Annual Report 2021
Spine & Orthopaedic Trauma Epidemiological Database (SORTED)
SERT Institute
Contents
SORTED Royal North Shore Hospital
Wide distribution of this document is encouraged. This work is copyrighted. It may be reproduced in whole or in part for study or training purposes subject to the inclusion of an acknowledgement of the source. It may not be reproduced for commercial usage or sale. Reproduction for purposes other than those indicated above requires written permission from the Orthopaedic Surgery Department at
Foreword
4
Snapshot
5
Executive Summary
6
Ray Hollings Surgical Excellence Award
7
2021 Data Summary
8
Royal North Shore Hospital. Published November 2022
Patient characteristics
10
Case details
14
Trainee case load
16
Fracture classification
18
Adult fracture location
19
Paediatric fracture location
22
Spine surgery
23
Spinal cord injuries
25
Complications
26
Length of stay
27
Acknowledgements
28
Glossary
29
Foreword
SORTED 2021 Snapshot
Royal North Shore Hospital (RNSH) has a long and proud history of providing world-class healthcare service to the community. The SORTED project is a great example of how the spinal and orthopaedic trauma services within RNSH are striving to continue this high standard of care. Despite a challenging year due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the project maintained its momentum and continued to grow year-on-year. We are proud to present the second SORTED annual report, which is another great achievement of the project. The report details the progress of the project, as well as highlighting some of the next steps in our journey. Seeing the data in this way allows us to understand in more detail the types of injuries that we are treating. The project also brings a deeper appreciation of the effects of our treatment, and allows us to identify potential areas of improvement that will ultimately lead to improved patient care and outcomes. Chairman of the Department of Orthopaedics & Traumatic Surgery
Head of the Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, RNSH It is with pleasure that I present the 2021 Annual Report for the Spine and Orthopaedic Trauma Epidemiological Database (SORTED). The ongoing development of this database has been a big achievement for our department and it has gone from strength to strength in 2021. The project has already been successful in improving patient care, driving research and creating a culture of empowerment and engagement for the multidisciplinary teams involved in orthopaedic trauma patient care. The major highlight for this year was Dr Michael Symes being named a recipient of the inaugural Ray Hollings Surgical Excellence Award for SORTED. The funds received from this award will be used to roll out the next phase of SORTED, by purchasing iPads to collect data on patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs). I would like to express my gratitude and appreciation to the Data Analysis & Surgical Outcomes (DASO) Unit team for their expertise, contribution and involvement with SORTED.
2049
Total ortho-trauma surgeries A total of 2049 operations were captured from January–December 2021. The reporting period includes the continuing COVID-19 global pandemic. Of the 2049 operations, 1784 were for general orthopaedic cases and 269 were for spine surgeries.
1304 99.6%
Total fractures A total of 1304 fractures were treated surgically between January—December 2021.
Data compliance rate The data compliance rate was 99.6% excluding neurosurgery cases. There has been a 5.6% increase in the data compliance rate since 2020.
1911
Emergency surgeries In 2021, there were 1911 (93%) emergency surgeries and 138 (7%) elective surgeries.
Dr Andrew Ellis Head of Orthopaedic Surgery, RNSH
Professor Bill Walter Chairman of the Department of Orthopaedics & Traumatic Surgery
4
SORTED Annual Report 2021
SORTED Annual Report 2021
5
Executive Summary
Ray Hollings Surgical Excellence Award
Dr Michael Symes receives inaugural Ray Hollings Surgical Excellence Award On behalf of the RNSH Department of Orthopaedics and Trauma Surgery, Dr Michael Symes was named a recipient of the inaugural Ray Hollings Surgical Excellence Award in February, 2022. The award is named after Dr Ray Hollings who was a General Surgeon at RNSH for more than 60 years and was passionate about providing high quality patient care and supporting innovation and quality improvement activity across surgery. The RNSH Surgical Education Research & Training (SERT) Institute was proud to facilitate the inaugural Ray Hollings Surgical Excellence Award, in recognition of the contribution Dr Hollings has made to surgery across Northern Sydney Local Health District (NSLHD). The Award is to encourage and support consultant surgeons at RNSH to undertake quality improvement projects that drive innovation, and improve service delivery and patient care. The quality improvement project application submitted by Dr Michael Symes on behalf of the Department of Orthopaedics and Trauma Surgery was to continue the next phase of the SORTED. The database, which was established in 2020 with the help of the Data Analysis & Surgical Outcomes (DASO) Unit, has been successful in achieving its initial goals of improving patient care, driving research and creating a culture of empowerment and engagement for the multidisciplinary teams involved in orthopaedic trauma patient care. Key outcomes of the next stage of SORTED include transitioning and incorporating patient reported outcome measures (PROMs). To facilitate this, the award funds will be used to purchase iPads to collect PROMs data directly from patients.
This report provides an overview of the Royal North Shore Hospital (RNSH) Spine and Orthopaedic Trauma Epidemiological Database (SORTED) for 2021. Since commencing in February 2020, SORTED has had a considerable impact on improving the culture of research and use of data to drive improvements in patient outcomes within the RNSH Orthopaedic and Trauma departments. Data integrity is highly valued in our department and over the past 12 months we have seen a significant improvement in data accuracy and completeness. Compared to last year’s annual report which reported 7.0% missing or incorrectly entered data, the figure dropped to just 0.4% in 2021. During the reporting period from 1 January to 31 December 2021, a total of 2049 operations were entered into the database. Of these, 1780 were general orthopaedic cases (performed by 11 surgeons), and 269 were spine surgeries (performed by four surgeons). Two operations were entered as combined single-stage orthopaedic and spine surgeries. A highlight for the department was that SORTED received the Ray Hollings Surgical Excellence Award, providing a major boost for the project. The award will be used to roll out the next phase of SORTED, which will involve collecting data on patient reported outcome measures (PROMs).
• Establishing a six-month development and training period until a testing and trial period is ready mid-next year (including information on key steps, timeframes and project stakeholders).
The combination of PROMs and complication data will not only be valuable for research and publications, but ultimately in improving the quality of care for patients. Speaking at the Ray Hollings Surgical Excellence Award and Harry Cumberland Travelling Scholarship awards night, Dr Symes explained how the funds from the award would enable the Department of Orthopaedics and Trauma Surgery to continue the momentum of SORTED. “It’s going to accelerate the next phase of SORTED which involves the collection of PROMs, help us collect more in-depth complication data, as well as increase collaborative engagement across departments at RNSH such as Trauma and Burns and Plastics,” he said. “This award will also help us work towards our goal of expanding SORTED across the Northern Sydney Local Health District in the next five to ten years.” The Ray Hollings Surgical Excellence Award will be awarded each year by the SERT Institute, giving recipients the opportunity to receive up to $10,000 towards a quality improvement project at RNSH.
The next stage of SORTED will focus on:
• Collecting more detailed complications data and collaborating with other departments including Trauma, Burns, and Plastics to improve patient outcomes. • Training for junior medical doctors, nurses, allied health and non-medical staff to ensure high quality data capture across multiple points of care including in wards, clinics and operating rooms.
6
7
SORTED Annual Report 2021
SORTED Annual Report 2021
2021 Data Summary
Dr Michael Symes with Professor Bill Walter (left) and Professor Tom Hugh
Dr Michael Symes
8
9
SORTED Annual Report 2021
SORTED Annual Report 2021
Patient characteristics
Patient residence Figure 2 demonstrates that the majority (73.2%) of the 2049 patients in this cohort resided within NSLHD.
General orthopaedic cases
Total operations
Spine surgeries
Gender and age A total of 2049 patients were included for this reporting period. Figure 1 illustrates the distribution of male and female patients across each age group. Distribution was relatively even across all age groups, with the majority of cases performed on male patients (60.5%) when compared with female patients (39.5%).
Age and Gender
Female Male
202
174
171
142
134
127
126
122
120
112
105
102
90
70
69
63
62
58
8.9% 12.9% 10.0% 8.7% 9.6% 12.7% 11.5% 12.1% 13.6% <10 10-19 20-29 30-39 40-49 50-59 60-69 70-79 80+
Figure 1: Age and gender bands of all patients
Figure 2: Patient distribution across Local Health Districts
10
11
SORTED Annual Report 2021
SORTED Annual Report 2021
Rural and regional LHDs
Outside NSW
Insurance classification A high number of patients undergoing emergency surgery were privately insured at the time of their surgery. However, due to compulsory third party (CTP) insurance claims, the insurance status for several patients changed after surgery. Insurance Classification
Local Health District Percentage (%)
Local Health District Percentage (%)
Western NSW
2.9
Queensland
0.2
Deferred No Insurance Overseas DVA Work Cover Motor Vehicle Unknown Public Private
976
Hunter New England 1.6
Victoria
0.2
Australian Capital Territory
795
Mid North Coast
0.4
0.1
172
Southern NSW
0.1
Unknown Address
0.1
47
Murrumbidgee
0.1
South Australia
0.0
34
Table 1A: Percentage of patients in rural and regional LHDs
Table 1B: Percentage of patients who resided outside NSW
15
8
1 1
Figure 3: Insurance classification
12
13
SORTED Annual Report 2021
SORTED Annual Report 2021
Case Details
Consultant caseload Figure 4 shows that over two-thirds (67.3%) of emergency orthopaedic cases were shared among three consultants for this reporting period.
Notes: • During this period one orthopaedic surgeon retired and one was appointed Consultant Caseload
Trainee case load
506 500
373
At RNSH, junior medical staff have terms of variable durations, however, during this reporting period the majority of cases performed by trainees were conducted by two trainees who both completed a full 12-month clinical year in 2021. In the majority of cases, trainees performed the role of assistant for a greater number of cases than those in which they were primary operators, as shown in Table 2.
183
172
97
84 88
15 5 6
9 2
1 8 S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S7 S8 S9 S10 S11 S12 S13 S14 S15
Figure 4: Total number of cases per consultant
14
15
SORTED Annual Report 2021
SORTED Annual Report 2021
Position Trainee 1 Trainee 2 Trainee 3 Trainee 4 Trainee 5 Trainee 6 Trainee 7 Trainee 8 Trainee 9 Trainee 10 Trainee 11 Trainee 12 Trainee 13 Trainee 14 Trainee 15 Trainee 16 Trainee 17 Trainee 18 Trainee 19 Trainee 20 Trainee 21 Trainee 22 Trainee 23 Trainee 24 Trainee 25 Trainee 26 Trainee 27 Trainee 28 Trainee 29 Trainee 30 Trainee 31 Trainee 32
Operator
Assistant 1
Assistant 2
Assistant 3
Assistant 4
Mechanism of injury Falls-related injury was the most common mechanism of injury resulting in surgical cases reported here. Road-related and sports injuries also contributed significant portions to the overall burden of cases. A focus of data reporting in 2022 will be the burden of cases linked to road-related trauma (motor vehicles/pedestrians/cyclists). Several cases may have multiple mechanisms of injury entered and may appear multiple times in this data.
2
24
6 2 2
1 1
3
1
1
Mechanism of Injury
12
34
1 1 1
4
17
20 25
70
110
56.4% 13.9%
1061
Fall related trauma Other Traumatic wound Sport Cyclist trauma
6
6
261
1
35
24
2
1
6.7% 6.0% 5.4% 4.9% 3.8% 1.7% 1.2% 0.1%
126
9
106 129
35
3
97
12
113
1 1
24
4
1
101
1
92
MBA MVA Post-op complication Pedestrian Uber Eats/Menulog delivery driving
2
42 71 13
19
3
19
3 3
72
2
32
5
105
18
2
22
7
7
2
3 5 6 3
105
16
1
1
1
17 17
16 18 41
Figure 5: Mechanism of injury
1
2
1 1 1 1 1 1
64
5
79
9 4
1 1
4 5
2
3
154
20
1
1
10
10
2
4
8
139
54
6
1 1
1
Orthospine Fellow
64 42
7
Resident
3
18 16 20
3
Intern
1 1
4
Medical Student
11
12
Scrub nurse
1
1
1
Fellow - other
34
54
35
2
Table 2: Trainee caseload
16
17
SORTED Annual Report 2021
SORTED Annual Report 2021
Fracture Classification
Adult fracture location
Total fractures
A total of 962 adult fractures were treated in 2021. Figure 6 shows the case numbers and locations of all fractures in adult patients. More than three-quarters (76.1%) of adult fractures were pelvis/lower limb fractures with 23.9% being upper limb fractures. Fractures of the femur accounted for 30.7% of all adult fractures.
Adult Fracture Locations >100 81-100 61-80 41-60 21-40 1-20
Fractures are classified according to a modification of the Fracture and Dislocation Compendium – Combined Orthopaedic Trauma Association and AO Foundation Classification system – Journal of Orthopaedic Trauma – 2018 (see Appendix for further details and reference for this classification system). A total of 1304 fractures were treated surgically in this period. Of these, 770 (59.0%) were upper-limb fractures, 534 (41.0%) were pelvic and lower limb fractures. It should be noted that at RNSH, any fractures involving the distal radius and more distal to this are treated by a separate unit and this data is not reported here. A total of 70 (5.9%) fractures were classified as open; more detail on the Gustillo-Anderson grade and wound management of the open fractures is available but not presented in this report.
Upper-limb fractures
Clavicle: 70
Scapula: 6
Humerus: 78
Pelvic/lower-limb fractures
Ulna: 45
Radius: 31
Pelvic Ring: 26
Acetabulum: 19
Femur: 295
Patella: 15
Tibia: 159
Fibula: 113
Malleolus: 39
Foot: 66
Adult Fracture Locations >100 81-100 61-80 41-60 21-40 1-20
Figure 6: Case numbers and fracture locations for adult patients
18
19
SORTED Annual Report 2021
SORTED Annual Report 2021
Clavicle: 70
Scapula: 6
Adult fracture location - segment
Adult fracture location - segment
Fractures occurring at the proximal segment (AO/OTA – 31) of the femur were the most common fracture requiring surgical treatment in 2021. There were 235 fractures (79.7% of all femur fractures) in this location. Tibia/fibula fractures accounted for 28.3% of all adult fractures. The majority of these fractures (68.8%) occurred at the distal segment.
Humerus fractures were the most common upper limb fractures in adults, accounting for 8.1% of all adult fractures. The majority of these fractures (56.4%) occurred at the proximal segment. The majority of radius/ulna fractures (60.5%) were also on the proximal segment.
Humerus - 78
Femur - 295
Proximal
Proximal
56.4%
79.7%
44
235
Diaphyseal
Diaphyseal
14.2%
26.9%
42
21
Distal
Distal
6.1%
18
16.7%
13
Figure 9: Total humerus fractures by segment
Figure 7: Total femur fractures by segment
Radius/Ulna - 76
Tibia/Fibula - 272
Proximal
Proximal
60.5%
15.8%
46
43
Diaphyseal
Diaphyseal
15.4%
31.6%
42
24
Distal
Distal
68.8%
7.9%
187
6
Figure 8: Total tibia/fibula fractures by segment
Figure 10: Total radius/ulna fractures by segment
20
21
SORTED Annual Report 2021
SORTED Annual Report 2021
Spine surgery
Paediatric fracture location There were a total of 342 paediatric fractures in 2021. Figure 11 shows the fracture location for paediatric patients requiring surgery at RNSH. The vast majority (88.9%) are upper limb fractures in this population and many patients appear twice, reflecting the commonality of having both forearm bones fractured simultaneously. Paediatric Fracture Locations >100 81-100 61-80 41-60 21-40 1-20
There were 269 spine surgery cases entered into the database during this period, with 267 involving spine only and two additional cases that involved single-stage combined orthopaedic and spine surgery. Note, data is only reported for orthopaedic spine cases and is not inclusive of neurosurgical spine data.
Spine surgery cases
Clavicle: 1
Figures 12, 13 and 14 summarise aetiology of cases undergoing spine surgery and location of spine fractures. Classification is aligned with data collected in the Australian spine registry where possible (disc and degenerative disease). The four most common reasons for spine surgery were trauma, degenerative disease, disc-related pathology and tumour.
Humerus: 58
Aetiology of Spine Surgery Cases
Radius: 178
29.2% 28.2% 19.5%
81
Trauma Degenerative Disease Disc Tumour Infection Deformity Revision surgery Unclassified Spondylolisthesis Inflamation
Ulna: 67
78
54
8.3% 5.8% 2.5% 2.5% 2.2% 1.4% 0.4%
23
Femur: 4
16
7 7
6
4
Fibula: 4
Tibia: 24
1
Figure 12: Aetiology of spine surgery cases
Foot: 6
Adult Fracture Locations >100 81-100 61-80 41-60 21-40 1-20
Figure 11: Case numbers and fracture locations for paediatric patients
22
23
SORTED Annual Report 2021
SORTED Annual Report 2021
Clavicle: 70
Scapula: 6
Spinal cord injuries
Fracture Location for Spine Surgery Cases
Fracture location for spine surgery cases
35
27
19
A total of 46 spinal cord injuries were treated in this reporting period, as summarised in Table 3. More than half (52.2%) of spinal cord injuries were the most severe grade according to the American Spinal Cord Injury Association (ASIA) impairment scale. This data is not inclusive of spine injuries treated during the same period by the neurosurgical department. ASIA Category n
8
ASIA A: Complete, no motor or sensory function is preserved below the level of the injury, including the sacral segments S4 - S5. 9
Cervical
Thoracic
Lumbar
Spinopelvic
Figure 13: Fracture location for spine surgery cases Location for Tumour, Disc and Infection Aetiology
ASIA B: Incomplete Sensory, but not motor function is preserved below the neurological level of injury, and includes the sacral segments S4 - S5. 6
Location for tumour, disc and infection aetiology
ASIA C: Incomplete, motor function is preserved below the neurological level of injury, but more than half of the key muscles below the level have a muscle grade less than 3 (i.e. unable to move against gravity) 7 ASIA D: Incomplete, motor function is preserved below the neurological level of injury, and at least half the key muscles below the injury level have a muscle grade of 3 or more (i.e. joints can be moved against gravity) 24
Total
46
Table 3: Summary of spinal cord injuries in 2021
Cervical
Thoracic
Lumbar
Spinopelvic
Disc
6 5 2
3
44
3 2 0
Tumour Infection
16
4
2
13
Figure 14: Location for tumour, disc and infection aetiology
24
25
SORTED Annual Report 2021
SORTED Annual Report 2021
Complications
Length of stay
Figure 15 shows the number of complications by type of event. The most common complication reported was an unplanned return to theatre, occurring for 1.2% of total operations. Figure 16 shows the reason for the 24 cases of unplanned return to theatre; the majority of cases returned for revision of fixation (66.7%). Further details on complications is available but has not been published here. Morbidity and mortality data fields have been amended and aligned with the NSW Health reporting guidelines for surgical complications.
The median length of stay for general cases was 2 days (IQR: 1-7) and 8 days (IQR: 4-19) for spinal cases. The maximum length of stay for one patient was 218 days.
Length of Stay
Complications
General
1.2%
24
Unplanned return to theatre
0.1%
3
Superficial Infection
Spine
0.1%
2
Other
0
50
100
150
200
250
1
0.0%
Unplanned readmission
Length of Stay (Days)
Number of Complications / Total Operations
Figure 17: Length of stay
Figure 15: Number of complications by type of event
Unplanned return to theatre reason
66.7%
25.0%
4.2%4.2%
Revision of fixation Infection Dislocation Other
Figure 16: Unplanned return to theatre reason
26
27
SORTED Annual Report 2021
SORTED Annual Report 2021
Glossary
Acknowledgements
Abbreviation
Definition
Benjamin Cass Myles Coolican Consultants
Preet Bubra Codey Burton Registrars
Nursing Team
AO/OTA
AO Foundation/Orthopaedic Trauma Association
Preet Bubra Codey Burton
Andrew Cree Andrew Ellis Randolf Gray Nathan Hartin Joseph Isaacs Terence Moopanar Dimitri Papadimitriou
Donald Cawthorne Matthew Donaldson Cameron Handford
Donald Cawthorne Matthew Donaldson Cameron Handford
ASIA
American Spinal Cord Injury Association
CTP
Compulsory Third Party
Sachin Kher Denis Koong Sarah Nicholls Kurt Seagrave Joel Steiner
Sachin Kher Denis Koong Sarah Nicholls Kurt Seagrave Joel Steiner Kathy Chung Ewan Driver Kenneth Vuong Data Team
DASO
Data Analysis & Surgical Outcomes Unit
David Parker Stephen Ruff Sean Suttor Michael Symes Bill Walter Andrew Wines
IQR
Interquartile Range
SRMOs
LHD
Local Health District
Nicholas Coulshed Ibrahim Darwish Mitchel Fung Sahand Imani Brendan Miles Miranda Norquay JMOs / Interns
MBA
Motor Bicycle Accident
Fellows
Darren Krusi Administration Team
MVA
Motor Vehicle Accident
Yasser Alhaddab Johanna Elliot Carrie Lobb Peter Lorentzos Samuelt Mackenzie
NSLHD
Northern Sydney Local Health District
Report Design & Development
NSW
New South Wales
Daniel Antaw Jeremy Bishay Ryan Campbell Gareth Crouch Rhea Darbari Michael Duan Gabriel Gregory
Rajat Mittal Tofunmi Oni Shaan Patel
Nadine Chidiac Kathy Chung Timothy Pollicina
Paediatric
Patients aged 16 and below
PROM
Patient Reported Outcome Measures
Robery Piggott Ramsay Refaie Ramsay Refaie Ravi Rudraraju Andrew Sefton Majooran Sinnathurai Milos Spasojevic Dion Tsinas Jonathan Warnock Vout Weltman
REDCap
Research Electronic Data Capture - An online data collection platform to manage online surveys and databases
Christopher Harvey Mudith Jayasekara Breanna Johnson Mickey Kondo Luke McKinnon Sahan Nanayakkara Anita Niu Paulina Salamat David Shen David Wei Brent Whittaker Joshua Xu Fumi Yasutomi
RNSH
Royal North Shore Hospital
SERT
Surgical Education, Research and Training Institute
SORTED
Spine & Orthopaedic Trauma Epidemiological Database
28 SORTED Annual Report 2021
SORTED Annual Report 2021 28
29
SORTED Annual Report 2021
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
30
31
SORTED Annual Report 2021
SORTED Annual Report 2021
Northern Sydney Local Health District Royal North Shore Hospital Reserve Road St Leonards NSW 2065
Page 1 Page 2-3 Page 4-5 Page 6-7 Page 8-9 Page 10-11 Page 12-13 Page 14-15 Page 16-17 Page 18-19 Page 20-21 Page 22-23 Page 24-25 Page 26-27 Page 28-29 Page 30-31 Page 32Made with FlippingBook - professional solution for displaying marketing and sales documents online