SUMMARY OF IMPORTANT CALIFORNIA SENTENCING PROVISIONS
California’s Determinate Sentencing Law creates a framework to guide judges when considering and imposing sentences. When the Determinate Sentencing Law was enacted in 1977, the vast majority of felonies were given three distinct terms of incarceration, lower, mid and upper, which are colloquially called the “triads.” The default terms were 16 months, two years and three years. The legislature set the triads for individual crimes over the following years for violent and sex crimes. Life and life without parole were also set as alternatives to the triad in the most serious crimes (murder, violent rape, etc.). California Penal Code §§ 1170 and 1170.1 set the basic rules for sentencing and selecting the term from the triad. The provisions required imposition of the middle term unless the circumstances in aggravation or mitigation outweighed that choice and required the upper or lower term. 38 In 2007 the U.S. Supreme Court found this sentencing scheme unconstitutional in Cunningham v. California , 549 U.S. 270, 863-64 (2007), saying that “under the Sixth Amendment, any fact that exposes a defendant to a greater potential sentence must be found by a jury, not a judge, and established beyond a reasonable doubt, not merely by a preponderance of the evidence.” The legislature (over the objections of CACJ and many other civil rights players) amended § 1170 as recommended by the Attorney General and the California District Attorneys Association. They claimed the new wording removed the preference for any term and left the court free to choose the upper term without any facts proven to the jury. Each amendment had a sunset date.
Some legislators, defense attorneys, and advocates believed the amended language actually called for imposition of the lower term in all cases except where aggravating factors were used. They advocated for extension of the sunset date on § 1170 every time it came up. In 2021, the legislature passed a bill (SB 567) to amend §§ 1170 and 1170.1 to require that aggravators be pled and proved to a jury, or admitted by the accused. The bill did not include a sunset date. The State Supreme Court in 2024 held, per the intent of the legislation, that California courts cannot go above the midterm of the triad unless facts supporting the enhancement are proven to the jury or admitted by the defendant. People v. Lynch , 552 P.3d 877 (Cal. 2024). Consecutive sentencing is also determined by statute and the Rules of Court. Cal. Penal Code § 1170.1; Cal. Rules of Court, rule 4.425. For most crimes it is up to the court to apply the Rules, but the legislature has set many requirements of consecutive sentencing, for some crimes and all enhancements. California Penal Code § 1170.1 establishes the principal term and subordinate terms for additional felony convictions sentenced. Finally, California has sentencing enhancements based on some eligible prior convictions, which are referred to as “strikes.” Defendants can receive enhanced sentences based on the number of prior strikes—one, two, or three (or more) prior strikes. Plea offers are sometimes conditioned on accepting (by defendants) a certain number of strikes or, alternatively, conditioned on agreements that prior strikes will not be used to enhance a sentence.
16
THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker