PAPERmaking! Vol12 Nr2 2026

Carrejo et al. Carbon Neutrality

(2026) 5:3

Page 21 of 35

cradle-to-grave system boundary. Under these broader boundaries, carbon removal is treated as inseparable from the entire pulp mill operation: the removal would not occur without the harvesting, transportation, and processing of biomass, making the full pulping process— along with CCS—a necessary component of the carbon removal activity. In this configuration, biogenic CO 2 is treated as a co-product rather than a “waste” stream, and all lifecycle emissions are accounted for—includ- ing upstream emissions from biomass cultivation and sourcing, onsite emissions from biomass processing, and downstream emissions from paper product decomposi- tion. The maximum theoretical carbon removal is defined as the total amount of biogenic CO 2 fixed by the biomass feedstock during photosynthesis. All other emissions— regardless of source—are classified as CO 2 “leakages” in the net removal calculation. Net carbon removal is quantified using Eq. 6 , which reflects this comprehensive boundary condition. This approach provides the most complete accounting of emissions and removals without considering ecosystem carbon dynamics. It highlights the role of product end-of-life management in determining the durability and credibility of claimed carbon removals. In this system, the amount of CO 2 fixed by the biomass is defined as the CO 2 equivalent to the carbon content of the roundwood logs and chips used for paper production, as well as the bark and forestry residues combusted in the biomass boiler to generate steam for CCS operations. Wood rejects utilized in the biomass boiler of the pulp and paper facility are already included in the account- ing of biomass used for paper manufacturing to avoid double-counting. Biogenic CO 2 emissions include all uncaptured CO 2 released from biomass combustion in the paper mill’s point sources—namely, the recovery boiler, biomass boiler, and lime kiln—as well as in the CCS facility. These emissions also account for CO 2 losses during pipeline transportation and geological injection. The biogenic CO 2 retained in pulp corresponds to the carbon content of the final paper product, assuming complete oxidation to CO 2 upon degradation or end-of-life disposal (e.g., incineration). This assumption is reasonable given that the dominant end-of-life pathways for paper products in the United States are recycling, landfill, and incineration. While anaerobic decomposition in landfills can generate methane, most U.S. municipal solid waste landfills are equipped with gas collection systems, and the majority of collected methane is flared [35, 61]—converting it to CO 2 prior to atmospheric release. This supports the assump- tion that the majority of carbon in discarded paper is ulti- mately released as CO 2 , not methane. The paper product end-of-life implications on the net carbon removal effi- ciency when integrating CCS into P&P operations are

analyzed in a section of the supplementary information material. Additional unaccounted biogenic CO 2 emis- sions, such as those associated with the removal of vol- atile compounds (e.g., turpentine), are categorized as “other biogenic losses” to close the mass balance. Direct fossil CO 2 emissions reflect the combustion of natural gas within both the pulp and paper mill and the CCS facility. Indirect emissions include upstream and downstream activities such as raw material transporta- tion, forest management, grid-based electricity consump- tion, and the embodied emissions of CCS infrastructure and consumables. To evaluate the impact of fully integrating CCS across multiple point sources within P&P operations, we assessed net carbon removal across five sequential cap- ture scenarios, normalized to the total biogenic CO 2 fixed by biomass—representing the theoretical carbon removal potential. These results are shown in Fig. 10, with emis- sions disaggregated using a complete cradle-to-grave sys- tem boundary (System 4). The initial scenario (Fig. 10a) targets only the recovery boiler flue gas—the largest biogenic CO 2 point source in a typical kraft mill. This configuration yields the lowest net carbon removal efficiency of 17%, as upstream and operational emissions from both the P&P and CCS facili- ties reduce the overall effectiveness of the CO 2 captured from the recovery boiler. Despite the modest net car- bon removal efficiency, the system achieves net-negative emissions, demonstrating that even partial CCS integra- tion can transform a kraft mill into a carbon sink while continuing to produce economically and socially valuable materials. Subsequent scenarios expand the CCS facility to include flue gas from additional point sources. Captur- ing emissions from the CCS biomass boiler increases the net removal efficiency to 26% (Fig. 10b), while further inclusion of the P&P biomass boiler raises this to 36% (Fig. 10c). These incremental improvements highlight the value of expanding CCS coverage to other biogenic sources, although they also illustrate diminishing returns due to the rising influence of indirect and infrastructure- related emissions. Further expansion to include the lime kiln and natural gas boiler elevates net carbon removal efficiency to 46% in the most comprehensive scenario (Fig. 10e). This indi- cates that when all major CO 2 point sources are captured, nearly half of the potential carbon removal from biomass is durably sequestered. Although targeting smaller point sources like the lime kiln or fossil-derived emissions from the natural gas boiler may not be sufficient on their own to achieve net-negative outcomes, their inclusion in a fully integrated capture system significantly enhances overall performance.

Made with FlippingBook Online newsletter maker