101 West Ohio Street, Suite 1540 Indianapolis, IN 46204 317-636-7777 www.sevenishlaw.com
PRST STD US POSTAGE PAID BOISE, ID PERMIT 411
Inside THIS ISSUE
Just Another Day for Her, a Miracle for Me Page 1 Top 5 Healthy Life Hacks to Have an Awesome Morning The Safest Way for Teens to Learn Motorcycling Page 2
Can Gratitude Help You Live Longer? Page 3
Woman Sues Starbucks Over ‘Too Much Ice’ Page 4
ICE, ICE, LAWSUIT
Woman Sues Starbucks Over ‘ Too Much Ice’
Sometimes, there is such a thing as “too much ice.” You’re sipping your cold beverage when suddenly, it’s gone far quicker than you expected. All you’re left with is a cup full of ice. It’s disappointing, for sure, but is it so disappointing that you would want to file a lawsuit against the company that supplied the beverage? That’s exactly what Stacy Pincus did in 2016. She ordered an iced coffee from Starbucks, only to find “too much ice” in her drink. The lawsuit, filed in Chicago, alleged that the drink was advertised as a 24-ounce beverage, but once the ice was factored in, Pincus and her lawyers claimed the drink was really only “14 fluid ounces.” “Starbucks’ advertising practices are clearly meant to mislead consumers when combined with the standard practice of filling a cold drink cup with far less liquid than the cup can hold,” the suit claimed. NBC News reported that Pincus sought damages to the tune of $5 million against the coffee chain.
“The plaintiff would not have paid as much,” her lawyers stated in a court document, “if anything, for the cold drinks had she known that they contained less, and in many cases, nearly half as many, fluid ounces than claimed by Starbucks. As a result, the plaintiff suffered injury in fact and lost money or property." Starbucks’ response: “Our customers understand and expect that ice is an essential component of any 'iced' beverage. If a customer is not satisfied with their beverage preparation, we will gladly remake it.” The company also reaffirmed that you can order any iced beverage with “light ice” and receive half the ice normally included. Interestingly, a second lawsuit against Starbucks popped up in Los Angeles a few months later, but both cases were thrown out. Pincus never saw a cent of that $5 million, nor did she recoup her attorneys’ fees. The case went on to be called “one of the most frivolous lawsuits of 2016.”
4
www.sevenishlaw.com | 317-636-7777
Made with FlippingBook Learn more on our blog