The California Trial Penalty

In addition to the quantitative responses above, respondents provided several specific examples of how the trial penalty manifests in their practice.

plea must include admission of strikes or other sentence enhancements (15%),

}

} plea must include waiver of appeal generally (15%),

Waiver of appeal is required in every negotiated disposition. Prosecutors love to offer strikes for probation. Then if we lose at trial, they ask for years of state prison, and judges often impose it. The judges do little to undercut the DAs when negotiating. Some judges almost never let people out, knowing it will resolve the case faster. * * * The most common is the threat of additional strikes, commonly through enhancements on existing charges. This is coupled with an exploding offer. “Accept today or I am making count X a strike.” * * * Client was made to stay away from family until he pled guilty; suffered great financial and emotional distress; committed suicide.

} plea must include admission to elements necessary for a future prosecution — prosecutor (15%).

plea must include waiver of appeal of denial of requests pursuant to California Penal Code § 1538.5 for return of seized property 47 or other constitutional issues (~10%),

}

plea must be entered before litigating some defense motion (~10%),

}

} plea must include admission to elements necessary for a future prosecution — judge (~10%).

The survey results show that the trial penalty manifests in a variety of ways (most frequently through significantly increased penalties if convicted after trial, exploding plea offers, addition of new charges, dramatically reduced plea offers, as opposed to dismissal, after revelation of a constitutional defect, and opposing an accused’s release on bail) and is driven by numerous factors (most notably the policies and practices of prosecutors and judges, excessive caseloads, mandatory minimum sentences, financial considerations of the defendant, and judicial manipulation of pre-trial release). Procedural Issues Respondents indicated that the plea offers often require foregoing or waiving fundamental procedural rights that would otherwise be available to defendants at trial or during pre-trial proceedings. A plurality of respondents reported conditions being imposed on the defense in felony cases. Defense counsel were asked, “Are prosecution offers conditioned on the defense foregoing discovery, refraining from bringing motions, or waiving appellate rights?” Roughly 44% responded “yes” in felony cases. Omitting missing responses, the percentage of yes responses increases to 54%. The most frequent responses from a provided list of conditions were:

Unlike in felony cases, a plurality of respondents, 39%, answered that pleas in misdemeanor proceedings were not often conditioned on waiving rights (beyond the right to trial), such as foregoing discovery, refraining from bringing motions, or waiving appellate rights. The most frequent responses from a provided list of conditions were:

} plea must include waiver of appeal generally (30%),

plea must be entered before litigating some defense motion (22%),

}

} plea must include waiver of appeal of denial of 1538.5 or other constitutional issues (21%), and

plea requires foregoing a non- criminal disposition (14%).

}

Cases can resolve at various stages of a proceeding. With respect to felony cases, respondents were asked: “At what stage of the proceedings

plea must be entered before preliminary examination (16%),

}

25

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker