Love of the Game Fall, 2025 Premier Auction

5. 1895 Cap Anson “A Runaway Colt” Original Theater Advertising Poster (HOF)

The most popular player of his day, Cap Anson had visions of stage stardom as well, appearing in a theatrical production called A Runaway Colt . The play was written spe- cifically for Anson by leading playwright Charles Hoyt, and was performed on Broad- way as well as throughout New York State, Chicago, Duluth, and Minneapolis. The play was, by all accounts, a dismal failure, largely a comedic drama focusing on the impeccable character of Cap Anson (sic), climaxing with Anson hitting a game-winning home run. Though the play was written with Anson as its star, many professional players also joined the cast as the play made its way around the Northeast. Tim Keefe played the role of um- pire on Broadway when actual umpire Tim Hurst played the role as well (he called Anson out at home to end the play, resulting in bed- lam on the stage as Anson flew into a rage). In New York, Hughie Jennings, Willie Keeler, Joe Kelley, Arlie Latham, John McGraw and Wilbert Robinson joined the cast, Keeler trip- ping Anson as he rounded third. Eventually, the production succumbed to poor reviews. Presented here is an advertising poster for the production. Professionally matted and framed to a finished size of 35” x 28”, the piece is visually stunning, a large-format image of Anson set against a cream-colored background. The piece is in remarkable con- dition; a few areas of minor restoration have cleaned up some minor water staining and repaired some small tears, notably at the left above Anson’s right shoulder. The restoration work is well done and barely visible, helping preserve what is a gorgeous piece. A wonder- ful 19th Century advertising poster, a color- ful large-format piece that represents what is perhaps the earliest example of a professional athlete trying – however unsuccessfully – to “cross over” into the entertainment business. MINIMUM BID: $750

13

Made with FlippingBook Ebook Creator