A practical guide to photographing wild animals with respect. By The Motherbear Expeditions.
THE MOTHERBEAR EXPEDITIONS
CLOSE, NOT CLOSER
A practical guide to photographing wild animals with respect By Melissa Schäfer and Fredrik Granath, The Motherbear Expeditions. People often ask how close we are to animals in the wild. After more than two decades in the Arctic, we have come to believe that is the wrong question. The better question is how well we understand the moment, and whether the animal can continue its life without being changed by us. We love a beautiful close encounter. But only when the animal sets the terms. The wild places left on our planet are shrinking, even as more of us seek them out. Wildlife has less room to roam, feed and rest, and more chances of being disturbed by our presence. That makes the way we travel all the more important. When we enter these places, we are guests. It’s up to us to give the animals who live there the space and quiet they need. This guide is for wildlife photographers, Arctic expedition guests, and anyone who wants to observe wild animals responsibly. By the end, you will have a practical way to choose respectful distance, read behaviour, wait for meaningful moments, and make images while putting the animal first.
The rule that guides everything The animal sets the terms. We are only guests.
Before you begin • Learn about the environment and the animal’s behaviour before you enter the field. • Know the rules on distance, while remembering that distance alone is only the beginning. • Know where not to stand so the animal can reach water, food, or open ground without being blocked. • Prepare to observe for a long time instead of pursuing a brief close-up. • Commit to never baiting animals or sending drones after them.
Seven principles for respectful wildlife photography
Principle
What it means
What to do
1. Let the animal set the terms
Judge the encounter by the animal’s response, not only by a distance rule.
Watch for changes in behaviour and stop affecting the animal. Leave room for it to move, feed, rest, and continue its life. Spend time witnessing the animal’s own life instead of trying to get closer. Observe before deciding whether to move, wait, or turn away. End the encounter while the animal can continue without us. Stop, wait, and experience what changes over minutes and hours.
2. Be a guest
The animal’s home comes first.
3. Choose observation over approach
The strongest connection can happen from a distance.
4. Read the animal from the start
Direction, speed, and body language reveal how the encounter is changing. An animal may look relaxed and still needs to search for food. Time allows the landscape and wildlife to reveal themselves.
5. Leave before the encounter becomes a show
6. Let patience do the work
7. Make the image ethically
A photograph is not worth changing an animal’s life.
Never chase, bait, or send drones after wild animals.
Read the animal before you act We start reading a polar bear from the first moment we see it, even when it is far away. As it comes closer, we watch every step and every reaction. A polar bear will rarely look straight at you; it is more likely to change its behaviour slightly because of you, and those small changes are what we do not want.
Watch the direction A bear walking along the shore is usually looking for sea ice, because that is where it finds food. It may first head towards a fjord with solid sea ice, then turn towards an area where there is none. It may not look stressed or nervous, but a change of course can mean that people, a ship, or something else has disturbed it. • Direction — notice where the animal is going and whether it changes course. • Speed — notice whether it is walking faster or differently than before. • Body language — notice whether it remains relaxed or begins to show signs of disturbance or stress. Practical response If the animal changes its behaviour because of you, turn away. The goal is not to prove that you can get close; it is to let the animal continue undisturbed. Know when to leave A curious male bear once stayed near us for a long time, playing in the water and rolling on the ice while guests took thousands of wonderful photographs. He was relaxed, but after a couple of hours we felt it was time for him to continue looking for food instead of putting on a show for us. We left while the encounter was still calm. What guests often miss Most guests do not yet feel when it is enough or when it is the wrong time to approach. Another example is when we once were observing a mother and her cub at a distance. Another boat went in front of us, launched its zodiacs, surrounded the bears, and waved at the mother to make her look into their cameras. The encounter changed for the worse and put the lives of the mother and cub in danger. At first our guests were angry that the other boat had come so close while wondering why we kept our distance. Once they understood the situation and why we do not work that way, they agreed with us. Learning to recognise disturbance changes what a respectful photograph means.
Patience and experience Learn the moment
In nature, and especially in the Arctic, patience pays off. Stay in one place for a while and something will happen. The sun rises and sets, colours shift, the air changes, and wildlife may pass through when you are ready to notice it. 1. Stop and wait when the place is worth experiencing, even if nothing is happening yet. 2. Watch how the light, water, ice, and air change over minutes and hours. 3. Give wildlife time to appear naturally instead of trying to make an encounter happen. On an expedition, patience must be balanced with the wish to travel and see different places. Sometimes the right choice is to stop in one fjord; sometimes it is to move on. A seal may surface, a walrus may swim past the ship, or a polar bear may appear on the sea ice in front of you when you simply wait. Knowledge takes years Long before tourism became big in these parts of the Arctic, Fredrik worked alone in the field. Years on the sea ice taught him things about polar bears, sea ice, and nature that could not be learned by travelling around the archipelago on a ship. He sometimes spent weeks with one particular bear, learning who it was, what its life looked like, and what it needed. He also learned the hard way. On one of his first hikes, he brought a tent from home without knowing how harsh the conditions could be. It blew to pieces on the first night. He read the weather wrong, and he went out alone, which you should never do in polar bear country. The same is true of reading bears. Early on, some bears showed stress in ways Fredrik did not recognise. A bear that changes its behaviour or direction may be conserving energy that it needs to hunt. Stressing a bear for only a few minutes can have a huge impact, and might even mean it does not survive the next summer. Experience is part of the responsibility Nobody learns to read wild animals in a day, through a class, or by reading a book. Years in the field make it possible to know when to wait, when to turn away, and how to leave the smallest possible footprint. And how the get the most amazing encounters without disturbing the animal. The ethics of the image We would never chase a bear for a picture. That is an ethical choice, but it is also a story- telling choice. When you chase a wild animal, there is no honest story in the resulting image—only a stressed animal changing its life because of you.
Do you really need to get closer? Everyone loves a good close-up, but getting closer at any price is selfish. If you want a 50 mm photograph of a polar bear, go to the zoo. There is no way to take that kind of picture in thewild while preserving nature and helping it as you document it. The better image shows the Arctic in its real, raw, and beautiful form. It may include a bear in its landscape, a long stretch of sea ice, or a moment that asks you to pay attention rather than fill the frame. The photograph should be something you can be proud of because you did not disturb anyone to make it. Never manufacture the moment Do not chase animals. Never bait them. Never send drones after them. A wild animal’s life is not a performance arranged for the camera. Respect is the subject
The aim is to see, learn from, and experience an animal living its own life.
Field checklist Use this checklist before and during an encounter. If you cannot answer these questions honestly, create more distance or leave. • Have I learned about this environment and this animal’s behaviour? • Do I know where not to stand so I am not blocking the animal’s way to water, food, or open ground? • Is the animal continuing in its own direction, at its own speed? • Does its body language remain relaxed? • Has the animal changed its course, speed, or behaviour because of me, a boat, or another disturbance? • If the animal is curious and staying near me, has the encounter gone on long enough that I should leave? • Am I waiting patiently rather than approaching to force a photograph? • Am I refusing to bait the animal or send a drone after it? • Will I leave the smallest possible footprint and let the animal continue its life?
Bring the principles home What we have learned from polar bears applies to all animals. You do not need to come to the Arctic to work this way. Every animal is different, and so is every place, so begin by learning what the environment and the animal require. • Educate yourself. Learn about the environment and the animal’s behaviour before you photograph it. • Know where not to stand. Make sure the animal can carry on without you blocking its route to water or feeding grounds. • Keep a distance that leaves it unbothered. You usually cannot hide from animals, but you can be as careful as possible. • Be patient. Patience is the key to the most amazing moments in nature. Why being there matters There is a big difference between seeing Svalbard and Greenland on social media and actually being there. No matter how great a photographer you are, you cannot capture the real beauty of the Arctic and its wildlife. You have to stand in front of a gigantic iceberg, a powerful polar bear, or a magnificent sunset to truly understand it and breathe it in.
Nature is bigger than anything.
Come with us We want you to come home with amazing memories and photographs that you can be proud of, knowing that you didn’t disturb or stress anyone. If this is the way you want to experience the Arctic, we would love to have you with us. We lead small expeditions to Svalbard and Greenland aboard M/S Freya, with never more than 12 guests, guided by Fredrik, Melissa, Acacia Johnson, and Lianna Nixon.
We are only guests up here. Let’s be good ones together.
Melissa & Fredrik
themotherbear.com/expeditions
THE MOTHERBEAR EXPEDITIONS www.themotherbear.com • E-mail: info@themotherbear.com • Phone and WhatsApp: +46 707 811 787
Page 1 Page 2 Page 3 Page 4 Page 5 Page 6Made with FlippingBook. PDF to flipbook with ease