NACDL CACJ Trial Penalty Survey
Introduction
The “trial penalty” refers to the substantial difference between the sentence offered in a pre-trial plea bargain versus the sentence an accused receives after trial. Many believe this penalty is so severe and pervasive that it has virtually eliminated the constitutional right to a trial by effectively coercing guilty pleas. The trial penalty has not only eliminated trials, it has also undermined other rights established in the Constitution that are essential to the adversarial process by requiring waivers of the rights guaranteed by the Fourth, Fifth and Sixth Amendments, including the right to seek pre- trial release, the right to discovery, the right to receive exculpatory material, the right to conduct a meaningful investigation, the right to challenge unlawful searches and seizures, the right to develop mitigation, and the right to appeal. Without these, police and prosecutorial misconduct go unchecked and innocent people get convicted in increasing numbers. For these reasons CACJ and NACDL have assembled a task force to assess the impact of the trial penalty in California and to identify causes and potential remedies. Our investigation builds on reports issued by the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (NACDL) and NYSACDL which studied the trial penalty on the federal level and in the state of New York. Our focus, however, is purely on the extent and impact of the trial penalty in California. Our objective is to issue a comprehensive report, along with recommendations to provide the basis for a broad reform movement.
To compile the necessary data, we need your help! Your responses to the following survey will form the basis for our findings and recommendations.
The survey is exclusively targeted to California state prosecutions (not federal). It consists of a total of 20 questions with sub-parts and is divided into two parts. Part I asks where you practice, the extent to which accused persons in your jurisdictions face a trial penalty, the various stages in the process at which the trial penalty comes into play, and whether systemic racism or discrimination or implicit bias play a part. [1] Part II asks you to identify a specific case or cases in which you believe the trial penalty was evident and to contribute a particularly illustrative example of resulting injustice. NOTE: In this questionnaire the term “trial penalty” is referring both to cases which went to trial and resulted in a sentence much more severe than the pre-trial offers, and cases where a plea was entered to avoid the potential for a much longer sentence if there was a conviction at trial.
[1] “Systemic racism or discrimination” as used here refers to racial, ethnic, gender, sexual orientation, religious, etc. characteristics of the accused that affect outcomes of cases, whether intentionally or unconsciously applied.
62
THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker