The critiques of these aspects of guilty plea resolutions span the ideological and political spectrum. In 2019, the Federal Sentencing Reporter journal dedicated a double issue to the trial penalty. Critiques of the practice came in from all quarters across the ideological gamut, including the ACLU, Right on Crime, the Cato Institute, Families Against Mandatory Minimums, The Charles Koch Institute and Americans for Prosperity. Additionally, a coalition of advocates and groups from across the political spectrum and including prosecutors, defense lawyers, and academics has formed that is committed to mitigating the trial penalty and the harmful effects it has on the criminal legal system. 29 Concerns about the trial penalty are not limited to academics and other observers of our criminal justice system. In 2017, Judge Joseph Goodwin of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of West Virginia rejected a plea in an otherwise routine drug case, stating that:
with great irony, call a game. Rather, our Court’s tortured jurisprudence on appellate waivers has wreaked havoc on the lower courts, district attorneys, defense counsel and defendants, and is not worth any of the hypothetical benefits purportedly bestowed by appellate waivers. 31
[S]ecrecy surrounding plea bargains in heroin and opioid cases frequently undermines respect for the law and deterrence of crime. The bright light of the jury trial deters crime, enhances respect for the law, educates the public, and reinforces their sense of safety much more than a contract entered into in the shadows of a private meeting in the prosecutor’s office. 30
The Fourth Circuit upheld this decision in 2019, though it noted that the court might have abused its discretion had it rejected the plea based primarily on the government’s frequent use of the practice. Judge Goodwin rejected another plea on similar grounds in 2018. He is not alone: in 2014, Judge Jed Rakoff of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York wrote that “[t]he Supreme Court’s suggestion that a plea bargain is a fair and voluntary contractual arrangement between two relatively equal parties is a total myth: it is much more like a ‘contract of adhesion’ in which one party can effectively force its will on the other party.” In 2019, Judge Rowan Wilson of the New York Court of Appeals also raised concerns about how pleas operate in New York State. Dissenting in a case involving the waivers of appeal rights that often are required by the terms of a plea agreement, he noted that:
The game is not worth the candle. That is not to say this is a game: for many defendants, the harsh and chilling effect of appellate waivers results in the deprivation of their constitutional and statutory rights, far from anything one could, other than
14
THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker