Some weekends are about getting away. This one was about going deeper—into barrels, into proof, and into the kind of conversations that only happen when the right people are around the table. Our Syndicate weekend in Martinsburg, West Virginia had a lot of moving parts— skeet shooting, cigars, football, blind tastings—but the heartbeat of the trip was clear: Devil’s Due Distillery in Kearneysville. Friday: Where the Barrel Speaks We kicked off Friday with a few hours at Devil’s Due, about fifteen minutes off I-81 and roughly forty-five miles outside of D.C. The setting feels historic for a reason —you’re standing near the confluence of the Shenandoah and Potomac, in land shaped by farmers, frontiersmen, and a whole lot of American whiskey history. Owner Wiley McDade doesn’t give you a rehearsed speech. He gives you perspective. Devil’s Due opened in April 2021 with a hyper-local commitment: source grain inside the county whenever possible. Mash, ferment, distill, and age it all under one roof. No outsourcing. No shortcuts. If it’s in the bottle, it lived its entire life right there.
And then there’s the Whiskey Thief Experience.
BY BRIAN BAILIE The standout for many of us was the Twin Malt Bourbon—70% corn, 15% malted rye, 15% malted barley. The rye and barley were locally grown and hand-malted nearby, which isn’t common in bourbon production. That malt presence brought a depth you don’t typically find—chocolate, leather, a hint of roasted coffee, and a mouthfeel that felt almost oily in the best way. This isn’t a tasting room with polite half- ounce pours and a laminated flavor wheel. This is barrel-proof whiskey, pulled where it rests. Four distinct bourbons. No added water. No coloring. No smoothing for mass-market comfort. Proof ranged from the low 110s into the high 120s. And every one of them had identity.
It wasn’t trying to imitate Kentucky. It wasn’t chasing consistency. It was telling its own story.
And that’s the beauty of the Whiskey Thief format—you draw it yourself. You fill your own bottle at cask strength, single barrel. You label it. You leave knowing no one else has that exact bottle in that exact form.
“That Twin Malt didn’t drink like bourbon—it drank like a signature.”
Made with FlippingBook - PDF hosting