44 | THOUGHT LEADERSHIP
Repositioning payroll: governance, risk and organisational value
P ayroll is a strategic, compliance-led profession that protects people and organisations, but only when it's properly governed, resourced and involved early in decision-making. The pay professions have evolved dramatically over the last few decades. I began my career in an era of yellow A3 sheets of paper and carbon-copy forms, all handwritten, where accuracy depended on a reliable Biro and a steady hand. Today, payroll operates in a world of real- time reporting, cloud-based systems and increasingly sophisticated automation. Yet despite this evolution, payroll remains one of the most misunderstood functions within organisations. One of the most common questions I encounter is where payroll actually sits. Is it part of human resources (HR), finance or compliance? Having worked as both an Accountant and a Payroll Manager, my view is that payroll sits at the intersection of all three and belongs fully to none of them. That lack of a clear home often explains why payroll is consulted late, fragmented across departments or treated as purely operational. If payroll is to move beyond this, organisations need to be more deliberate. In practice, this means establishing payroll as a recognised specialist function, with clear governance, defined escalation
routes and visible sponsorship at senior leadership level. Whether payroll reports through finance, HR or a shared services model matters less than ensuring it has direct access to decision-makers and is formally embedded in change, reward and system governance. In an in-house payroll team, from a finance perspective, payroll is typically viewed as a cost. It sits firmly within overheads, it doesn’t generate revenue and it must be controlled. That view isn’t wrong. However, it’s incomplete. Payroll actively protects organisations from financial risk. Incorrect pay leads to penalties, interest, retrospective corrections and reputational damage. Getting payroll right avoids all of that. Because payroll directly controls risk and cost, it needs to be involved early in decision-making, not consulted after decisions have already been announced. This requires more than goodwill. It requires payroll’s role to be clearly defined within governance structures, with explicit triggers for involvement in areas such as reward design, contractual change, system implementation and workforce planning. This is where payroll’s value to the finance function is often underestimated. Payroll data supports accurate forecasting, headcount planning, overtime analysis and cost modelling. In practical terms, this
might mean routine reporting on overtime spend by department, trend analysis highlighting when overtime becomes habitual or modelling the employer National Insurance impact of reward changes before they’re approved. For many organisations, the barrier isn’t insight but access. Payroll teams often hold the cleanest workforce data yet extracting it manually can be time- consuming. Investment in reporting tools, better system integration and shared dashboards between payroll and finance can turn existing data into usable insight without adding disproportionate workload. The same dynamic appears when payroll is viewed through an HR lens. HR teams focus on people, engagement and reward. Payroll translates those intentions into lawful, compliant outcomes. Issues rarely arise from ill intent. They arise because employment tax legislation is complex, highly technical and constantly evolving. I’ve seen enthusiastic discussions around vouchers or incentives framed as being ‘tax-free’, or salary sacrifice arrangements promised without understanding national minimum wage constraints. In these situations, payroll is often left explaining why an idea cannot proceed as planned. The solution isn’t blame, but shared understanding. Joint training, early collaboration and clearly
Made with FlippingBook - Online magazine maker