The California Trial Penalty

NACDL CACJ Trial Penalty Survey

Part II

Please identify one or more cases which you believe provide an example of the trial penalty at work, and what you believe to have been a substantial injustice arising from it. For example, it could be a case in which a client who was less culpable than one or more co-defendants, who went to trial and received a significantly greater sentence than the more culpable defendants. Or it could be a case in which the client turned down a plea offer with a minimal or modest sentence and then received a significantly greater sentence after trial. Conversely, it could a be case in which a client entered a guilty or no contest plea before full discovery was given to the attorney and/or investigation was completed or waived a particularly strong motion to suppress. Or it could be a case in which you believe a client who may have been innocent or less culpable nevertheless opted to plead guilty or no contest to increased charges rather than risk increased charges or penalties going forward.

Please provide up to three examples that you believe illustrate the injustice caused by the trial penalty with your answers to the following questions.

76

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker