Carrejo et al. Carbon Neutrality
(2026) 5:3
Page 23 of 35
While economic studies suggest that targeting high- volume, high-purity CO 2 streams (e.g., recovery boiler, biomass boilers) can be financially viable under exist- ing incentives such as the U.S. 45Q tax credit, these find- ings emphasize that maximizing environmental benefit requires broader system integration [7, 8]. Taken together, these results underscore the importance of strategic CCS deployment across multiple point sources to optimize car- bon removal outcomes in the pulp and paper sector. Figures S5 and S6 present life cycle CO 2 emissions nor- malized by two additional functional units—per tonne of paper produced and per tonne of biomass consumed— offering complementary insights to the results shown in Fig. 10. These alternative perspectives highlight the sig- nificant contribution of uncaptured biogenic emissions as well as end-of-life product emissions to the overall car- bon balance. Figure 11 summarizes net carbon removal efficiency across several system and scenario configurations using both gate-to-gate and cradle-to-grave system bounda- ries. Under the gate-to-gate system (System 2), results are normalized to the total biogenic CO 2 available for capture from biomass combustion only (whether in RB or RB + CCS BB), excluding upstream and downstream emissions. As shown, targeting only the recovery boiler achieves 60.7% net carbon removal, while including the CCS biomass boiler increases this to 75.6%. This is a notable contrast to Fig. 9, where both capture scenarios showed similar removal performance—and where the net carbon removal efficiency reached as high as 92% under a narrow system boundary. The discrepancy arises from differences in the normalization method—Fig. 9 uses gross biogenic CO 2 captured, whereas Fig. 11 uses total biogenic carbon input, consistent with Eq. 6. The cradle-to-grave system (System 4) incorporates all life cycle emissions, including upstream sourcing, onsite operations, and downstream product decomposition. The carbon removal efficiencies presented in Fig. 11 for this system boundary are normalized to the total amount of CO 2 fixed by the biomass during photosynthesis, which represents the theoretical upper limit for atmos- pheric carbon removal, and differs from the functional unit for System 2 results presented in Fig. 11, which is the total biogenic CO 2 available for capture from bio- mass combustion in the recovery boiler (RB) or the RB plus the CCS biomass boiler (CCS BB). As additional flue gas streams are incorporated into the CCS design— from the P&P biomass boiler, lime kiln, and natural gas boiler—net carbon removal efficiency steadily increases from 17.1% to 45.2%. These gains reflect the importance of maximizing the number of point sources captured in order to overcome the emissions burden associated with
the full cradle-to-grave footprint of the mill and CCS infrastructure. Importantly, Fig. 11 also includes a hypothetical sce- nario in which the carbon content of the paper product is assumed to be permanently stored rather than emitted at end-of-life. This scenario results in a substantial jump in net removal efficiency to 78.2%, demonstrating the powerful influence of durable product carbon storage on overall system performance. While not currently achiev- able under standard waste management practices, this level of removal could be possible through future inno- vations in biomass burial or other carbon stabilization strategies. Together, these results emphasize that while expand- ing the number of capture targets within the facility improves net removal, achieving high overall carbon removal efficiency will ultimately require addressing end- of-life (EoL) emissions as well. As such, product carbon fate should be considered a critical design parameter in future CDR strategies applied to the pulp and paper sec- tor. In a section in the supplementary information, we analyze the paper product EoL and perform a sensitivity analysis on the methane emissions impact on net carbon removal (Figure S3). Additionally, Table S11 presents a summary of the annual CO 2 emissions and net carbon removal under a complete static LCA perspective of a CCS integrated into the UBSK mill. The net carbon removal potential of integrating CCS into a virgin fiber-based pulp and paper mill, expressed per unit of annual product and per tonne of biomass con- sumed, is presented in Fig. 12. These results confirm that carbon capture from the recovery boiler—the largest bio- genic CO 2 point source—is sufficient to shift the facility from a net emitter to a net carbon sink under a cradle- to-grave life cycle boundary. In contrast, capturing only the emissions from smaller sources, such as the biomass boiler or lime kiln, is unlikely to achieve net-negative emissions on its own. As additional point sources are included in the CCS system design, the carbon removal potential improves significantly, demonstrating the value of targeting multiple emission streams for durable carbon sequestration. 3.5 System 5 (Dynamic Cradle-to-Grave): Paper mill and CCS facility System 5 preserves the configuration of System 4 but replaces its static biogenic carbon balance with the time-explicit GWP bio factor. This parameter (i) applies a radiative forcing penalty for the years that biogenic CO ᔐ remains in the atmosphere between combustion and
Made with FlippingBook Online newsletter maker