MRMTC Tabletop Workshop Reference Documents

Initial Site-Specific De-Inventory Report for Big Rock Point Report No.: RPT-3014537-002

TABLE 5-15: WEIGHTING OF ROUTES AT MAXIMIZED METRIC VALUE (PART 3 OF 3)

Cumulative Population Dose along Route

Average Accident Frequency on Route

Immediacy of Ability to

Transit Duration per Conveyance and Consist

Security Vulnerability of Route

Metric Maximized:

Perform Transfer

Route

Rank

Result

Rank

Result

Rank

Result

Rank

Result

Rank

Result

1. HHT to Petoskey, MI – Clarion Ave Option 1 2. HHT to Petoskey, MI – Washington St Option 1 3. HHT to Petoskey, MI – Clarion Ave Option 2 4. HHT to Petoskey, MI – Washington St Option 2 5. HHT to Gaylord, MI – Option 1 6. HHT to Gaylord, MI – Option 2 7. Barge Route to Milwaukee, WI

1

15.26%

1

15.24%

1

15.24%

1

15.26%

1

15.24%

2

15.13%

2

15.11%

2

15.12%

2

15.13%

2

15.12%

3

14.68%

3

14.68%

3

14.67%

3

14.70%

3

14.69%

4

14.51%

4

14.52%

4

14.51%

4

14.53%

4

14.53%

6

13.43%

6

13.45%

6

13.53%

6

13.51%

6

13.47%

5

14.38%

5

14.33%

5

14.42%

5

14.38%

5

14.30%

7

12.60%

7

12.67%

7

12.50%

7

12.50%

7

12.67%

Page 5-39

Initial Site-Specific De-Inventory Report for Big Rock Point May 10, 2017

Made with FlippingBook - Online Brochure Maker