EVALUATE MORE THAN PRICE Step 8: Build Your Provider Scorecard Before Proposals Arrive Price matters. But the lowest rate does not necessarily represent the lowest total transportation cost or the strongest operational fit. A transportation provider should also be evaluated on its ability to support your lanes, equipment, volume, service requirements, and communication expectations. SAMPLE PROVIDER EVALUATION SCORECARD Evaluation Category Suggested Weight Your Weight Pricing / Total Cost 30% Capacity & Lane Coverage 20% Service & Reliability 15% Communication & Support 10% Technology & Visibility 10% Equipment / Specialized Capabilities 5% Carrier Qualification / Risk Management 5% Implementation & Account Management 5% TOTAL 100% 100% Adjust the categories and weights based on what matters most to your operation.
QUESTIONS YOUR SCORECARD SHOULD ANSWER
Can this provider realistically support the lanes? Can it support the required equipment? Does it understand our freight? Can it absorb normal volume fluctuations? What happens when our primary plan fails? How will the provider communicate problems? Can we see where shipments are? Who manages our account? Who responds after hours? How are carriers qualified? How will performance be reported? Can the provider scale with our business?
Made with FlippingBook interactive PDF creator