The California Trial Penalty

indicated that the trial penalty occurred uniformly across courts and prosecutors. The most common responses suggested that the manifestation of the trial penalty varied based on the deputy DA or City Attorney (69.77%), the presiding judge (54.24%), the supervising prosecutor (48.24%), and from courthouse to courthouse (36.44%). Respondents provided numerous examples illustrating how the trial penalty operates in practice.

charge, yet received a harsher sentence than he would have received had he pleaded guilty to the prosecutor’s offer.

Taken together, both the quantitative findings and practitioner narratives establish a clear consensus among California defense counsel that the trial penalty is a pervasive reality that varies in degree but not in existence. It is shaped by prosecutorial discretion, judicial practices, and local court culture. Coercion In addition to acknowledging the existence of the trial penalty, a noteworthy majority of respondents reported a belief that the state coerces defendants to accept plea offers. Approximately 72% of respondents replied that prosecutors “frequently” or “sometimes” apply coercion to induce clients to accept a plea offer. Omitting missing responses, 43 that number increased to roughly 89%, as shown in the chart below for Q4–3a. Approximately 60% of respondents reported the same of judges; which increased to roughly 73% when accounting for missing responses, as shown in the chart below for Q5–3b. These responses varied by county. In felony cases, roughly 70% of respondents reported a belief that prosecutors often “use direct or implied threats to encourage acceptance of offers.” Omitting missing responses, 44 that number increased to 90%. In comparison, only 31% of respondents cited judges as using

On the day of jury selection the DA offered 7 years to settle the case before trial, the offer had been about 14 years, we went to trial, client didn’t want to plea, after trial he was convicted and the court gave him 29 years, all same charges for the plea offer of 7, found not guilty on one count but not the most serious. * * * The DA offered 14 years but then pursued a life count at trial. * * * Client rejected the prosecutor’s offer. Client went to trial and was acquitted of the charge with the most exposure. Nonetheless, he was sentenced to MORE time than the prosecutor’s offer. In other words, client was punished for going to trial, where he was acquitted of the most serious

19

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker