The California Trial Penalty

ANALYSIS OF DATA COLLECTED FROM CALIFORNIA COURTS AND DISTRICT ATTORNEYS

As discussed in detail above, the defense counsel survey results and defense counsel interviews revealed the strong belief held by an overwhelming majority of California defense attorneys that defendants who take their cases to trial risk, and if convicted often receive, longer sentences than individuals who accept guilty pleas. Defense counsel attributed the trial penalty to many factors, including prosecutors’ decisions and judges’ sentencing actions, among other reasons. To a lesser extent, the prosecutor survey revealed a significant minority of prosecutors agreed that a trial penalty exists in California, although they suggested different reasons than those identified by many defense counsel; for example, prosecutors suggested that the trial penalty is explained by significantly discounted plea offers that do not necessarily reflect the gravity of offenses and judges’ lenient sentencing practices for defendants entering guilty pleas rather than prosecutorial coercion or judicial punishment for defendants choosing jury trials as common explanations. Regardless of lawyers’ subjective opinions, a robust set of quantitative data collected from California Superior Courts and District Attorneys and analyzed by the Task Force provide strong confirmation for the defense counsel impressions about the existence of a trial penalty. 56 The data described in detail below show that defendants who took their cases to trial between 2013 and 2023 often received harsher average sentences than defendants charged with the same crimes who chose to plead guilty. Specifically, data received from seven urban, suburban, and rural California counties—representing hundreds of felony defendants who went to trial compared to thousands of felony defendants who pled guilty—showed that the average sentences for a significant majority of the felony defendants who went to trial ranged up to three times longer than the average sentences for defendants charged under the same penal codes who pled guilty. In contrast, only a fraction of

Seth Cravens

the defendants in the datasets analyzed who went to trial received average sentences that were shorter than defendants charged under the same penal codes who pled guilty. A significantly smaller set of data from two counties also allowed for an assessment of the likelihood for felony defendants to receive life sentences. The data for defendants charged under the same penal code reflected a greater prevalence of life sentences imposed on defendants who took their cases to trial compared to those who pled guilty. The sentencing discrepancy found in the data for misdemeanor offenses was even more dramatic than the felony data. When the average sentences imposed under the same penal code were compared, the vast majority of the hundreds of misdemeanor defendants in California who chose to go to trial received average sentences that were up Seth Cravens was charged with second-degree murder, following a bar fight with several of his friends that quickly escalated to fatal consequences. After a drunken dispute over a spilled drink at the bar, Cravens and four other co-defendants, all known as the “Bird Rock Bandits,” followed the victim to his home to continue the confrontation. The altercation broke out into a full physical fight between all the men outside victim’s home. During the fight, the victim confronted Cravens, who responded by throwing the final punch to the head, causing victim to fall backwards and hit his head on the pavement. The victim suffered a severe fractured skull and died from his brain injuries a few days later. Cravens was offered a plea deal of 18 years if he pled guilty to involuntary manslaughter, but he chose to go to trial, was found guilty and was sentenced to 20 years to life. His four co-defendants each accepted a plea offer for involuntary manslaughter and were sentenced to probation.

33

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker