The California Trial Penalty

NACDL CACJ Trial Penalty Survey

MISDEMEANOR CASES

In this questionnaire the term “trial penalty” is referring both to cases which went to trial and resulted in a sentence much more severe than the pre-trial offers, and cases where a plea was entered to avoid the potential for a much longer sentence if there was a conviction at trial.

* 5a. At what stage of the proceedings do you most often resolve your cases by a guilty or no contest plea? (Check up to 2) At arraignment / bail setting At pre-trial conference before motions At or immediately after hearing on defense motions After motions and before TRC At the TRC N/A – I don’t handle misdemeanor cases

* 5b. Are the plea offers often conditioned on waiving rights (beyond the right to trial), such as foregoing discovery, refraining from bringing motions, or waiving appellate rights?

{ Yes { No

* 5c. Which of the following are fairly common conditions on pleas in your county? (Check all that apply) Plea must be entered at arraignment / bail setting Plea must be entered at first appearance after arraignment and bail setting Plea must be entered before litigating some defense motion - Sec. 1538.5, Pitchess, Discovery or enforcement of subpoenas duces tecum , etc.

Plea requires foregoing a non-criminal disposition (i.e. diversion or similar) Plea must include waiver of appeal of denial of 1538.5 or other constitutional issues Plea must include waiver of appeal generally

5d. Do prosecutors often use direct or implied threats to encourage acceptance of offers? { Yes { No

68

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker