their county). Slightly more than half of respondents indicated that the trial penalty varied by the type of case, indicating that the trial penalty was most common in felony cases with available enhancements (strikes, priors, etc.), homicide cases, sex cases and assault cases.
Sometimes cases are undercharged to encourage a plea. If [defendant] doesn’t plead, then we charge him for what he actually did which is more than his initial charges. * * * I’ve stated that future offers may or may not be the same. I’m not going to make an offer with a promise that it will never change. * * * We don’t punish defendants or add anything if they reject an offer in my unit. We may change the offer at a later point, but it usually means they want trial. Up until trial assignment, they can usually accept the offer. Other times, offer expires at day of trial calling and no further negotiations are had because defense rejected or let it expire.
What I really see is not a trial penalty, but an intentional pre-trial “discount” especially by certain judges in [my county], who “give away” cases to get them off the docket.
Prosecutors indicated that the trial penalty manifests itself through dramatically reduced plea offers (as opposed to dismissal) after the revelation of a constitutional defect or other core problem with the prosecution, the addition of new charges if a plea offer is not accepted, increased severity of charges, increased sentence in subsequent plea offers, waiver of appeals, significantly increased penalty if convicted after trial and local or common perceptions about how the trial penalty could be used against the accused. Respondents further indicated that mandatory minimum sentences, policies and practices of prosecutors, specific offices and courts, and judges (e.g., the court actively engaging or not engaging in the bargaining process), pre- trial release status of the defendant, policies and practices of defense attorneys and excessive case load were all factors in the occurrence of the trial penalty. The vast majority of respondents that provided responses 53 indicated that judges will impose concurrent sentences, dismiss charges under Penal Code 1385 or take other actions after trial so that
The Trial Penalty Prosecutors were also asked to comment on the existence of, and factors driving, the trial penalty in their county. More than two-fifths of respondents indicated that the trial penalty is a factor in their county and were split nearly evenly as to whether the trial penalty varied due to the presiding judge or from courthouse to courthouse (none indicated that it was uniform across all courts in
31
THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker