Respondents were generally divided as to whether they perceived a disparity in the application of coercion with respect to plea offers in felony cases based on race, gender, ethnicity, or other unconstitutional
did perceive a disparity based on race, gender, ethnicity, or other unconstitutional classification, and a small majority (56.29%) answering that they did not. For misdemeanor cases, the county-by-county answer mirrored the statewide response more closely. The responses show a variety of factors underly the trial penalty, with certain case types and defendant characteristics (most notably a defendant’s custody status) more frequently resulting in the trial penalty manifesting for a defendant. DEFENSE COUNSEL PERSPECTIVE: MANIFESTATION OF THE TRIAL PENALTY & POLICY IMPACTS Responses to the survey suggest that the trial penalty takes a number of different forms and is driven by numerous factors. When asked the ways in which the trial penalty manifests, the most frequently selected answers were: significantly increased penalty if convicted after trial (72.75%), exploding plea offers (68.67%), adding new charges (64.16%), dramatically reduced plea offers (as opposed to dismissal) after revelation of a constitutional defect or other core problem (61.16%), and policy or practice of opposing an accused’s release on bail (56.65%). Respondents also cited a number of factors in the occurrence of the trial penalty. From a provided list of options, the most-cited factors were policies and practices of the prosecutors (87.27% of responses) and policies and practices of the Judge (67.95% of responses), as well as excessive caseloads (45.45% of responses), mandatory minimum sentences (45.23% of responses), financial considerations of the client (44.09% of responses), and judicial manipulation of pre-trial release (42.05% of responses). The latter factor is particularly worthy of future study. Since 2021, the California Supreme Court has repeatedly held that bail must be set an amount that is attainable in order to effectuate defendants’ right to release on bail under the Constitution of California. 46 The survey period for defense counsel, however, was in 2022 so these decisions may not be fully taken into account by respondents and, of course, opinions on law and practice may have changed in time.
classification. A slim majority (52.87%) said they did not, while 47.13% said they did.
For misdemeanor cases, respondents were similarly divided regarding perceived disparities, with a large minority of respondents (43.71%) answering that they
23
THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker