to 22 times longer than sentences received by thousands of defendants who pled guilty. Like felony defendants, only a fraction of misdemeanor defendants who opted for a trial received sentences on average that were shorter than the sentences imposed on defendants charged under the same penal code subsections who entered guilty pleas. The findings described in this section are statistically significant. DATA COLLECTION EFFORTS AND DATA ANALYSIS METHODOLOGY Public records data requests and responses In June 2023, the Task Force sent California Public Records Act requests to District Attorney offices and to Public Defender and other institutional defender offices in each of the 58 counties in California. The Task Force also sent records requests pursuant to the California Rules of Court, Rule 10.500 to the Superior Courts in all 58 California counties. Each request sought records from 2013 to 2023 containing the following information:
they did not have any responsive records;
}
} their record systems were not configured to make it possible for them to generate responsive records; } they could not generate the requested records without significant expense to the Task Force; or } the records requested are exempt from disclosure by the applicable public records provisions. In addition, a number of Public Defenders responded that they were not permitted to provide responsive data due to client confidentiality restrictions. A number of respondents provided data that did not contain sufficient information to conduct any sort of trial penalty analysis for a range of reasons, and the Task Force excluded those datasets from its analysis. Among the reasons that the Task Force excluded datasets from its analysis were: } the datasets did not identify the penal code or contain a narrative description of the crime charged; } the datasets did not distinguish between cases that were tried versus those in which guilty pleas or nolo contendere pleas were entered;
For each crime for which data is available, any data, including aggregated data, showing the sentences for convictions upon guilty or “no contest” pleas, as compared to, or in addition to, data showing sentences upon conviction after trial for that same crime.
} the datasets did not include the sentence lengths; or
} the datasets only included aggregate sentences and did not distinguish the sentences imposed upon individual counts.
Many of public records request recipients indicated that they were not providing records in response to the Task Force’s request for one of several common reasons:
Dwayne Frampton Dwayne Frampton was at home, drinking with friends when a shooting took place. Having heard the gunshots, Frampton and his friends drove by the scene and asked questions about what had happened. An eyewitness identified Frampton by photograph as the shooter, and Frampton was charged with first degree murder. Frampton was 5-foot, 3-inches and 125 pounds. The eyewitness described the shooter as a 5-foot, 11-inch tall, 230 pound man. Although Frampton matched certain other aspects of the police composite sketch, the eyewitness told the artist and the investigating detective that the sketch was inaccurate. Frampton had been arrested previously but had never been convicted of anything.
The prosecutor initially offered to drop the charge to manslaughter and offered a sentence of 6 years imprisonment. Because he insisted that he was innocent, Frampton rejected the offer and took the case to trial. When Frampton attempted to call 3 of his friends as defense witnesses to corroborate his alibi, Judge William Pounders, who oversaw the case in Los Angeles County Superior Court, criticized Frampton’s counsel for not disclosing the witnesses sooner. Ultimately, only one of them testified. The jury initially returned as a hung jury. Instead of allowing counsel to reargue the entire case, Judge Pounders merely permitted the defense to present argument
on a specific question that the jury had raised. The jury returned a second time with a guilty verdict, and the judge sentenced Frampton to 50 years to life. After Frampton was sentenced, the eyewitness contacted Frampton’s counsel and admitted that the detective on the case and her mother had both convinced her to identify Frampton as the shooter because he was a bad guy and this was the only way to get him off the street. Because he chose to contest his innocence at trial, Frampton is serving a sentence more than 8 times longer than what he was offered if he had agreed to plead guilty.
34
THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker