The California Trial Penalty

CALIFORNIA’S DISAPPEARING TRIAL

The Committee on Revision of the Penal Code (the “Committee”), established by the California Legislature and Governor, has acknowledged that “[a]n overwhelming majority of criminal convictions are resolved by plea bargaining,” and that “[t]he severity of punishment . . . can often push people to plead guilty to avoid or be freed from incarceration, not because it is a fair resolution.” 32 Between 2021 and 2022, across California counties reporting data, 75% of felony cases resulted in guilty pleas while 20% of the felony cases reported were dismissed or transferred. Less than 3% of the felony cases reported went to trial. 33 The Committee also found that defendants who plead guilty typically receive shorter sentences than those convicted at trial, adding further pressure for defendants to agree to guilty pleas. 34 In testimony provided to the Committee, it was explained that “[p]retrial detention can . . . exert a lot of pressure for people to plead guilty, especially if a guilty plea is going to get them out of detention,” 35 and that the emotional and financial hardships of incarceration influence decision-making because people will do anything to avoid staying in jail. 36 Accordingly, the Committee recommended that steps be taken to lessen the undue pressure to plead guilty by limiting part of the uncertainty of what sentence a court may impose after trial. Recommended measures included: revisiting rules surrounding pretrial detention and expanding the grounds upon which detention can be reduced to include existence of a plea offer, reducing the instances in which the same fact can be used for conviction and enhancement, instructing jurors on lesser-related offenses if those may be considered instead, and creating a presumption of probation instead of incarceration for certain offenses. 37

15

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker