FOREWORD
The Honorable LaDoris Hazzard Cordell Judge of the Superior Court, Santa Clara County, California (Ret.) Author of Her Honor: My Life on the Bench. . . What Works, What’s Broken, and How to Change It
In 2012, Associate Justice Anthony Kennedy lauded the practice of plea bargaining, writing for the court, “to note the prevalence of plea bargaining is not to criticize it. The potential to conserve valuable prosecutorial resources and for defendants to admit their crimes and receive more favorable terms at sentencing means that a plea agreement can benefit both parties. 1 Ah, Justice Kennedy, would that it were so and that the prevalence of pleas in the criminal justice system reflected a reality of fair-minded prosecutors and well- represented accused negotiating for mutual benefit. Unfortunately, my experience as a Superior Court trial judge, and this report, speak of a very different reality. For nearly 20 years (1982-2001), I was a California trial court judge who presided over hundreds, if not thousands of plea bargains, but only a handful of jury trials. My situation was not unique. Throughout the Golden State, trial judges dispose of the vast majority of criminal cases with guilty pleas, while knowing full well that many, if not most of those individuals who do not accept plea bargains and insist on going to trial, will pay a price—a trial penalty. The constitutional right to a jury trial in criminal prosecutions is guaranteed by the Sixth Amendment. Yet, I routinely saw prosecutors overcharge defendants only to promise to drop some charges in return for their
guilty pleas. And I heard judges declare to defendants that should they go to trial and be convicted, they would face harsher sentences than had they pled guilty. Sadly, the trial penalty is alive and well in California. As noted in the groundbreaking report, The California Trial Penalty: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack, recent research shows the significant use of pleas to resolve criminal cases, with approximately 97% of federal criminal convictions resulting from pleas, 2 and, in certain jurisdictions, resolving all of their criminal cases through pleas, 3 and that phenomena is mirrored in California where, in the most recent data from 2023/2024, just 2.2% of felony dispositions resulted from jury trials. The extensive use of pleas to resolve criminal cases undermines the important role that jury trials play in our criminal justice system. The California Attorneys for Criminal Justice Foundation (CACJ Foundation) and the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (NACDL), authors of The California Trial Penalty: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack, have given to policy makers, judges, prosecutors and defense attorneys an important, in- depth analysis of the trial penalty that has almost disappeared jury trials in California. As importantly, they have given us recommendations that will disappear the trial penalty entirely from our criminal legal system.
Missouri v. Frye , 566 U.S. 134 (2012).
1.
2. See Nat’l Ass’n of Crim. Def. Lawyers, The Trial Penalty: the Sixth Amendment Right to Trial on the Verge of Extinction and How to Save It. at 14 (2018). 3. See Am. Bar Ass’n, Crim. Just. Section, 2023 Plea Bargain Task Force Report (2023), at 6 (hereinafter “2023 Plea Bargain Task Force Report”).
7
THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker