While not recognized as a formal legal precedent for future desegregation court cases, it did influence some of the legal strategies used in other landmark cases such as in the neighboring community of Orange County, where Mexican American families sued and won in the case of Mendez v. Westminster in 1946. Mendez would also influence Brown v. Board of Education in 1954.
School Segregation Guadalupe Ruiz Cuelles, a widow, mother of eight, and former teacher who resided in in Lemon Grove, California, was one of the leaders of the nation’s earliest and successful school desegregation cases in the country. However, the Ruiz family was deported before the court victory was announced. 8 The Ruiz family, like many of their neighbors, struggled against segregated schools, one of the most meaningful social movements originating in San Diego County. The 1931 case of Roberto Alvarez v. The Board of Trustees of the Lemon Grove School District was among one of the first in a series of successes against segregation in the U.S.
“However, the families originally asserted a broader claim that segregation and inferior learning conditions of non-white students were unacceptable and illegal.”
The court ruled in favor of the Mexican community because it had historically categorized Mexicans as “Caucasian.” Thefore, the ruling was outside the legal definition of segregation that was tech - nically limited to “Negro, Oriental or Native American” students. However, the families originally asserted a broader claim that segregation and inferior learning conditions of non-white students were unacceptable and illegal. The plaintiffs insisted on equal treatment under the law for Mexicans in Lemon Grove regardless of their immigration status and argued for the continuation of a multi-ethnic school environment that included Japanese, European and Mexican students before the district attempted to impose segregation. 9
The San Diego Union – Mar. 12, 1931 (Courtesy The San Diego Union-Tribune)
Top: 1924 Lemon Grove Grammar School • Bottom: the “La Caballeriza” building, once a segregated one-room classroom for Mexican students (Photos courtesy Lemon Grove Historical Society)
44
San Diego Latino Legacy – Timeline • Milestones • Stories
Chapter 2 – Rebuilding Lives, Against All Odds
45
Made with FlippingBook Ebook Creator