4A — May 29 - June 11, 2015 — M id A tlantic

Real Estate Journal


M id A tlantic R eal E state J ournal By Scott C. Butler, Kaplin Stewart Is there a such thing as a “Simple Sublease”?

New Jersey Realty Advisory Group, LLC Commercial Valuation and Litigation Support Providing Professional Appraisal Services for Lenders, Property Owners, Government Agencies and the Legal Community of over 35 years

ExpEriEncE New Jersey Realty Advisory Group, LLC, is a full service Real Estate Appraisal Company servicing central and northern New Jersey. With over 35 years of experience in the real estate business, we perform a wide variety of services for lenders, attorneys, government agencies, corporations and private individuals. KnowlEdgE We know the market. We have worked extensively in Northern New Jersey and have appraised all types of properties from residential homes, large industrial and office buildings, to mom and pop investment properties. TrusT We specialize in commercial, retail, industrial, multi-family of all sizes, special purpose properties and the mom and pop buildings located throughout northeastern New Jersey. We can handle all of your appraisal needs, delivering USPAP-compliant reports for financing, equitable distribution, eminent domain, inheritance tax or partial interest purposes.


ccupants of commercial buildings often believe that drafting and nego-

be reviewed to identify whether the master landlord’s consent is required for the sublease and whether the master landlord has the right to terminate the master lease in response to a request for a sublease. In ad- dition, the master lease might provide that the master land- lord has the right to receive some or all of the sublease rents and the right to be re- imbursed for its costs related to reviewing any proposed sublease transaction. Subleases often include a general provision that the sub- tenant is to comply with all of the terms and conditions of the master lease as such provisions

relate to the subleased premis- es. This type of provision should be thoroughly evaluated since the master lease might include provisions that are specific to the sublandlord (such as spe- cific use restrictions) that are not applicable to the subtenant. Another issue when drafting and negotiating a sublease is whether the master landlord will grant “non-disturbance” to the subtenant in the event the master lease is terminated due to a default by the sub- landlord. From the subtenant’s perspective, if the subtenant is complying with the terms and conditions of the sublease, the subtenant should have the full right to use and occupy the subleased premises. From the master landlord’s perspective, if the sublandlord has defaulted under the master lease, the master landlord should have the right to exercise all of its rights under the master lease, including the right to terminate the master lease and all rights of occupancy thereunder (in- cluding the rights of occupancy under the sublease). As a compromise to this non- disturbance issue, the master landlord might allow the sub- tenant to cure the defaults of the sublandlord and, in the event of such cure, the rights of the subtenant under the sublease will be recognized. There are two major issues with this compromise. The first is that the subrent in the sublease may be less than the rent in the master lease and, therefore, the subtenant will be obligated to pay more than it bargained to have its sublease rights protected. The second is that the sublease space may be less than the space being leased under the master lease. As with the first issue, the subtenant will then have to pay rent for the entire space being leased under the master lease in order to cure the default and, as a result, the subtenant will again be paying more than it bargained in order to have its sublease rights protected. Due to the complex issues raised by a sublease, there is no such thing as a “simple sublease” and it is important to have the cooperation of the master landlord in order to fully protect the subtenant’s rights. Scott C. Butler is a principal of Kaplin Stewart and a mem- ber of the Real Estate Trans- actions and Corporate & Business LawDepartments. n

tiating a sub- lease with an existing ten- ant is a sim- ple process that is easier than drafting and negotiat- ing a direct lease with a

Scott C. Butler

Albert F. Chanese, SCGREAMAI | Jennifer Barany, SCGREA | Michael Nwose, SCRREA

landlord. A sublease, however, has many hidden traps that often complicate this process. Prior to drafting a sublease, the sublandlord’s lease with the master landlord (often called the “master lease”) must

2500 Plaza 5 Harborside Financial Center Jersey City, New Jersey 07311 (201) 499-7618

333 State Street Perth Amboy, New Jersey 08861 (732) 853-0271


Firmly Rooted in the Law and in the Community We are well grounded in every facet of real estate law, from acquisition to construction. We are committed to serving the needs of our clients and our communities.

Kaplin Stewart At t o rne y s a t Law

Contact: Scott C. Butler • sbutler@kaplaw.com 910 Harvest Drive, Blue Bell, PA 19422-0765 • 610-941-2560 • www.kaplaw.com Visit our Real Estate Blog: www.philadelphiarealestatelaw.com Other Offices: • Cherry Hill, NJ 856-675-1550 • Philadelphia, PA 215-567-3120

KS Ad 6X5.5 Tree Neil S.indd 1

1/29/15 11:42 AM

Made with FlippingBook - Online magazine maker