Nearly all respondents indicated that their offices do not have a general policy that if a defendant, in either a felony or misdemeanor case, rejects an initial plea offer that the defendant will be told that any future plea offers will be less favorable. 52 Despite the lack of an official policy, nearly one‑third of respondent prosecutors, with respect to felony cases, and nearly one‑quarter of respondents, with respect to misdemeanor cases, indicated that they do tell defendants that any future plea offers will be less favorable if the initial plea offer is rejected, with the remaining respondents indicating that they rarely or never make such comments to defendants. Further, with respect to felony cases, nearly one‑third of prosecutors indicated that they have added additional charges and/or enhancements following a defendant’s rejection of an initial plea offer and one‑third of respondents indicated that future offers have increased sentencing. With respect to misdemeanor cases, nearly one‑quarter of respondents indicated that they add felony charges following a defendant’s rejection of an initial plea offer, with over one‑third of respondents indicating that they have added additional charges and/or enhancements and over one‑half of respondents indicating that future offers have increased sentencing. Additionally, nearly two‑thirds of respondents, with respect to felony cases, and over one‑half of respondents, with respect to misdemeanor cases, indicated that they offer expiring plea offers (e.g., “for today only”). Respondents were split evenly as to whether judges in felony cases encourage or support such conditions to plea offers and were split approximately two‑to‑one as to whether judges in misdemeanor cases encourage or support such conditions to plea offers, with most indicating that judges did not encourage such conditions.
F E LON Y
MISDEMEANOR
30
THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker