Michael Lissack
significant value. Rather than presenting complexity mastery as univer- sally superior in all circumstances, a more nuanced position recognizes the continuing relevance of established practices in specific contexts.
Domains of Continuing Traditional Relevance
Several organizational domains legitimately benefit from approaches that emphasize standardization, hierarchy, and detailed planning: Safety-critical operations require consistent execution of established procedures. Nuclear power plant operations, surgical procedures, and avi- ation safety protocols all benefit from standardized approaches with clear hierarchical oversight. As Karl Weick’s studies of high-reliability organi- zations demonstrate, even these environments require a balance between procedural discipline and adaptive response, but the balance typically favors standardization to prevent catastrophic failure. A healthcare organization implementing complexity-adapted ap- proaches throughout most operations deliberately maintained traditional command structures for specific safety-critical procedures, recognizing that in certain situations, the risks of improvisational approaches out- weigh potential benefits. This calibrated implementation acknowledges what safety expert Sidney Dekker calls “adaptive space within procedural boundaries”—maintaining core protocols while enabling appropriate re- sponse to unexpected variations. Regulatory compliance functions often require detailed documen- tation and consistent application of established standards. Financial insti- tutions implementing more adaptive approaches in customer experience and product development maintain traditional governance structures for compliance operations, recognizing the legitimate value of stability and consistency in these domains. Mature, stable operations with minimal environmental variabil- ity may genuinely benefit from efficiency optimization through traditional approaches. Manufacturing operations for established products with sta- ble demand patterns and limited technological change can appropriately
420
Made with FlippingBook. PDF to flipbook with ease