The California Trial Penalty

PREVALENCE OF GUILTY PLEAS VERSUS TRIALS On aggregate, across thirteen counties 59 for which the Task Force received usable data, 97.4% of felony cases resulted in a guilty plea and 2.6% proceeded to trial. Focusing on the data from the individual counties, the percentage of guilty pleas in felony cases ranged from 94.9% in Trinity County on the low end to 98.4% in Amador and Calaveras counties on the high end. For misdemeanors, on aggregate, 99.2% of defendants entered guilty pleas compared to .8% of misdemeanor defendants who went to trial. On an individual county basis, 98% of cases were resolved in Modoc County by guilty pleas on the low end, and 99.6% of misdemeanor cases were resolved by guilty pleas in San Benito County on the high end.

The following chart shows the percentage of felony and misdemeanor guilty plea cases versus trial cases by county.

(1) Felony

(2) Misdemeanor

Guilty/ Nolo Plea

Guilty/ Nolo Plea

# of Records

# of Cases

# of Records

# of Cases

# County

Date Range

%

%

1/2/2013 ~ 6/28/2023 2/23/2021 ~ 6/13/2023 10/18/2021 ~ 6/29/2023 11/18/2013 ~ 12/12/2023 1/2/2015 ~ 12/30/2022 9/28/2015 ~ 5/31/2023 6/7/2018 ~ 7/5/2023 1/2/2013 ~ 6/30/2023 9/12/2016 ~ 11/9/2023 1/2/2013 ~ 6/29/2023 7/15/2009 ~ 8/23/2023 1/2/2013 ~ 4/4/2023 1/2/2018 ~ 8/31/2023

1

Amador

4,218

2,323

2,286

98.4% 6,550

3,816

3,787

99.2%

2

Calaveras

321

250

246

98.4% 568

497

494

99.4%

3

El Dorado

4,036

761

736

96.7% 9,593

2,011

1,991

99.0%

4

Lassen

5

Merced

10,822 8,247

8,095

98.2% 18,854 15,827 15,701 99.2%

6

Modoc

607

502

478

95.2% 1,358

1,136

1,113

98.0%

7

Monterey

8

Orange

105,432 105,432 103,388 98.1% 322,108 322,108 320,346 99.5%

9

San Benito

1,166

988

970

98.2% 5,678

4,560

4,540

99.6%

10 San Diego

92,810 92,810 90,816 97.9% 163,225 163,225 162,054 99.3%

11

Siskiyou

5,769

5,769

5,649

97.9% 8,888

8,888

8,812

99.1%

12 Trinity County

467

467

443

94.9% 578

578

574

99.3%

13

Ventura

35,450 8,625

8,383

97.2% 174,576 48,740 48,280 99.1%

97.4%

99.2%

(Avg)

(Avg)

37

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker