The Diminishing Case for Continued PPO Participation
There was a time when signing up with every PPO under the sun felt like a smart move.
They don’t wake up excited about networks.
Smart practices are leaning into this shift. They build brand equity. They invest in communication. They create membership plans and flexible payment options. They train their teams to speak confidently about value.
“More patients. Full chairs. We’ll make it up in volume.”
Sound familiar?
And the result?
Fast-forward to today, and that volume strategy looks more like a slow leak. PPOs have become dentistry’s version of quicksand. It feels stable at first. Stay too long, and you sink. The case for staying deep in PPO participation is getting weaker by the year. Reimbursement rates are flat or declining. Administrative friction keeps rising. And the only people consistently smiling are the insurance executives protecting their margins. Dentists once saw PPOs as a safety net. They filled open chair time and brought in new patients. But the truth is that most of those patients are loyal to the network, not to you. The original pitch from “Mr. PPO” was simple: Take the discount, and we’ll send you patients. That worked when fewer practices participated. Today, nearly everyone participates. When every practice accepts the same plan, no one stands out. The supposed competitive advantage disappears. And here’s something interesting. Many practices that step away from select PPOs discover that far fewer patients leave than expected. Some find that the patients who stay are more engaged, more appreciative, and more consistent. When your schedule is packed with heavily discounted patients, you’re not running a premium practice. You’re operating a discount model with high overhead.
Higher profit per patient. Less stress. Stronger loyalty.
The greatest risk isn’t leaving PPOs. The greater risk is staying in them until your margins are buried. PPOs rarely improve over time. Reimbursements tighten. Documentation demands increase. Payment timelines stretch. Audits multiply. Meanwhile, overhead rises. Morale dips. Investment capacity shrinks. You work harder and keep less. And that is not a growth strategy. It’s a fatigue strategy.
Leaving PPOs is not about flipping a switch. It is about building a bridge.
Start with your payer mix. Identify which plans produce volume but destroy profitability. Create a deliberate transition timeline. Communicate clearly with patients. Offer alternatives such as in-house membership plans, flexible payment options, and transparent explanations of your value. Then shift your positioning from “we accept your insurance” to “we provide care worth paying for.” That mindset shift alone changes everything. Every business decision moves you toward freedom or deeper into dependency. For years, PPOs sold dentists a story of safety. The modern market rewards something different: clarity, confidence, and value.
Let’s look at the math.
You discount fees by 30%–40%. Then layer in rising supply costs, payroll inflation, and the hidden time cost of claims, resubmissions, and pre- authorizations. What’s left? Margins so thin they barely justify the effort. You can’t outwork bad margins. You can’t scale an unprofitable model into a profitable one. But many dentists stay in PPOs because it feels safer than changing. Dan Kennedy would call that security-based decision-making, and it quietly kills growth. Here’s what the insurance companies don’t want emphasized: The power dynamic is shifting.
So, ask yourself: Are you running your practice, or is your PPO?
One of you is protecting profit margins. If it isn’t you, it may be time to change the script. Just do it strategically and deliberately. I would never suggest abandoning every PPO at once. But I would suggest examining whether the story you’ve been told still serves you.
Patients care about convenience. Technology. Comfort. Relationships. Experience.
Stan Kinder - (703) 298-1690 · 9
Made with FlippingBook Ebook Creator