NACDL CACJ Trial Penalty Survey California Trial Penalty Survey for Prosecutors
Introduction
Organizations nationally have studied and are studying the existence, and consequences, of the “trial penalty” in criminal prosecutions in federal courts and in specific state courts. The California Attorneys for Criminal Justice (CACJ) and the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (NACDL) have assembled a task force to assess whether there is a “trial penalty” in criminal prosecutions in state courts in California. NACDL, in fact, has been working with prosecutors and former prosecutors in numerous jurisdictions and with national prosecutor organizations to understand the issue in numerous jurisdictions, to identify factors that contribute to any trial penalty identified, and to propose potential joint remedies to alleviate the trial penalty. The phrase “trial penalty” refers to the substantial difference between the sentence offered in a pre- trial plea bargain versus the sentence an accused receives after trial. Many believe the trial penalty has led to a marked reduction in the exercise of the constitutional right to a trial by simultaneously incentivizing the acceptance of guilty pleas and raising the risks of going to trial. And many are concerned that the trial penalty can lead to unfair sentences, including disparities between defendants charged with similar or the same offenses and even circumstances in which more culpable defendants who plead guilty receive significantly shorter sentences than less culpable defendants who exercise their right to trial. The goal of the California Trial Penalty Project is to issue a comprehensive report analyzing the existence and impact of the trial penalty in California, including recommendations that provide the basis for reducing the negative consequences of the trial penalty. To compile the objective data, we hope to receive input from all parties within the criminal justice system in California, including and especially prosecutors. One source of data is surveys of defense counsel and prosecutors, exclusively targeted on California state prosecutions (not federal). The following survey consists of 16 questions, some with sub-parts, and is divided into two sections. Part I asks where you practice and asks a series of questions designed to identify whether and how the trial penalty occurs in your county. Part II asks you to identify up to three specific cases in which you believe the trial penalty was evident and asks you for additional information about those cases. Parts I and II are independent, meaning that you can complete Part I but not Part II if you prefer. Part I takes less than five (5) minutes to complete.
85
THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker