While the impact of anticipated actions cannot be yet known, the Duane Morris Wage & Hour Class Action Review is intended to not only to explain recent developments that have occurred, but also their importance on the challenges facing employers in 2024 and beyond.
In 2023, courts considered more motions for certification in FLSA matters than in any other substantive area. Overall, courts issued 183 rulings. Of these, 165 addressed first-stage motions for conditional certification of collective actions under 29 U.S.C. § 216(b), and 18 addressed second-stage motions for decertification of collective actions. Of the 167 rulings that courts issued on motions for conditional certification, 125 rulings favored plaintiffs, for a success rate of nearly 75%. These numbers are lower than the numbers observed in 2022, during which courts issued 236 rulings. Of these, 219 addressed first-stage motions for conditional certification of collective actions under 29 U.S.C. § 216(b), and 18 addressed second- stage motions for decertification of collective actions. Of the 219 rulings that courts issued on motions for conditional certification, 180 rulings favored plaintiffs, for a success rate of 82%. Such rate was in line with and slightly higher than the historic rate of success that plaintiffs have achieved with respect to such motions.
The decline in success rates in 2023 likely reflects the impact of courts in certain federal circuits more closely scrutinizing motions for conditional certification. Until recently, courts almost universally applied a two-step process to certification of FLSA collective actions. At the first stage, courts applied a lenient burden such that they required a plaintiff to make only a “modest factual showing” that he or she was similarly situated to others, and plaintiffs often met such burden by submitting declarations from a limited number of potential collective action members. At the second stage, courts conducted a more thorough examination of the evidence to determine whether in fact the plaintiff was similarly situated to those he or she sought to represent such that the matter should proceed to trial on a representative basis.
2
© Duane Morris LLP 2024
Wage & Hour Class And Collective Action Review – 2024
Made with FlippingBook - professional solution for displaying marketing and sales documents online