The California Trial Penalty

Usable data sets However, a significant subset of data the Task Force received contained sufficient information to assess whether or not a trial penalty existed. The Task Force focused on datasets that identified each of the following types of specific case information: (1) the California Penal Code charge number for each count charged; (2) disposition information for each count charged, including whether the charge resulted in a guilty plea, a nolo contendere plea, a trial verdict, or some other disposition; and (3) the individual sentence imposed for each charged count. Datasets that included all of the above information were deemed to contain “usable data” because they permitted at least one type of data analysis relevant to the potential existence of a trial penalty. The Task Force received usable data from five Superior Courts of California: Amador County, El Dorado County, Orange County, Trinity County, and Ventura County. The datasets

from these five Superior Courts contained a combined total of 716,358 records. Similarly, the Task Force received usable data from District Attorney’s offices in ten counties: Calaveras County, Lassen County, Merced County, Modoc County, Monterey County, San Benito County, San Diego County, Siskiyou County, Trinity County, and Tuolumne County. The datasets from these ten District Attorney offices contained a total of 802,054 records. Overall, the datasets from the five Superior Courts and ten District Attorney offices contained 1,518,412 records from 14 different counties between January 2013 and August 2023, although not every county produced data for the entire ten-year period. The chart below shows the 14 jurisdictions that provided usable data from Superior Courts and District Attorneys that the Task Force subsequently analyzed, and the number of records contained in the datasets from each provider.

County

Date Range

Number of Records

Records Source

Superior Court

District Attorney

Amador

1/13 to 6/23

18,311

X

Calaveras

2/21 to 7/23

9,698

X

El Dorado

1/13 to 6/23

44,041

X

Lassen

11/13 to 12/23

3,072

X

Merced

1/15 to 12/22

163,479

X

Modoc

9/15 to 7/23

10,496

X

Monterey

6/18 to 5/23

62,847

X

Orange

1/13 to 6/23

428,980

X

San Benito

9/16 to 11/22

30,269

X

San Diego

1/13 to 6/23

270,859

X

Siskiyou

1/09 to 8/23

188,624

X

Trinity

1/13 to 5/23 1/13 to 7/23

1,285

6,963

X

X

Tuolumne

1/15 to 6/23

55,747

X

Ventura

1/18 to 8/23

223,741

X

Total

1,518,412

35

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker