The Next Next Common Sense
Digital environments enable fundamentally different approaches that emphasize collaborative rather than competitive recognition. These ap- proaches acknowledge that complex challenges typically require diverse contributions rather than individual heroics and that recognition can expand rather than divide when properly designed. Consider how Stack Overflow transformed technical knowledge shar- ing through collaborative recognition. Their reputation system acknowl- edges both those who ask insightful questions and those who provide helpful answers. Points accumulate based on peer validation rather than managerial judgment. And reputation creates expanded capability (like moderation privileges) rather than zero-sum rewards. This system has enabled millions of collaborative knowledge exchanges that competitive recognition would likely have suppressed. Similar collaborative recognition approaches have emerged within organizational contexts. Bosch’s innovation platform allows employees to contribute to challenges outside their formal roles, receiving acknowl- edgment for valuable contributions regardless of their position in the hierarchy. Internal expertise directories at companies like Deloitte create visibility for specialized knowledge that transcends reporting structures. And peer recognition systems at organizations like Southwest Airlines enable appreciation to flow multidirectionally rather than exclusively from management. These collaborative approaches fundamentally transform territorial dynamics by creating what sociologist Carol Heimer calls “surplus ac- knowledgment”—recognition practices that generate more acknowledg- ment than would be available through competitive frameworks. When people trust that their contributions will receive appropriate acknowl- edgment without requiring territorial defense, collaboration naturally increases. This doesn’t mean eliminating all competitive elements from recogni- tion systems. Healthy competition can motivate performance and create productive tension when properly balanced with collaborative recogni- tion. The key lies in designing systems where competition occurs within
197
Made with FlippingBook. PDF to flipbook with ease