One Small Step for Space Acquisition Doctrine
TABLE 4. TENET 1—3 AND QUESTION 7—9 ALIGNMENT Tenet 1 Tenet 2 Tenet 3 Question GPT Claude AVG GPT Claude AVG GPT Claude AVG Q7 80% 80% 80% Q8 60% 60% 60% Q9 58% 70% 64% Note. If ChatGPT or Claude noted a range, low end of percentage is displayed (e.g., 80-90% is displayed as 80%). Tenet 6 Question GPT Claude AVG GPT Claude AVG GPT Claude AVG Q10 85% 80% 83% Q11 70% 60% 65% Q12 71% 60% 66% Note. If ChatGPT or Claude noted a range, low end of percentage is displayed (e.g., 80-90% is displayed as 80%). TABLE 5. TENET 4—6 AND QUESTION 10—12 ALIGNMENT Tenet 4 Tenet 5 TABLE 6. TENET 7—9 AND QUESTION 13—15 ALIGNMENT Tenet 7 Tenet 8 Tenet 9 Question GPT Claude AVG GPT Claude AVG GPT Claude AVG Q13 70% 70% 70% Q14 70% 70% 70% Q15 80% 85% 83% Note. If ChatGPT or Claude noted a range, low end of percentage is displayed (e.g., 80-90% is displayed as 80%). Question Analysis The analysis that follows will begin with an overview of Questions 7 through 15, explaining how well they aligned with the 9 Tenets. Generally, survey responses were closely aligned with the essence of the tenets. Figure 14 depicts the alignment strength between each question- tenet pair based on the final assessment, which considered the initial quantitative evaluation and the manual qualitative (subjective) review of the survey responses. Every question was evaluated separately; however, this section will focus on edge cases to provide examples of high and moderate tenet alignment and low response sentiment.
164
Defense ARJ, Summer 2025, Vol. 32 No. 2: 132—193
Made with FlippingBook - Online Brochure Maker