At first glance, the 401(k) seems like the obvious choice. But a deeper look reveals some major contrasts.
Traditional 401(k)
Alternative Strategy (IRC §7702 Permanent Life Insurance) Employer Match No match, but long-term compounding benefits can outweigh it. Tax Treatment Today Contributions are after-tax, but growth can be accessed tax-free later. Tax Treatment at Retirement Policy loans/distributions can be income-tax free under current law.
Employer Match Up to $1,500 per year — “free money”. Tax Treatment Today Contributions are pre-tax — saves $4,403 annually in taxes. Tax Treatment at Retirement 100% taxable as ordinary income. Rising future tax rates mean a smaller net paycheck. Market Risk 401(k) is exposed to market volatility. Losses can wipe out years of growth and destroy future cash flow. Liquidity & Access Early withdrawals before 59½ penalized and taxed. Estate Planning Subject to probate, estate taxes, and required minimum distributions (RMDs). Long-Term Certainty Dependent on future tax policy and market performance.
Market Risk Cash values are protected by contract. No market losses.
Liquidity & Access Liquidity and access at any age without penalties. Estate Planning Provides immediate tax-free death benefit plus living benefits. Avoids probate.
Long-Term Certainty Guarantees liquidity, legacy protection, and tax-free income options.
43
Made with FlippingBook. PDF to flipbook with ease