organizations to address these gaps, enhance patient safety, and strengthen their overall system. Effective debriefing programs involve acknowledging and resolving system flaws, which increases team members’ investment in the debriefing process and improves their ability to perform. Key Elements of Effective Debriefing Effective debriefing after a crisis event requires key elements to promote a productive discussion among team members. The mnemonic “ WATER ” summarizes these elements: 1. Welfare Check: Assess the well-being of team members involved in the event, ensuring they can continue providing care safely. 2. Acute Corrections: Address immediate concerns and make necessary adjustments, such as replacing equipment or restocking supplies. 3. Team Reactions and Reflection: Create a safe environment for open communication, allowing team members to share their thoughts and experiences without fear of retribution. 4. Education: Allocate time for reflection and learning, discussing what went well, areas for improvement, and lessons learned. 5. Resource Awareness: Inform team members about available support resources, such as employee assistance programs or peer support. Incorporating these elements fosters a comprehensive and effective debriefing that promotes learning, communication, and emotional support among the team. Let’s discuss them in more detail. Welfare Check The aftermath of a crisis event can have a profound negative impact on individuals involved. Research has shown that healthcare professionals who have experienced a memorable
perioperative catastrophe often report feelings of guilt, anxiety, and reliving the event. Additionally, a significant percentage of respondents in a survey experienced compromised ability to provide care for up to four hours after the event, but only a small percentage were allowed sufficient time to recover. Conducting a welfare check immediately after a crisis event provides an opportunity to assess the well-being of team members and determine if they are emotionally and physically capable of continuing to provide care. Acute/Short-term Corrections Following a crisis event, it is crucial to address any immediate matters that require attention. This includes identifying and resolving time- sensitive issues, such as replacing or replenishing equipment or medications that were used during the event. For example, monitoring devices, infusion pumps, or medications that were taken out of the operating room with the patient may need to be addressed promptly. It is important to involve personnel outside of the perioperative team in order to accommodate the ongoing care provided by the team. By addressing these acute corrections in a timely manner, potential barriers to implementing debriefing can be removed, and the pressure to resume clinical work can be reduced. Whenever possible, clinical work should pause to create dedicated time and space for debriefing.
Types of Debriefing
Definition
would benefit providers in the future. By providing a platform for open discussion and incorporating psychological support, debriefing can help individuals process their emotions, enhance resilience, and facilitate faster recovery. Debriefing should not be mandatory, as some providers may recover better through personal reflection and solitude. 3. Promotes Pyschological Safety and Team Building Another advantage of timely debriefing is its ability to foster a climate of openness and level hierarchical structures within healthcare teams. Daily debriefing sessions implemented during the COVID-19 pandemic, for example, promoted a sense of psychological safety, enabling team members to freely express concerns and collaborate with colleagues they might not typically approach. This promotes team-building and a shared sense of purpose among individuals involved in a crisis event. By establishing a non- judgmental environment, debriefing enhances communication, collaboration, and overall team performance during future crises. 4. Improves System Gaps Furthermore, debriefing allows for the identification of system gaps and subsequent improvements in patient safety and quality of care. By analyzing the events and challenges experienced during a crisis, debriefing helps Debriefing at the point of care within two days (ideally immediately) after a critical event/procedure. Debriefing that occurs days or longer after the incident. May involve individuals not involved in the event (e.g., leadership/quality and safety). Facilitator-led group held soon after traumatic events with individuals considered to be under stress from traumatic exposure.
Proximal or real-time “hot” debriefing
Distal or “cold” debriefing
Critical incident stress debriefing
Four Benefits of Timely Crisis Debriefing
Timely debriefing is a critical aspect of a comprehensive crisis response plan, offering numerous advantages to individuals, multidisciplinary teams, and the healthcare system as a whole. The benefits of debriefing are evident in various areas, including expert learning, mitigating negative impacts, psychological support and team-building, and system improvement. 1. Facilitates Expert Learning One significant advantage of timely debriefing is its potential to facilitate expert learning from crisis events. It allows team members to reflect on and discuss the event immediately after it occurs, enabling them to extract valuable insights and lessons. This expert learning is particularly valuable in fields like advanced cardiac and pediatric life support, as well as medical simulation. By incorporating timely debriefing into the crisis response process, organizations can promote continuous improvement and knowledge transfer. 2. Mitigates Negative Impact Debriefing also plays a role in mitigating the negative impact of crisis events on healthcare providers. Research indicates that debriefing is underutilized, with actual crisis events being debriefed less than 30% of the time. However, healthcare professionals who have experienced such events express a belief that debriefing
Crisis situations can have profound psychological repercussions for both participants directly involved and bystanders observing the events unfold.
uncover potential weaknesses in existing procedures and protocols. This enables
126
WHAT DID YOU SAY?
BENEFITS OF CRISIS DEBRIEFING 127
Made with FlippingBook Publishing Software