The California Trial Penalty

Felony Trial Penalty Cases As noted above, a trial penalty occurred in eight SF OPD felony cases. The lead or most serious felony counts in these eight cases were: felony driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs; burglary; second degree burglary; first degree burglary; assault with a deadly weapon; oral copulation; assault with intent to commit felony (rape/sexual offense); and first degree murder. The least severe trial penalty among the eight cases involved sentences that were 1.5 times greater than the plea offers, which occurred in two burglary cases. In one of those cases, the pretrial plea offer was to 16 months in state prison and the defendant, after being convicted at trial, was sentenced to two years in state prison. In the other case the defendant was offered 32 months in state prison if they pled guilty and instead received a sentence of four years in state prison after being convicted of second degree burglary. Two felony cases led to trial penalties that were three times longer than the pretrial guilty plea offers. In one of those cases, the defendant was offered a plea with a maximum sentence of one year in the county jail but was convicted at trial of assault with a deadly weapon, after rejecting the plea offer, and was sentenced to three years in state prison. The second defendant, convicted of assault with intent to commit rape/sexual offense, was sentenced to 12 years in prison after their trial after they rejected a plea offer with a maximum sentence of four years in prison. In two cases, the courts imposed post-trial sentences that were four times the maximum jail time that the defendants faced if they accepted the pretrial plea offers. In one of those cases, the defendant was offered a plea with a maximum of 180 days in the county jail but, after rejecting the plea and being convicted of felony driving under the influence of drugs/alcohol, was sentenced to two years in state prison. Similarly, in the second case, a defendant charged with first degree burglary was offered a guilty plea to six months in the county jail but was sentenced, after trial, to two years in state prison.

The following chart depicts the six felony trial cases that demonstrated a trial penalty in the SF OPD data from 2015:

46

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker