Back to Table of Contents
Another approach to the development of the self follows the work of Winnicott in Arnold Modell’s synthesis of Freudian drive theory, Winnicott, intersubjectivity and neuroscience. In this context, self is both an evolving contingent product and an enduring core, a process and a re-contextualized re-transcription of an experience. A major landmark in the theory of narcissism and the concept of ‘self’, Kohut’s school of Self Psychology places the development of the self and self-esteem at the center of psychoanalytic inquiry, articulating how the self forms through the internalization of experiences with caregivers. Kohut described how early empathic experiences give rise to internal ‘self-objects’ which help maintain a stable, robust sense of self that can tolerate life’s disappointments, and how a caregiver’s empathic failures and could give rise to narcissistic psychopathology. In his radical revision of psychoanalytic clinical practice, he suggested that the analyst needed to provide the self-object experiences the patient had not received in childhood. According to Harry Stack Sullivan, the author of the Interpersonal theory in psychiatry and the founder of Interpersonal Psychoanalysis, the ‘self’ is a collection of various reflected appraisals of others. His concept of self is essentially multiple as there is a somewhat different self for each distinct relationship. For Sullivan, shame, not guilt, is at the center of the human experience, as danger comes from an encounter with the other. Following Sullivan, contemporary interpersonalists and relational theorists like Bromberg, Stern, Mitchell and Levenson view the self as emerging in the interpersonal field. As the self is responding to the ever-shifting set of relational experiences, it is necessarily multiple. Bromberg views the mind as a collection of ‘self-states’ and the ‘unitary self’ as a necessary illusion. In his view, the particularly threatening self-states are deemed ‘not me’ experiences, which are subjected to dissociation. Psychopathology is determined by the degree of dissociation with the more extreme examples constituting psychotic experiences. Mitchell describes multiple self-states as akin to internalized self-object relationships. However, Mitchell postulates a distinct and valid sense of a ‘private self’ that serves to constitute a boundary between oneself and others. Levenson deems self and other as essentially inextricable. For him, ‘self’ is a process of the ongoing unfolding of a person’s adaptations to the challenges that the interpersonal world presents, and psychopathology is seen in the failures to confront such challenges. In clinical practice, any narrative about the self or the other is likely to be a somewhat defensively organized construction designed to exclude other more disturbing perspectives. In Europe , the psychoanalytic exploration of concept of Self originates mainly in post- Freudian psychoanalysis, in particular in the conceptualization of object relations, with developments related also to the psychoanalysis of children and adolescence. Some precursors of this concept may be identified both in Freud and in Melanie Klein, although not through the formulation of an explicit theory. Winnicott is the first author who has developed a complete and constantly updated theory of the Self, importantly including his conceptualizations of true self and false self. The traces of his thought have influenced the expansion of Self theories in different currents of European psychoanalysis: The English authors have favored the exploration of the Self within the object relations theories. Bollas developed in his own way
798
Made with FlippingBook - professional solution for displaying marketing and sales documents online