The California Trial Penalty

NACDL CACJ Trial Penalty Survey

Part I

8. In what ways does the trial penalty manifest itself in your county? (Check all that apply) One time only offers at first appearance Exploding plea offers that expire immediately or on short notice Policy or practice of opposing an accused’s release on bail even when a non-custodial plea offer is made Dramatically reduced plea offers (as opposed to dismissal) after revelation of a constitutional defect

or other core problem with the prosecution Adding new charges if offer not accepted

Increasing severity of charges Waiver of the right to counsel Waiver of time to conduct a meaningful investigation Waiver of discovery Waiver of pretrial suppression motions Waiver of access to experts to develop mitigation Waiver of appeal Waiver of prospective claims of ineffective assistance Waiver of Public Records Act requests (PRAs) Significantly increased penalty if convicted after trial Local or common perceptions about how the trial penalty could be used against the accused Other (please describe)

72

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker