From NACDL and CACJ
About the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers and the NACDL Foundation for Criminal Justice | 6 |
About the California Attorneys for Criminal Justice | 6 |
Foreword | 7 |
Acknowledgments | 8 |
Executive Summary | 9 |
Introduction | 10 |
The Trial Penalty: Research and Background | 12 |
California’s Disappearing Trial | 15 |
Summary of Important California Sentencing Provisions | 16 |
Defining the Trial Penalty: Practitioner Experiences and Survey Results | 17 |
Survey and Interview Methodology | 17 |
Defense Counsel Perspective: Trial Penalty and Coercion | 18 |
Defense Counsel Perspective: Case Characteristics and Defendant Demographics | 21 |
Defense Counsel Perspective: Manifestation of the Trial Penalty & Policy Impacts | 23 |
Prosecutors’ Perspective: Prosecutor Survey Results | 27 |
Analysis of Data Collected from California Courts and District Attorneys | 33 |
Data Collection Efforts and Data Analysis Methodology | 34 |
Prevalence of Guilty Pleas Versus Trials | 37 |
Penal Code Analysis | 38 |
2015 San Francisco Office of the Public Defender Plea Offer and Trial Data Analysis | 44 |
Felony Trial Data Analysis | 44 |
Misdemeanor Trial Data Analysis | 48 |
Misdemeanor DUI Trial Penalty Cases | 49 |
Miscellaneous Misdemeanor Trial Penalty Cases | 50 |
Conclusion | 51 |
Principles and Findings | 53 |
Policy Recommendations | 54 |
Restore Respect for The Right to Trial | 54 |
Restore Respect for The Presumption of innocence | 54 |
Restore Judicial independence and Judicial Discretion to Fit the Punishment to The Crime | 54 |
Restore Effective Assistance of Counsel Before Plea Bargaining | 55 |
Restore Transparency and Accountability | 55 |
Endnotes | 56 |
Appendix 1: Defense Counsel Survey | 61 |
Appendix 2: Prosecutor Survey | 84 |
Appendix 3: Examples of Outreach Letters | 105 |
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker