The California Trial Penalty

seek pre-trial release, the right to discovery, the right to receive exculpatory material, the right to conduct a meaningful investigation, the right to challenge unlawfully seized evidence, the right to develop mitigation, and the right to appeal.

A homeless man suffering from a drug addiction, who had a history of minor robberies, was accused of stealing a ring from another man in a train station. The officer who was on the scene stated that she thought she saw the homeless man take the ring, but the defendant maintained that it was a legitimate exchange. The officer was not wearing a bodycam, there were no other witnesses, and there was minimal investigation after the fact. The ring was returned to the alleged victim, and he did not participate in the criminal proceedings.

To provide further context and details on the experiences of individual practitioners with the trial penalty, the survey included open-ended questions for practitioners to describe specific cases they believe provide examples of the trial penalty. Additionally, two dozen survey participants participated in follow-up interviews to provide further details on cases and practitioner experiences with the trial penalty.

overwhelming majority of respondents answered “Yes.” Specifically, over 90% of survey respondents said the trial penalty was a factor in their county. In 12 of 30 counties for which more than five responses were recorded, 100% of respondents answered “Yes.” The lowest average affirmative response rate to the question from a county was 83%. The prosecutor charged the homeless man with a third strike, which would mean a sentence of 25 years to life. The defendant’s counsel suggested a plea deal to misdemeanor theft, but the prosecutor insisted on the 25 to life sentence. After pre-trial motions, where counsel detailed the facts, the judge questioned the prosecutor why there had been no plea agreement. It was only at that point that the prosecutor was willing to negotiate. He agreed to lower the charge to a misdemeanor, and the defendant was sentenced to time served.

DEFENSE COUNSEL PERSPECTIVE: TRIAL PENALTY AND COERCION One defense counsel’s response captures the essence of the trial penalty in California:

The client did not want to take the plea but even the judge iterated that if he did not accept the plea, she would have to sentence him to life in prison if he lost at trial. DA threatened enhancements.

The survey responses and corresponding interviews capture the perspectives of hundreds of practitioners across the state of California. The vast majority of respondents reported the existence of the trial penalty and cited the coercive role played by prosecutors, judges, or both. Respondents also provided further insights into a range of other aspects of the trial penalty including how it manifests, the populations it is most likely to affect, and its impact on procedural and rights-based issues. 42 Subsequent narrative interviews were conducted with a subset of practitioners. These narrative interviews provide additional specificity and supplementary context to the way the trial penalty is imposed across the state. Statewide survey responses were received in 53 counties out of 58 counties in California, representing a mix of urban, suburban, and rural communities. Existence and Occurrence of the Trial Penalty Defense practitioners across California affirmed that the trial penalty is both real and pervasive, though its severity and consistency vary across jurisdictions. Responses from across the state point overwhelmingly to the existence of the trial penalty. When asked, “Do you believe the trial penalty is a factor in this county?”, an

While survey respondents overwhelmingly reported that the trial penalty existed in their county, they also said that it varied from courthouse to courthouse and case to case. Respondents were asked in Q23–6, “If the trial penalty is a factor in your county, is the trial penalty uniform throughout the county, or does it vary significantly by courthouse, courtroom, or prosecutor?” Respondents were encouraged to check each answer that applied and only roughly nine percent of the responses provided

18

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker