The California Trial Penalty

NACDL CACJ Trial Penalty Survey California Trial Penalty Survey for Prosecutors

FELONY CASES

* 2a. At what stage of the proceedings do you most often resolve your cases by a guilty or no contest plea, when cases do not proceed to trial? (Check up to 3) Before entry of not guilty plea at arraignment; After denial of release from custody; Post plea on the complaint but prior to the preliminary hearing; Before providing full discovery; At or immediately after the preliminary hearing; At the arraignment on the Information; Prior to dispositive motions (e.g. 995, 1538.5); At or immediately after defense motions but before Trial Readiness Conference (TRC); At TRC; Immediately before or during trial. Other (please describe)

* 2b. Does your office have a general policy (including one in which exceptions can be made on a case-by-case basis) that conditions plea offers in felony cases on not filing motions or agreeing to enter a plea before discovery? (In other words, do defendants have to give up litigation in order to take advantage of a favorable plea offer?)

{ Yes { No

* 2c. You indicated that your office does not have a general policy like the one described in (b) above; how often do you condition plea offers in felony cases on waiving rights or foregoing discovery or defense motions?

Rarely or Never

Sometimes

Frequently



87

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker