimates invasive species cost California more than $6.18 billion per year and can cause farmers to lose entire crops."
Agricultural detection K-9 Kernul and handler Michelle King
10 Western Grower & Shipper | www.wga.com November | December 2024
against invasive species. Currently, California’s fruit-sniffing dogs are flown to and trained at the USDA National Detector Dog Training Center in Newnan, Georgia. While this training center offers a great opportunity to train and deploy detector dogs, capacity is limited, and the long distance is challenging for the dogs and their handlers. If we want to bolster the local capacity to train and deploy detector dogs in California, a local training center would help strengthen efforts to protect our local agriculture. We also spoke with Jason Leathers, Environmental Program Manager at the CDFA, who is leading the efforts to eradicate invasive fruit flies and other pests from California. “The majority "If we want to bolster the local capacity to train and deploy detector dogs in California, a local training center would help strengthen efforts to protect our local agriculture." of non-native invertebrate species established in California are insects. CDFA fruit sniffing dogs are able to detect fruits and insects that cross the border into California, potential vectors for pests and diseases that can cause significant damage to our local agriculture,” said Leathers. “Insects are highly adaptable with a high reproductive rate and a lot of genetic variability. This gives them the ability to quickly colonize and become a major pest. Exclusion is the best defense.” Maintaining rigorous biosecurity measures to exclude potentially harmful pests and diseases protects California’s agricultural productivity, economic stability, biodiversity and public health. To learn more about our visit with Kernul and the CDFA, you can listen to this episode on Western Growers’ Voices of the Valley podcast.
11 Western Grower & Shipper | www.wga.com November | December 2024
AN UPDATE ON THE AGTECH LANDSCAPE
By Walt Duflock, Senior Vice President, Innovation
The Western Growers Global Harvest Automation Initiative turns four in February, coinciding with the Tulare World Expo, in fact. A lot has happened since the launch. Some of the automation startups the WG Innovation team works with have successfully raised additional funding, others have entered the U.S. market from abroad, and some have partnered with equipment manufacturers and equipment dealers to scale their go- to market and reach more customers. Certain segments have made more progress than others. Weeding, thinning, harvest assist and spraying robots are already in the market and gaining traction. Our estimates show the U.S. market will make over $100 million in purchases in 2024 and will make over $500 million in purchases from 2024 to 2026. These products range from Carbon Robotics’ $1.4 million LaserWeeders to Stout’s $400,000 mechanical weeders, along with Burro’s harvest assist robots, available in three sizes priced between $15,000 and $30,000 each. Additionally, GUSS offers sprayers in three formats, priced from approximately $220,000 to $350,000. Capital has declined in the agtech space (and in all tech segments, in fact) for two years in a row. For agtech as a category, the $53 billion in funding in 2021 dropped by 70 percent in two years to $15 billion in 2023 and stayed there with $7 billion in the first half of 2024. There are macro reasons for this – limited partners who write checks to help venture capitalists get their fund
started are disenchanted with years of poor returns from VCs and are limiting their investments, and there are now more private company unicorns ($1 billion valuation) than public company unicorns. So the dynamics of getting capital into and out of venture funds has been transformed in a bad way for all of the key players. There are also agtech-specific reasons for capital struggles. Automation startups require a lot of capital to get machines built and iterated and require a lot of time to get the machines fine-tuned and market- ready for customers. The capital constraints have forced the WG Innovation team to focus on the later stage commercialization efforts for automation startups. While we recognize the potential of startups at every stage of the innovation funnel, we are concentrating our time and financial resources on those with products at the 1.0 stage or beyond, focusing on expanding their market presence and scaling operations. Specifically, WG is focused on delivering field trials for automation (and our second large initiative, biologicals) across all three stages: case studies to provide examples of grower economics, economic templates that growers can use self-service or DIY style, and WG Assist where WG provides a resource (i.e. a fractional financial analyst) to help growers evaluate automation solutions as they would integrate into their particular growing operations. It turns out that the type of crop (conventional versus organic), the type of labor (domestic versus H-2A) and the type of equipment ownership (buy versus lease) all impact the ROI for automation equipment. We’ve released our first two case studies featuring Carbon Robotics and Stout Industrial Technology. Our next case study will be on GUSS sprayers. We believe that helping growers understand how the math for each solution will work in their operations is one of the most valuable services we can help our members with, and we are glad to be focused on this process. If you have any questions on field trials, case studies, economic templates or WG Assist, please reach out to anyone on the WG Innovation team. Over time, we anticipate the number of economic templates will increase and that the templates for different types of automation and biological solutions will vary as we learn more from growers about how to evaluate the solution for their operations. We also anticipate we will add different WG Assist resources
12 Western Grower & Shipper | www.wga.com November | December 2024
to the WG Innovation team, including some with expertise in automation and others with expertise in biologicals. WG provides multiple late year options for seeing some of these solutions in demo environments. FIRA USA was October 22-24, and this year we were at Yolo County Fairgrounds after one year in Fresno and another in Salinas. We had more international and first-time startups at FIRA USA than the previous events, so by the time you read this growers will have had a chance to see from and talk to over 20 exhibitors in real-world conditions.
Similarly, we are partnering with YCEDA to deliver the Desert Difference in Yuma November 13-14. As with FIRA USA, there will be live demonstrations of automation solutions both days. To those who joined us in Yolo County, we hope you got great value out of attending and that you will share the feedback with other growers who can attend in the future. To those who can join us in Yuma next week, we appreciate your support and have put a great program together for you.
Have you seen how many biological suppliers are out there?
There are too many to wade through!
Yes! There are thousands of solutions and over 1,400 biological companies
You get it
How do I stay on top of all the new products and developments?
Don’t worry. Aginnovation has proven solutions, backed with trials and real-world data, for your peace of mind. We’ve got the data you need to make clear and informed decisions.
That sounds great
Aginnovation is your seed enhancement expert.
When would you like to connect?
Biologicals Polymers Colorants Equipment Organic Options
aginnovationusa.com
13 Western Grower & Shipper | www.wga.com November | December 2024
YOUR SPRAYER. ONLY SMARTER.
With the WeedSeeker ® 2 spot spray system from PTx Trimble, you can leverage your existing equipment to reduce tank refills, lower herbicide usage and spray when conditions are right — day or night. It pays to spray smarter.
For a limited time, save at least 10% on new purchases of WeedSeeker 2.
Scan to learn more and contact a local dealer.
PTxTrimble.com
© 2024, PTx Trimble LLC. All rights reserved.
YOU DON’T HAVE TO NAVIGATE THE H-2A PROCESS ALONE.
Secure a capable, reliable and legal workforce with expert help from Western Growers. Contact our experienced team to see how you can get the best benefits of the H-2A program for Western Growers member-only pricing.
To learn more, call 877-942-4529 or email H2A@wga.com
YOUR WORKFORCE.
Cover Story AG DAYS ARE HERE AGAIN AT FRESNO’S FAIRMONT ELEMENTARY
This school is redefining education through an innovative STEM program that brings local agriculture into the classroom.
By Michelle Rivera, Senior Communications Manager
Head of Fairmont's ag program Christine Torosian-Klistoff with student Olivia
In his poem “The Tables Turned,” English poet William Wordsworth wrote, “Come forth into the light of things, let Nature be your teacher.” That declaration is brought to life just 20 minutes outside of Fresno at Fairmont Elementary School, where children can experience something truly unique—perhaps even magical. From kindergarten to eighth grade, students discover science through the exciting framework of local agriculture, gaining knowledge in areas that include ag tech, ag business, ag marketing and animal science. The idea took root just eight years ago when Christine Torosian-Klistoff, now the head of the ag program, met with the school’s principal Jared Savage to discuss ways to make Fairmont extraordinary. That’s when they decided to make the school an ag-focused program. “I said, ‘What if we decided to base our school around agriculture and bring all of the kids their sciences through an ag lens?’ There are so many opportunities with technology and
innovation and agriculture that they wouldn’t otherwise know about,” Torosian-Klistoff said. For Torosian-Klistoff, the idea wasn’t entirely out of nowhere— she had grown up on a farm, where her father grew grapes and alfalfa and raised cattle. Drawing on this deep-rooted knowledge and passion for agriculture, she set out to create practical lessons aimed at providing students with a thorough understanding of agricultural fundamentals and their vital role to the San Joaquin Valley, one of the most productive food-producing regions in the world. She started small, setting up a chicken coop and several planter boxes in the back of the school. Eventually, she invited the district to view two acres of land that had become available next to the school, and they quickly decided to purchase it. Soon after, Torosian-Klistoff was introduced to Western Growers member Heather Mulholland, a fourth-generation citrus grower and chief operating officer at Mulholland Citrus in Orange Cove. There, the operation produces a diverse array of products,
16 Western Grower & Shipper | www.wga.com November | December 2024
including citrus, almonds and pistachios, along with nursery trees and beneficial insects. Mulholland’s eight-year-old daughter Olivia currently attends the Fairmont. In fact, it was Torosian-Klistoff’s passion and appreciation for agriculture that aided in Mulholland’s decision to enroll her daughter there, she said. “Christine is the greatest gift. She touches so many students’ lives and impacts them positively with creating love and knowledge for agriculture,” Mulholland said. Mulholland noted that Olivia has embraced the program enthusiastically, even insisting on attending school on days she’s not feeling well because she doesn’t want to miss Ag Day. The curriculum is comprehensive—covering a wide range of topics, including soil science, seed germination, pollination, plant sciences, fertilizers, agtech, irrigation, crop cycles and propagation. Engineering, drones and robotics, sustainable energy and 3-D printing are taught by Charlene Greisner and Tisha Jett, two other teachers who are part of Fairmont’s ag team. Students also benefit from field trips to packing plants and engaging lessons from local college students who are enrolled in ag-related programs. “When I was in third grade, I definitely didn’t learn about irrigation systems or robotics or propagation,” Mulholland joked. A standout feature of the program is the on-campus market, which not only teaches students about the business side of agriculture but also allows them to compete by selling produce. Torosian-Klistoff notes that the school collaborates with a local produce company, which provides the students with favorable pricing on goods. “The students get to choose off a list what produce they’d like to sell. They then decide on the price, when to sell their produce and how to best market it on social media. Parents and community members can purchase the produce at the school’s temporary
market. The goal of the students is to achieve a good profit,” Torosian-Klistoff said. The school has seen an increase in enrollees since the start of its ag program, going from 500 students eight years ago to more than 700 today. The program has captured the attention of not only parents from around Fresno, but also other school districts. “This program is the first of its kind in California, and many
L-R: Christine Torosian-Klistoff, student Olivia, Heather Mulholland
17 Western Grower & Shipper | www.wga.com November | December 2024
Olivia, student, learning firsthand about animal care and farm life.
18 Western Grower & Shipper | www.wga.com November | December 2024
districts have come to learn more about the program, in and out of California,” Torosian-Klistoff said. To accommodate its growth, Fairmont has plans to expand its facilities and construct an $8 million, two-acre complex that will house dedicated areas for plant and animal sciences. The expansion also includes a 4,000-square-foot innovation lab, which will focus on water energy and robotics. The agricultural complex will be accessible to all 8,000 elementary school students in the Sanger Unified School District, Torosian-Klistoff said, adding that all of this wouldn’t have been possible without the community and the Grow the Legacy Foundation. ‘It’s our goal to expand a program like this to other schools,” Torosian-Klistoff said. “We want to be able to create a blueprint for other schools to implement in classrooms not just in California, but anywhere. No one is putting this kind of focus into their curriculum plans,” she said. Torosian-Klistoff explains that the program has been a momentous opportunity for students as they transition to high school, offering them additional pathways to agriculture. “Kids have a great opportunity to get their associate’s degree in high school, so now there are 20-year-old students who graduate and are already out in the field working in incredible ag careers,” she said.
Mulholland sees the program as a good way to bring more awareness to high-tech positions in the industry. “Technology has been evolving so quickly, and growers are having a harder time filling specialized roles that require a lot of technical skills. We see a push for ag curriculum in college to attract people with these specialized skills, but at the Fairmont, it’s starting way earlier. It’s not just focused on production agriculture; it’s high-tech and includes the affiliated components that go into agriculture,” she said. Torosian-Klistoff’s passion for education is driven by a simple yet powerful goal: to make school a place where students are excited to learn. “I want kids to love school. That’s the hook of what’s going to get them loving it. So that has been my mission,” she said. And so far, that mission has proven to be fruitful. “Knowing that my child genuinely loves and looks forward to school, finding an additional reason to be excited about learning—it’s a tremendous achievement,” Mulholland said. “My hope is that each one of these students becomes an advocate for agriculture and gains knowledge about where their food comes from, no matter what path they choose in life. At the very least, they will have learned the fundamentals of agriculture and developed a deep appreciation for it.”
WESTERN GROWERS OFFICERS – 2024 Stuart Woolf, Chair Rob Yraceburu, Vice Chair Neill Callis,Treasurer Don Cameron, Executive Secretary Dave Puglia, President and CEO DIRECTORS – 2024 GEORGE ADAM Innovative Produce, Santa Maria, California CRAIG ALAMEDA Topflavor Farms Inc, Salinas, California ALEXANDRA ALLEN Main Street Produce, Santa Maria, California CHAD AMARAL D’Arrigo Bros Co of Calif., Salinas, Calif. KEVIN ANDREW Illume Agriculture, Bakersfield, California ROBERT BARKLEY Barkley Ag Enterprises LLP, Yuma, Arizona STEPHEN BARNARD Mission Produce, Inc., Oxnard, California BARDIN BENGARD Bengard Ranch, Salinas, California BRIAN BERTELSEN Cove Ranch Management, Reedley, California GEORGE BOSKOVICH III Boskovich Farms, Oxnard, California RODNEY BRAGA Braga Ranch, Soledad, California NEILL CALLIS Turlock Fruit Company, Turlock, California DON CAMERON Terranova Ranch, Inc., Helm, California
EDWIN CAMP D. M. Camp & Sons, Bakersfield, California CAROL CHANDLER Chandler Farms LP, Selma, California LARRY COX Lawrence Cox Ranches, Brawley, California STEPHEN DANNA Danna Farms, Inc., Yuba City, California THOMAS DEARDORFF II Deardorff Family Farms, Oxnard, California TIMOTHY ESCAMILLA Bolthouse Fresh Foods, Bakersfield, California CATHERINE FANUCCHI Tri-Fanucchi Farms Inc., Bakersfield, California DAVID GILL Rio Farms, King City, California ROBERT GIRAGOSIAN Kern Ridge Growers, LLC, Arvin, California BRANDON GRIMM Grimmway Farms, Arvin, California JOHN JACKSON Beachside Produce, LLC, Nipomo, California TRACY JONES Booth Ranches, Orange Cove, California A. G. KAWAMURA Orange County Produce, LLC, Fullerton, California ALBERT KECK Hadley Date Gardens, Thermal, California J.P. LABRUCHERIE LaBrucherie Produce, El Centro, California STEPHEN MARTORI III Martori Farms, Scottsdale, Arizona HAROLD MCCLARTY HMC Farms, Kingsburg, California
DOMINIC MUZZI, JR. Muzzi Family Farms, LLC, Moss Landing, California THOMAS NUNES The Nunes Company, Inc., Salinas, California STEPHEN PATRICIO Westside Produce, Firebaugh, California JOHN POWELL, JR. Peter Rabbit Farms, Coachella, California RON RATTO Ratto Bros. Inc., Modesto, California CRAIG READE Bonipak Produce, Inc., Santa Maria, California ERIC REITER Reiter Affiliated Companies, Oxnard, California KYLE RICHARDSON Garry Richardson Farms, Bakersfield, California SONNY RODRIGUEZ The Growers Company, Inc., Somerton, Arizona BRUCE TALBOTT Talbott’s Mountain Gold, LLP, Palisade, Colorado RYAN TALLEY Talley Farms, Arroyo Grande, California BRUCE TAYLOR Taylor Farms Calif., Salinas, California JACK VESSEY Vessey and Company Inc, Holtville, California MIKE WAY Prime Time International, Coachella, California STUART WOOLF Woolf Farming & Processing, Fresno, California ROB YRACEBURU Wonderful Orchards, Shafter, California
19 Western Grower & Shipper | www.wga.com November | December 2024
Feature story TECH’S ROLE IN FEEDING THE WORLD By Julia Nellis, Social Media Manager
Lately, conversations are dominated by the latest gadgets and cutting-edge tech trends. Questions like, ‘Did you get the new iPhone?’ or ‘When are you getting an EV?’ have become standard in our daily conversations. While these innovations undeniably shape our modern world, we rarely turn our attention to the technological breakthroughs that sustain us – figuratively and literally. The technological advancements that revolutionize how we grow and harvest the food that nourishes society often go unnoticed. For centuries, farmers and agricultural pioneers have relentlessly pushed the boundaries of progress in pest control and harvest technology. In the 1600s, early farmers relied on methods like tobacco infusions, herbs and arsenic to combat pests. By the 1800s, the arrival of the Colorado potato beetle spurred the development of more sophisticated pest control solutions, leading to the creation of Paris Green, a mixture of arsenic and copper sulfate. These early growers laid the foundation for what would eventually become the field of Integrated Pest Management (IPM), which did not see widespread momentum until the 1970s and 1980s. Meanwhile, the introduction of horse-powered combines in the Pacific Coast wheat fields in the late 1800s revolutionized the harvesting process, paving the way for gas- powered tractors two decades later. John Deere has become a major player in the ag tech space, particularly within high-value crop (HVC) industries that have yet to experience a full technological revolution. In partnership with GUSS, a leader in HVC autonomy with over 40 years of commercial spraying expertise, John Deere is bringing
autonomous solutions to growers worldwide. GUSS sprayers operate fully autonomously and are under constant supervision, reducing the need for multiple tractor operators and support personnel during spray jobs. This innovative technology enables growers to optimize labor management, upskill their employees and improve overall worker safety. GUSS technology allows operators who are adept at tractor driving to develop skills of field mapping, configuring sprayers for specific tasks and assigning routes to the machine. Having sprayed over 2.2 million acres, GUSS has firmly established itself as a global leader in agricultural autonomy. John Deere complements this with its rigorous engineering and testing processes, ensuring that their partnership continually improves and redefines the ag tech space. Growers using the John Deere and GUSS partnership to their advantage report promising outcomes, including a 98 percent retention rate and a 65 percent re-order rate. Looking ahead, John Deere envisions a future where data- driven precision spraying will further enhance safety, efficiency and sustainability in agriculture. With grower margins perpetually under pressure, precision technology and automation provide growers with the tools to control costs without compromising on yield or quality. This technology streamlines the entire process, ensuring no missed or double rows and eliminating human error from the equation. “GUSS sprayers are fully autonomous, and while under constant supervision, alleviate the need to have dozens of tractor operators and support personnel in the orchard while the spray
20 Western Grower & Shipper | www.wga.com November | December 2024
like the way the technology is working and really appreciate the information that it gives back to us,” he notes. One of the most significant advantages Dutton has observed is the reduction in material usage, directly translating to cost savings per acre. For a medium-sized grower like Dutton, controlling costs is critical to maintaining profitability. He emphasizes that reducing material use is one of the most effective, if not the only, ways to boost margins in today’s agricultural landscape. “The price of production materials will never go down,” Dutton adds. “But if growers can use less while still protecting their crops, they’ll be successful.” The ability to do more with less is the key to why precision agriculture and advanced technology are so vital to the future of farming, especially for the fresh produce industry. Beyond improving worker safety, these advancements offer substantial cost savings by allowing farmers to cover more land with fewer resources. Dutton remains optimistic, confident that these machines will only continue to become smarter and more resilient as they continue to be integrated into farming operations over time. He encourages small and mid-sized growers to embrace these advancements, sharing his belief that, “There is no need to fear this technology. You get out of it what you put into it.” The message is clear: adopting these innovations will not only streamline farming operations but transform how we feed the nation, ensuring a future full of affordable and accessible fruits and vegetables.
job is being completed,” says Sean Sundberg, HVC Business Integration Manager at John Deere. “By reducing the number of employees in or near the orchard or vineyard during the spray job, you inherently improve worker safety. Think overnight tractor operation, row after row in the dark, spraying material to protect crops. It is an incredibly important function, but it is difficult to find those that want to do that kind of work.” One operation embracing this shift toward precision agriculture is Dutton Ranch, a family-run wine grape operation in Sonoma County. Since adopting advanced technology in April 2024, Steve Dutton, a fifth-generation grower, has witnessed firsthand the transformative impact on his operations. The technology, SmartApply® Intelligent Spray Control System from John Deere, significantly reduces spray drift by precisely opening and closing nozzles to target the vines, in turn using less material per acre and extending the lifespan of each tank. Fewer refills and reduced operator exposure to crop protection material have improved both efficiency and safety, minimizing direct contact with potentially harmful agents. Dutton shares that his team, who uses the technology daily, has consistently provided positive feedback. “Their feedback is that it is working well. There is a user-friendliness to the technology that allows us to work through any potential hiccups. They all
LET YOUR PACKAGING TELL YOUR STORY.
YOUR FLEXIBLE PACKAGING PARTNER.
Fox Packaging understands that packaging is more than just a container - it’s a powerful way to express your brand’s identity and values. Our innovative packaging programs help you tell your story with every product. Whether you prioritize freshness, sustainability, or premium quality, our customizable solutions are designed to reflect your brand ethos and resonate with your audience. Let your packaging speak for itself and showcase your brand’s unique vision with Fox Packaging. Highlight Your Product With A Packaging Program That Tells Your Brand Story
Phone: 965.682.6176 Fox Drive • McAllen, TX 78504 www.foxbag.com | CQDE
REQUEST BAG SAMPLES, SCAN QR OR EMAIL info@foxbag.com
21 Western Grower & Shipper | www.wga.com November | December 2024
WITH GRATITUDE TO OUR VALUED SPONSORS Your support drives the success of the Western Growers Annual Meeting. We couldn’t do it without you!
3P Partners Barkley Ag Enterprises, LLC Biotechnology Innovation Organization Blue Tech Water Bunzl Agriculture Group Caine Law Cal.net
California Organic Fertilizers, Inc CopperPoint Insurance Companies D’Arrigo New York DP&F Law Feeding San Diego Fifth Third Bank Fisher Phillips LLP
Frost, PLLC Fruit Growers Supply Gowan Green Rubber Kennedy Ag Grimmway Farms H M Clause Inc Headstart Nursery, Inc.
JRG Attorneys at Law Keithly-Williams Seeds King City Nursery MIXTEC Group Peartree+Belli Architects Rosasco Law Group, APC Sakata Seed America
Sensitech Inc Southern Valley Chemical Co
Sturdy Oil Company Teleos Ag Solutions Tiverton Advisors LLC
Toro Petroleum TS&L Seed Co
Scan this QR code or visit wgannualmeeting.com
to learn more about Annual Meeting and our sponsorship opportunities.
NOVEMBER 3–6, 2024 SCOTTSDALE ARIZONA ,
Feature Story A COMPREHENSIVE APPROACH TO SUSTAINABLE FOOD SAFETY By Joelle Mosso, Associate Vice President, Science Programs
This is part two of a two-part series on food safety and sustainability. You can read the first part of this series in the September/October edition of the Western Grower & Shipper.
the agronomic system while assembling a multi-step process to mitigate risks for both sustainability and food safety. While the concept is straightforward, it is challenging to build a system for comprehensive farm characterization and monitoring due to the size and scope of all the variables. The direction may be clear, but the question quickly becomes, how would we begin? When we start to consider whole ecosystems, we must think broadly about measurement systems and targets since we have numerous factors that may have a positive relationship/ correlation, a negative relationship/correlation or a neutral relationship (i.e., independent). One of the reasons that food safety and sustainability efforts have sometimes felt at odds with one another is that it is much simpler to consider, in terms of food safety, a practice as either good or bad for food safety. This binary simplification is amenable to simple communication and alignment of actions. However, the reduction of complex questions to binary outcomes can lead to actions that are misaligned or even opposite of the intended results. For example, following the 2006 spinach outbreak, a common and recommended reaction was to remove non-crop vegetation to reduce interactions between wildlife and crops. Over time, removal of habitat has been shown to have no impact, or even increase the amount of wildlife in a production field due to the need for wildlife to find food, water and shelter. We must be careful of reducing complex questions to binary answers (good/bad) since those decisions can lead to poor unintended outcomes despite even the best of intentions. Risk-based decision-making and risk management require characterization of risk (e.g., pathogenic E.coli, Salmonella , heavy metals) in an environment, and then identifying the factors that can lead to changes in that risk. To achieve risk-based food safety management, a baseline understanding of the risk(s) is needed
Climate change is rapidly changing ecosystems worldwide, and there are increasing concerns about the long-term impacts that these changes may have on the stability, sustenance and growth of communities. Agriculture is accelerating efforts to understand and optimize practices to address changing conditions and ensure the security of a safe and nutritious food source. With rising temperatures, destabilized weather patterns and diminishing nonrenewable resources, the food supply chain must consider all factors when developing a food system aimed at long-term resilience. Overarching environmental pressures are nonselective and impact the entire ecosystem, including bacterial and viral pathogens contributing to human health risks. To be efficient and effective in building a resilient food supply chain, the complexities require a comprehensive and multidisciplinary approach that designs for and balances the needs of sustainability and food safety together. Efforts for food safety are currently aimed at developing a risk-based management system with the goal of continuous improvement leading to ongoing risk reduction to consumers. Sustainable Food Safety (SFS) prioritizes the interconnectedness of sustainability and food safety efforts to ensure optimal outcomes, leading to the goal of environmental and agricultural resiliency. To ensure both efforts are addressed efficiently, monitoring systems must be developed to characterize the risk from all agronomic, food safety and sustainability practices. With a measurement process and monitoring system to understand outcomes, growers can align the management of
23 Western Grower & Shipper | www.wga.com November | December 2024
Page 1 Page 2 Page 3 Page 4 Page 5 Page 6 Page 7 Page 8 Page 9 Page 10 Page 11 Page 12 Page 13 Page 14 Page 15 Page 16 Page 17 Page 18 Page 19 Page 20 Page 21 Page 22 Page 23 Page 24 Page 25 Page 26 Page 27 Page 28 Page 29 Page 30 Page 31 Page 32 Page 33 Page 34 Page 35 Page 36 Page 37 Page 38 Page 39 Page 40 Page 41 Page 42 Page 43 Page 44 Page 45 Page 46 Page 47 Page 48Made with FlippingBook - professional solution for displaying marketing and sales documents online