A practical guide to organizing lane data, defining service requirements, evaluating transportation providers, and preparing your freight program for bid.
THE FREIGHT RFP TOOLKIT FOR SHIPPERS
A practical guide to organizing lane data, defining service requirements, evaluating transportation providers and preparing your freight program for bid.
• Build a Better Transportation Bid • Compare Providers More Effectively • Prepare for a Stronger Launch
Presented by
5130 Executive Blvd. • Fort Wayne, IN 46808 • 260.471.1877 • buchananlogistics.com
A BETTER FREIGHT RFP STARTS BEFORE THE RATES ARRIVE
Your RFP Should Help You Find the Right Transportation Fit; Not Just the Lowest Number A freight Request for Proposal (RFP) can help your business evaluate transportation costs, capacity, service and provider capabilities across recurring freight lanes. But the quality of the results depends heavily on the information provided to bidders. Incomplete lane data can force transportation providers to make assumptions. Unclear service expectations can produce proposals that are difficult to compare. And selecting providers based primarily on the lowest rate can create problems after implementation if the awarded provider cannot consistently support the freight. A stronger RFP gives prospective transportation providers a clear picture of: • Where your freight moves • How frequently it moves • What equipment it requires • How your facilities operate • What service levels matter • What accessorials commonly occur • How volumes fluctuate • How you expect shipments to be communicated and managed • How performance will be measured This toolkit will help you organize that information before your next transportation bid.
WHAT YOU’LL BUILD
By the end of this toolkit, you should have the information needed to create: F A clean lane file F Shipment-volume assumptions F Equipment requirements F Facility operating details F Accessorial requirements F Service expectations F Provider evaluation criteria F A bid comparison framework F An implementation plan F A final RFP readiness checklist
IS AN RFP THE RIGHT TOOL?
Not Every Transportation Need Requires a Formal Bid A freight RFP is most useful when you are evaluating an ongoing transportation program rather than pricing a single shipment.
AN RFP MAY MAKE SENSE IF YOUR BUSINESS IS:
F Rebidding recurring freight lanes F Reviewing existing transportation providers F Seeking additional carrier or brokerage capacity F Opening or closing facilities F Entering new markets F Adding suppliers or customers
F Changing transportation modes or equipment requirements F Building a routing guide F Looking for managed transportation support F Preparing for seasonal or anticipated volume changes
F Consolidating transportation vendors F Experiencing rapid shipment growth
AN RFP MAY NOT BE NECESSARY WHEN:
• You need pricing for one shipment • The freight does not repeat • The transportation requirement is temporary and very short-term
• The lanes or volumes are still unknown • You primarily need immediate spot- market capacity
In those situations, a shipment-specific rate request or project discussion may be more efficient than the process of building an RFP.
DEFINE THE OBJECTIVE FIRST
Before building the RFP, complete this statement:
“We are conducting this transportation RFP because…” ____________________________________________________________________________ Then identify your top priorities.
RANK THESE FROM 1–7
_____ Transportation cost _____ Capacity availability _____ Service reliability
_____ Communication _____ Shipment visibility
_____ Specialized capabilities _____ Administrative efficiency
Other priority:_ ______________________________________________________________ Knowing the objective will help you evaluate proposals against the outcome your business actually needs.
START WITH CLEAN LANE DATA
Step 1: Build the Foundation of Your RFP Your lane file is one of the most important parts of the freight bid. Transportation providers need enough detail to understand where freight moves, how often it moves and what operating conditions exist at each end of the lane. At minimum, consider providing: • Origin city
• Destination ZIP/postal code • Equipment type • Estimated shipment frequency • Estimated annual volume
• Average weight • Commodity
• Origin state/province • Origin ZIP/postal code • Destination city • Destination state/province
• Pickup requirements • Delivery requirements
SAMPLE LANE FILE
Average Weight
Shipments Per Year
Lane
Origin
Destination Equipment
001 002 003 004
IMPROVE THE DATA WHEN POSSIBLE
A more detailed lane file may also include: • Weekly shipment frequency • Monthly shipment frequency • Historical shipment count • Minimum and maximum weight
• Current rate, if you choose to disclose it • Requested pricing structure • Pickup days • Delivery days • Transit-time expectations • Facility hours
• Typical pallet count • Typical dimensions • Miles • Current mode • Incumbent transportation provider
• Appointment requirements • Drop-trailer requirements • Special instructions
QUICK CHECK
F Origin and destination ZIP/postal codes are included F Lane directions clearly identified F Equipment requirements included
F Volume estimates included F Weight information included F Facility requirements included F Historical data reviewed for errors
SHOW HOW THE FREIGHT REALLY MOVES
Step 2: Define Volume and Seasonality Annual shipment totals can be misleading. Ð A lane that moves 104 times per year could mean approximately two shipments every week. Ð Or it could mean 80 shipments during three peak months and only 24 shipments during the rest of the year. Those are very different capacity requirements. Whenever possible, show providers how your freight actually moves.
VOLUME PROFILE
Approximate annual shipments: _____________________________________ Average shipments per week: _____________________________________ Peak shipments per week: _____________________________________
Lowest-volume period: _____________________________________ Highest-volume period: _____________________________________
DOES VOLUME CHANGE DUE TO:
F Seasonality F Promotions F Harvest cycles F Customer demand
F Holidays F Weather F Project schedules F Construction schedules
F Production schedules F End-of-month activity F End-of-quarter activity F Other:________________
PROVIDE REALISTIC VOLUMES
Avoid presenting aspirational volume as guaranteed freight. If volume is uncertain, describe it appropriately: Committed: Freight you reasonably expect to tender. Forecast: Freight anticipated based on current projections. Potential: Freight that may become available, but should not be treated as committed volume or expected freight. Clear volume assumptions help transportation providers make more realistic capacity and pricing decisions.
DEFINE THE FREIGHT AND EQUIPMENT
Tell Providers What They Will Actually Be Moving Different freight can require different equipment, handling and operating procedures. For each lane or freight category, identify the transportation requirements that matter.
EQUIPMENT REQUIREMENTS
Check all that may apply: F Dry van F Refrigerated / temperature-controlled F Flatbed
F Specialized equipment F Heavy haul F Expedited F Team service F LTL F Drop trailer
F Step deck / drop deck F Conestoga / curtainside F Removable gooseneck / RGN
F Other: _______________________________________________________________
FREIGHT PROFILE
Primary commodity: _ _________________________________________________________ Average shipment weight:_____________________________________________________ Maximum expected weight:____________________________________________________ Typical dimensions, if relevant:_________________________________________________ Typical pallet count:_ _________________________________________________________ Freight value considerations:___________________________________________________
SPECIAL REQUIREMENTS
F Tarping F Strapping / securement F Edge protection
F Crane / rigger coordination F Oversized / overweight
F Permits F Escorts
F Temperature range F Seal requirements F Driver assist F Liftgate F Jobsite delivery
F High-value procedures F HAZMAT requirements F Cross-border transportation F Other:_ __________________________
DON’T MAKE BIDDERS GUESS
If a requirement materially affects equipment, time, risk or cost, disclose it in the RFP. The goal is not simply to generate an attractive bid. The goal is to generate a bid that can actually work when freight begins moving.
DOCUMENT HOW YOUR FACILITIES OPERATE
Step 4: Give Providers the Operating Details Transportation performance is affected by what happens at pickup and delivery. Facility information helps bidders understand scheduling requirements and identify potential operational constraints before pricing the freight.
ORIGIN FACILITY
Facility name: _________________________ Location: _____________________________ Shipping hours: _______________________ Appointment required? F Yes F No Drop trailer available/required? F Yes F No
Typical loading time: _ _________________ Weekend loading available? F Yes F No After-hours loading available? F Yes F No Driver check-in procedure: _____________________________________ Weekend receiving available? F Yes F No After-hours receiving available? F Yes F No Driver check-in procedure: _____________________________________
DESTINATION FACILITY
Facility name: _________________________ Location: _____________________________ Receiving hours: _ _____________________ Appointment required? F Yes F No Typical unloading time: _ _______________
IDENTIFY KNOWN CONSTRAINTS
Narrow appointment windows F First-come, first-served receiving
F Driver PPE requirements F Restricted site access F Driver unload / assist F Multiple stops F No overnight parking
F Limited dock availability F Extended loading times F Extended unloading times F Jobsite conditions
F Other: _ _________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ The more accurately you describe operating conditions, the easier it is to compare bids on an equivalent basis.
IDENTIFY ACCESSORIALS BEFORE THEY BECOME SURPRISES
Step 5: Look Beyond the Linehaul Rate Freight cost is not always limited to the base transportation rate. Accessorial charges can become a meaningful portion of transportation spend when operational requirements are not clearly identified. Review your freight history and identify which additional charges occur regularly.
COMMON ITEMS TO ADDRESS
F Detention F Layover F Truck ordered not used F Stop-off charges F Driver assist F Lumper charges F Liftgate F Permits F Escorts F Border-related services F Other: ____________________________________________________________________ F Tarping F Specialized securement F Expedited service F Team service F Reconsignment F Redelivery F Storage F Limited-access delivery
ASK FOR CONSISTENT PRICING
Your RFP should clearly state how you want charges presented. For example:
Linehaul: ____________________________________________________________________ Fuel surcharge: _ _____________________________________________________________ Detention: _ _________________________________________________________________ Layover: _ ___________________________________________________________________ Stop charge: _________________________________________________________________ Truck ordered not used: _______________________________________________________ Other recurring accessorial: _ __________________________________________________ Using a standard response format makes proposals easier to compare and reduces the chance that an attractive base rate hides higher total transportation costs.
DEFINE THE SERVICE EXPECTATIONS Step 6: Decide What Good Service Looks Like Before You Award the Freight Transportation providers cannot be evaluated fairly if service expectations are undefined. Document the level of performance your organization expects.
SERVICE REQUIREMENTS: TENDERING
How will freight be tendered? F Email F Customer portal F TMS F EDI F API / integration F Other: ____________________________ Expected tender response time: ________________________________________________
SERVICE REQUIREMENTS: TRACKING AND VISIBILITY
How frequently should shipment status be available? F At pickup F In transit F At delivery F At predefined milestones F On demand
F Continuous/technology-enabled tracking where available
What events require proactive notification? F Late pickup F Late delivery risk F Breakdown
F Appointment issue F Accessorial event F OS&D issue F Other: ____________________________
F Weather delay F Rejected freight
COMMUNICATION
Primary business-hours contact required? F Yes F No After-hours support required? F Yes F No Weekend support required? F Yes F No
Escalation process required? F Yes F No Regular business reviews required? F Weekly
F No F Optional
F Monthly F Quarterly
CHOOSE THE KPIs BEFORE THE BID
Step 7: Determine How Performance Will Be Measured If transportation providers will be held accountable after implementation, the measurement criteria should be clear before the freight is awarded. Potential transportation KPIs include:
ON-TIME PICKUP
Define what counts as on time: _________________________________________________
ON-TIME DELIVERY
Define what counts as on time: _________________________________________________
TENDER ACCEPTANCE
Target: ______________________________________________________________________
TRACKING COMPLIANCE
Target: ______________________________________________________________________
CLAIMS / DAMAGE PERFORMANCE
Target: ______________________________________________________________________
RESPONSE TIME
Target: ______________________________________________________________________
INVOICE ACCURACY
Target: ______________________________________________________________________
ADDITIONAL KPI:
Target: ______________________________________________________________________
DEFINE THE RULES
A KPI is only useful when everyone understands how it is calculated. For each metric, establish: • Data source • Measurement period • Exclusions • Target performance • Reporting frequency • Escalation process
• Corrective-action expectations
This reduces disagreements after implementation.
EVALUATE MORE THAN PRICE Step 8: Build Your Provider Scorecard Before Proposals Arrive Price matters. But the lowest rate does not necessarily represent the lowest total transportation cost or the strongest operational fit. A transportation provider should also be evaluated on its ability to support your lanes, equipment, volume, service requirements, and communication expectations. SAMPLE PROVIDER EVALUATION SCORECARD Evaluation Category Suggested Weight Your Weight Pricing / Total Cost 30% Capacity & Lane Coverage 20% Service & Reliability 15% Communication & Support 10% Technology & Visibility 10% Equipment / Specialized Capabilities 5% Carrier Qualification / Risk Management 5% Implementation & Account Management 5% TOTAL 100% 100% Adjust the categories and weights based on what matters most to your operation.
QUESTIONS YOUR SCORECARD SHOULD ANSWER
Can this provider realistically support the lanes? Can it support the required equipment? Does it understand our freight? Can it absorb normal volume fluctuations? What happens when our primary plan fails? How will the provider communicate problems? Can we see where shipments are? Who manages our account? Who responds after hours? How are carriers qualified? How will performance be reported? Can the provider scale with our business?
QUESTIONS TO ASK EVERY TRANSPORTATION PROVIDER Use Consistent Questions to Make Proposals Easier to Compare Include questions that uncover how the provider will actually support your freight.
CAPACITY
1. Describe your ability to support the lanes and equipment included in this RFP. 2. How do you source additional capacity when normal market conditions change? 3. How would you handle unexpected volume increases?
OPERATIONS
4. Who will manage our day-to-day freight? 5. What support is available outside normal business hours? 6. Describe your escalation process when a shipment is at risk.
CARRIER MANAGEMENT
7. How are motor carriers evaluated and qualified before being assigned freight? 8. How do you vet a carrier is appropriate for a particular shipment or lane?
VISIBILITY
9. How are shipments tracked? 10. What shipment information can our team access or receive?
PERFORMANCE
11. What performance reporting can you provide? 12. How are recurring service issues reviewed and corrected?
IMPLEMENTATION
13. Describe your implementation process following an award. 14. What information will you need from our organization before launch?
COMPARE THE REAL COST OF THE PROPOSAL
Step 9: Normalize the Bids Before Making a Decision Transportation proposals may use different assumptions. Before comparing providers, verify that rates are based on the same:
• Lane definition • Equipment type • Shipment volume
• Weight • Transit expectation • Fuel methodology
• Accessorial structure • Facility requirements • Service expectations
BID REVIEW QUESTIONS
For each provider, ask: F Did the provider bid every requested lane? F Are any rates conditional? F Are minimum-volume commitments required by the provider? F Are capacity commitments defined? F Is fuel included or separate? F Are accessorial charges included?
F Are rates valid for the same period? F Are there seasonal restrictions? F Are there equipment limitations? F Did the provider identify any assumptions? F Did the provider identify lanes it does not consider a strong fit?
That final question can be especially useful. A provider willing to identify where it is not the best fit may give you a more realistic picture of where it can perform well.
DON’T AWARD A RATE YOU CAN’T OPERATE
A rate only creates value when capacity and service actually materialize. Before awarding freight, ask: “Can this provider consistently execute the transportation requirement at the proposed terms?”
BUILD A SMARTER AWARD STRATEGY
Step 10: Decide How Freight Will Be Allocated An RFP does not necessarily need to produce one winner. Many transportation programs use primary, secondary, and backup providers. POSSIBLE AWARD STRUCTURE Primary provider: Receives the first opportunity to accept freight. Secondary provider: Supports additional volume or freight declined by the primary provider or to adjust for short term increases. Backup / spot provider: Provides support when contracted capacity is unavailable or transportation conditions change.
CONSIDER EACH LANE INDIVIDUALLY
A provider that performs well on one region or equipment type may not be the strongest choice everywhere. Awards can be based on: • Individual lanes • Geographic regions • Equipment types • Facilities • Freight categories • Percentage allocations • Project requirements
AWARD WORKSHEET
Lane / Group: ________________________________________________________________ Primary: _ ___________________________________________________________________ Secondary: __________________________________________________________________ Backup: _____________________________________________________________________ Reason for award: ____________________________________________________________ Expected volume allocation: ___________________________________________________
DON’T STOP AT THE AWARD
Step 11: Prepare for Implementation An RFP can look successful on paper and still struggle during launch. Before the first shipment moves, make sure everyone understands how the new transportation program will operate.
IMPLEMENTATION CHECKLIST
Commercial F Final rates approved F Fuel schedule confirmed
Operations F Awarded lanes communicated F Routing guide updated F Facility contacts provided F Pickup instructions provided F Delivery instructions provided
F Accessorial schedule confirmed F Rate effective dates documented F Payment terms confirmed Performance F KPIs finalized F Reporting cadence finalized F First business review scheduled F Corrective-action process defined Communication F Primary contacts exchanged F After-hours contacts exchanged F Escalation process established F Status-update requirements confirmed F Exception-reporting process confirmed
F Equipment requirements documented F Appointment procedures documented F Special freight requirements documented Technology
F Tender method tested F Tracking process tested F Portal access established F EDI/API/TMS integrations tested (if applicable) F Reporting format agreed upon
THE FREIGHT RFP READINESS CHECKLIST
Are You Ready to Send the Bid? Before distributing your freight RFP, confirm that you can check the following boxes. OBJECTIVES
F Purpose of the RFP is clearly defined F Business priorities are ranked
F Scope of the bid is clearly defined F Origins and destinations verified
LANE DATA
F ZIP/postal codes included F Shipment volumes included F Equipment requirements included
F Weight information included F Lane directions identified F Facility hours included
OPERATIONS
F Appointment requirements included F Loading/unloading requirements included F Special handling requirements included
F Seasonal patterns included F Accessorial requirements identified
SERVICE
F Tracking expectations defined F Communication requirements defined F After-hours expectations defined
F Escalation requirements defined F KPIs defined F Requested pricing format standardized
PRICING
F Fuel methodology identified F Accessorial pricing requested
F Rate validity period defined F Provider questions finalized
EVALUATION
F Evaluation criteria established F Scorecard weights agreed upon
F Decision-makers identified F Target award date established
IMPLEMENTATION
F Target launch date established
F Implementation requirements outlined
YOUR FREIGHT RFP PLANNING WORKSHEET
Use This Page to Define Your Program Before the Bid Company: ___________________________________________________________________ Primary RFP contact: _ ________________________________________________________ RFP issue date: _______________________________________________________________ Questions due: _______________________________________________________________ Proposal due date: _ __________________________________________________________ Expected award date: _________________________________________________________ Expected implementation date: ________________________________________________ PROGRAM PROFILE Approximate annual shipments: _ ______________________________________________ Number of lanes: _____________________________________________________________ Number of facilities: __________________________________________________________ Primary equipment types: _____________________________________________________ Primary transportation modes: _ _______________________________________________ Primary geographic markets: _ _________________________________________________ Seasonal peaks: ______________________________________________________________
TOP THREE BUSINESS PRIORITIES
1. _________________________________________________________________________ 2. _________________________________________________________________________ 3. _________________________________________________________________________
BIGGEST CURRENT TRANSPORTATION CHALLENGES
F Capacity F Cost F Service consistency F Visibility F Communication F Claims / damages
F Specialized equipment F Seasonal coverage
F Administrative workload F Appointment performance F Provider consolidation F Other: ________________________
WHAT WOULD MAKE THIS RFP SUCCESSFUL?
____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________
BEFORE YOU SEND THE RFP: FIVE QUESTIONS WORTH ASKING 1. Is Our Data Accurate? Incorrect lane, volume or equipment data can undermine the entire bid. 2. Are We Asking Providers To Price The Same Thing? Standardize the response structure so bids can be compared fairly. 3. Have We Disclosed The Operational Details That Affect Cost? Appointments, detention patterns, special handling and facility limitations matter. 4. Are We Evaluating Execution — Or Just The Rate? Capacity, communication and service should be considered alongside price. 5. Do We Have A Plan For What Happens After The Award? The RFP isn’t finished when the spreadsheet says “winner.” Implementation is where the transportation strategy becomes an operating process. NEED A SECOND SET OF EYES ON YOUR FREIGHT PROGRAM? Preparing an RFP, Rebid or Transportation Review? Before you distribute your bid, Buchanan Logistics can review your freight requirements and discuss where our transportation capabilities may fit your program. Come Prepared With: • Your lane file • Estimated shipment volumes • Equipment requirements • Facility requirements • Service expectations • Target bid and implementation timeline Buchanan Logistics supports businesses with transportation capacity for: • Full truckload • Less-than-truckload
• Heavy haul • Specialized freight • Expedited transportation • Project freight • Cross-border transportation • Managed logistics
• Dry van • Flatbed
• Step deck / drop deck • Conestoga / curtainside • Removable gooseneck
HAVE AN RFP OR LANE FILE READY?
Share your transportation requirements with Buchanan Logistics. Our team can review the opportunity, identify the lanes and freight requirements that align with our capabilities, and discuss how Buchanan may fit into your transportation strategy.
ABOUT BUCHANAN LOGISTICS Transportation Support Built Around Your Freight Program
Buchanan Logistics, Inc. is a third-party logistics and freight brokerage provider helping businesses coordinate transportation throughout the United States, Canada and Mexico. Our logistics professionals work with shippers to understand freight requirements, identify qualified transportation capacity, coordinate shipment details, monitor active freight and communicate throughout the transportation process. Buchanan can support transportation needs ranging from an individual shipment or recurring lane to specialized projects and managed transportation programs.
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
• Buchanan Logistics Freight Capabilities: www.buchananlogistics.com/freight-capabilities • Freight Freight RFP Guide for Shippers: www.buchananlogistics.com/resources/company-news-and-blogs/blogs/freight-rfp-guide-for-shippers
PLANNING A TRANSPORTATION BID?
Bring us the lane file. We’ll start with the freight. Scan the QR Code to discuss your freight RFP with one of our professionals. Buchanan Logistics, Inc. www.BuchananLogistics.com 1-866-660-7091
INDIANA
5130 Executive Blvd., Fort Wayne, IN 46808 (Corporate Office)
11611 N. Meridian St., Carmel, IN 46032
ARIZONA 3707 E. Southern Ave., Office 2005 Mesa, AZ 85206 MICHIGAN 1717 Ridgewood Dr., Suite 101 Midland, MI 48642
ARKANSAS 811 N Dixieland Rd., Rogers, AR 72756 MISSOURI 9601 NE Barry Rd., Suite 220 Kansas City, MO 64158 TENNESSEE 2525-A Lebanon Pike., Suite 4 and 5 Nashville, TN 37214
MASSACHUSETTS 98 Lower Westfield Rd., Suite 111 Holyoke, MA 01040 PENNSYLVANIA 1200 Commerce Circle Trafford, PA 15085
SOUTH CAROLINA 5 Century Dr., Suite 240 Greenville, SC 29607
TEXAS 17630 Beaumont Hwy., Houston TX, 77049
IMPORTANT PLANNING NOTE This toolkit is intended as a general freight procurement and transportation-planning resource. Transportation requirements, pricing structures, carrier availability, service standards, regulatory requirements and operating conditions vary by shipper, provider, freight, lane and jurisdiction. Businesses should establish RFP requirements and transportation decisions based on their specific operational, financial, contractual and regulatory needs.
Ð 2019 National Interstate Insurance One Million Safe Miles Award Ð 2020 BCP Transportation Freight Brokerage Business Integrity Award Ð 2020 Trucker Tools 80% and Higher Visibility Compliance Champion Ð 2020 Armstrong & Associates’ Report of Top 100 List for Digital Freight Matching (Armstrong & Associates) Ð 2021 & 2020 Penske Logistics Flatbed Service Provider Award Ð 2021, 2020 & 2019 Top 50 Dedicated Contract Carriers (ttnews.com) Ð 2022 Diamond Trucker Tools Partner Award for Most Loads Tracked (Nominated) Ð 2023, 2022, & 2020 Schneider Flatbed Carrier of the Year Award Ð 2023 Clutch Top Shipping Companies in Indiana Ð 2023 Top 10 Flatbed Trucking Service Providers (The Logistics Transportation Review) Ð 2023 & 2022 Freightwaves Top 500 For-Hire Carriers (FreightWaves) Ð 2023 ABC Supply’s Southwest Region Carrier of the Year Ð 2023 Isometric Technologies (ISO) Retailer Service Winner Ð 2025 CarrierSource Top Carriers for 2025 (CarrierSource) Ð 2026 A&A’s Top 100 Domestic Transportation Management (DTM) 3PLs List (Armstrong & Associates) Ð 2026, 2025, 2022, 2021, 2020, & 2019 Top 100 Freight Brokerage Firms (ttnews.com)
5130 Executive Blvd. • Fort Wayne, IN 46808 260.471.1877 • www.buchananlogistics.com
© 2026 Buchanan Logistics
bl-frrfptoolkt_v1.7
Page 1 Page 2 Page 3 Page 4 Page 5 Page 6 Page 7 Page 8 Page 9 Page 10 Page 11 Page 12 Page 13 Page 14 Page 15 Page 16 Page 17 Page 18 Page 19 Page 20Made with FlippingBook interactive PDF creator