The California Trial Penalty

One survey respondent highlighted that waiver of specific procedural and constitutional rights results in defendants losing fundamental rights and protections.

Tehama and Yolo county had one respondent. The survey included questions related to both felony prosecutions and misdemeanor prosecutions and covered topics regarding when plea offers are generally accepted by defendants, general policies and practices regarding plea offers and respondents’ views on the trial penalty. Resolution of Cases by Plea Prosecutors were asked to provide details as to the timing of when plea offers are accepted by defendants. For felony cases, the first significant time in the process where plea offers are generally accepted is following the plea on the complaint and prior to the preliminary hearing. Following that time, acceptance of plea offers by defendants are more evenly spread out. For misdemeanor cases, the two most common times for plea offers to be accepted are at the pre- trial conference before defense motions and the period after defense motions and before the trial readiness conference. More specifically, for felony cases that do not proceed to trial, over one‑third of prosecutor respondents indicated that cases were resolved by a guilty or no-contest plea prior to the preliminary hearing and before providing full discovery, with another one‑third of respondents indicating that cases were resolved after the trial readiness conference up to immediately before or during the trial. For misdemeanor cases that do not proceed to trial, over one‑third of respondents indicated that cases were resolved by a guilty or no-contest plea at or prior to the pre-trial conference and before motions, with nearly one‑half of respondents indicating that cases were resolved at or immediately after hearing on defense motions but before the trial readiness conference and one‑quarter of respondents indicating that cases were resolved at the trial readiness conference.

I don’t specifically have an issue with the “trial penalty” however my issue is when the negotiations hinge on the Defendant waiving due diligence (e.g. discovery review), 4th Amendment (1538.5 Mx), or other rights. Those are a greater abridgment of basic rights IMO. As a practical matter, there is a sentencing factor that rightly permits a greater sentence after trial.

The survey responses show that defendants, in accepting plea offers, are often required to forego or waive key procedural protections that might otherwise produce mitigating evidence that would benefit the defendant.

PROSECUTORS’ PERSPECTIVE: PROSECUTOR SURVEY RESULTS

Substantial efforts were also made to obtain prosecutors’ input related to their plea offer policies and the prosecutorial perspective on the existence and impact of the trial penalty. These included multiple letters to every district attorney listed in the California District Attorney’s Association to advise them of the project and to invite them to provide information on plea practices and policies in their district. Follow-up inquiries by telephone, message, and email were also made to solicit their perspective. A copy of the prosecutors’ survey is included in Appendix 2. In total, 25 prosecutors from eight of California’s 58 counties responded to the survey. 49 Of the eight counties where prosecutors responded, Orange county had 16 respondents, San Francisco county had three respondents, and each of Alpine, Los Angeles, San Benito, Siskiyou,

27

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker