The California Trial Penalty

From NACDL and CACJ


About the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers and the NACDL Foundation for Criminal Justice
6

About the California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
6

Foreword
7

Acknowledgments
8

Executive Summary
9

Introduction
10

The Trial Penalty: Research and Background
12

California’s Disappearing Trial
15

Summary of Important California Sentencing Provisions
16

Defining the Trial Penalty: Practitioner Experiences and Survey Results
17

Survey and Interview Methodology
17

Defense Counsel Perspective: Trial Penalty and Coercion
18

Defense Counsel Perspective: Case Characteristics and Defendant Demographics
21

Defense Counsel Perspective: Manifestation of the Trial Penalty & Policy Impacts
23

Prosecutors’ Perspective: Prosecutor Survey Results
27

Analysis of Data Collected from California Courts and District Attorneys
33

Data Collection Efforts and Data Analysis Methodology
34

Prevalence of Guilty Pleas Versus Trials
37

Penal Code Analysis
38

2015 San Francisco Office of the Public Defender Plea Offer and Trial Data Analysis
44

Felony Trial Data Analysis
44

Misdemeanor Trial Data Analysis
48

Misdemeanor DUI Trial Penalty Cases
49

Miscellaneous Misdemeanor Trial Penalty Cases
50

Conclusion
51

Principles and Findings
53

Policy Recommendations
54

Restore Respect for The Right to Trial
54

Restore Respect for The Presumption of innocence
54

Restore Judicial independence and Judicial Discretion to Fit the Punishment to The Crime
54

Restore Effective Assistance of Counsel Before Plea Bargaining
55

Restore Transparency and Accountability
55

Endnotes
56

Appendix 1: Defense Counsel Survey
61

Appendix 2: Prosecutor Survey
84

Appendix 3: Examples of Outreach Letters
105

www.nacdl.org

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker