What distinguishes the current moment is that these pressures are not temporary disruptions layered onto an otherwise stable system. They reflect structural shifts reshaping how institutions operate, finance themselves, and define their value. Many institutions are now operating under business models that no longer align with their cost structures or revenue realities, requiring transformations that are difficult to execute within traditional governance frameworks (Rose and Large, 2021). Financial sustainability sits at the center of most board agendas. While stresses in the financial model are not new, they are becoming more visible and harder to offset, as demographic shifts, funding constraints, and market dynamics converge. Revenue models remain under strain as enrollment growth stalls or reverses, and net tuition revenue continues to erode even as sticker prices rise. The issue is less pricing and more realization: the growing delta between what institutions charge and what they collect. At the same time, costs, particularly personnel and aging physical plants, are accelerating. More than half of S&P Global’s rated private nonprofit colleges and universities ran operating deficits in 2024, up from the prior year, underscoring that these pressures are enduring rather than cyclical (S&P Global Ratings, 2025). Demographic and market forces compound that reality. Fall 2025 marked what many analysts describe as a high‑water point for traditional‑aged undergraduate enrollment, reflecting broader demographic trends that are expected to reshape enrollment patterns over time (Education Dynamics, 2025; National Center for Education Statistics, 2026). Modest enrollment gains at some institutions mask uneven market dynamics: enrollment growth at for-profit colleges alongside flat performance at many nonprofit private and regional public institutions, declining graduate enrollment, and reduced international student flows, particularly at the graduate level. Beyond these enrollment shifts, the demographic composition of prospective students is changing, requiring institutions to adapt recruitment strategies and support structures to serve increasingly diverse populations. These pressures are intensified by competitive escalation in facilities, athletics, and program offerings — investments that many institutions feel compelled to make to remain competitive in a shrinking market. Research-intensive institutions, while often maintaining more stable enrollment, face a different but equally destabilizing set of pressures: declining state appropriations and increasingly uncertain federal research funding, which together erode the financial foundation that has historically supported their missions. For boards, these trends unsettle long-standing assumptions about demand, market position, and institutional scale.
Boards spend more time responding to what arrives than shaping what matters.
06 | Boards of Trustees in Higher Education
Made with FlippingBook interactive PDF creator