The California Trial Penalty

NACDL CACJ Trial Penalty Survey California Trial Penalty Survey for Prosecutors

MISDEMEANOR CASES

In this questionnaire, the phrase “trial penalty” refers to the substantial difference between the sentence offered in a pre-trial plea bargain versus the sentence an accused receives after trial.

* 3a. At what stage of the proceedings do you most often resolve your cases by a guilty or no contest plea, when cases do not proceed to trial? (Check up to 2) At arraignment / bail setting At pre-trial conference before motions At or immediately after hearing on defense motions After motions and before TRC At the TRC * 3b. Does your office have a general policy (including one in which exceptions can be made on a case-by-case basis) that conditions plea offers in misdemeanor cases on not filing motions or agreeing to enter a plea before discovery? (In other words, do defendants have to give up litigation in order to take advantage of a favorable plea offer?)

{ Yes { No

* 3c. You indicated that your office does not have a general policy like the one described in (b) above; how often do you condition plea offers in misdemeanor cases on waiving rights or foregoing discovery or defense motions?

Rarely or Never

Sometimes

Frequently



90

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker