The California Trial Penalty

on a probation violation if they move forward with trial on a new case. They impose harsher punishments if client takes the stand at trial. * * * Prosecutors in our county routinely use the threat of increased penalties or additional charges or enhancements if the client won’t plead prior to Prelim or at PTC. Prosecutors who engage in this type of conduct are often more likely to do so against Defense Attorneys who challenge prosecutors more through motion work and aggressive defense tactics.

These findings show that defendants face significant pressure, from both prosecutors and judges, to accept plea offers to avoid the risk of increased sentences and additional charges or enhancements. DEFENSE COUNSEL PERSPECTIVE: CASE CHARACTERISTICS AND DEFENDANT DEMOGRAPHICS Surveyed defense counsel also provided instructive responses regarding the types of cases in which they were most likely to observe the trial penalty, and the extent to which the demographics of the accused may be associated with the trial penalty, showing a wide range of factors underlying the trial penalty. When asked whether the trial penalty varies by type of case, roughly 67% of respondents who responded to the question answered that it did. Respondents then had the opportunity to select up to two options from a list of case types — homicide cases, sex cases, gang cases, felony cases with available enhancements, assault cases, and others—in which a trial penalty was likely to be observed. The most regularly reported, statewide case types were “felony cases with available enhancements” (37.64%) followed by sex crime cases (28.83%).

In misdemeanor cases, roughly 54% of respondents reported a belief that prosecutors often “use direct or implied threats to encourage acceptance of offers.” Omitting missing responses, that number increased to roughly 80%. When asked what forms coercion takes, the most frequent responses were: exploding offers (26.95%), 45 increased sentences in future offers (24.56%), adding charges or enhancements (24.08%), and adding felony charges (18.90%). Respondents also provide examples of how judges apply coercive pressure on defendants to accept plea offers:

The judges make a point of telling the client his maximum sentence if he refuses to plea; indicates they are likely to give a higher sentence, and typically give higher sentences after trial. * * * Judges deny our request to release our clients during the pendency of a case, but accept a plea deal on the same client that allows them to get out that day. They threaten to max them out

21

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker