The California Trial Penalty

PENAL CODE ANALYSIS Another way to understand how pervasive guilty pleas were in the data analyzed by the Task Force is to sort the data by analyzing sentences separately for specific criminal offenses. To do this, the Task Force isolated individual California Penal Code subsections contained in the datasets. Data from nine counties contained penal code information—specifically, the datasets identified a total of 3,324 penal code subsections. Of that total, 2,710 penal codes subsections, or fully 81.5% of the penal code subsections in the aggregate data, were associated exclusively with guilty pleas; this means that there was not a single trial associated with more than four-fifths of the subsections representing charges in the datasets. In contrast, only 120 penal code subsections, or 3.6%, were associated exclusively with trials. The remaining 14.5% of the subsections (483), or merely one in seven, had cases associated both with guilty pleas and trials.

# of Penal Codes 60

Guilty/Nolo Plea Only

#

County

# of Penal Codes

Trial only

Both

Life Sentence

1

Amador

132

120

5

7

2

Calaveras

153

139

10

4

PC187(a) - Murder

3

El Dorado

288

244

7

37

4

Lassen

293

254

9

30

5

Modoc

181

152

8

21

6

Monterey

857

692

34

131

7

San Benito

280

255

6

19

8

Siskiyou

360

320

3

26

11

9

Ventura

780

534

38

208

Total

3,324

2,710

120

483

11

Total as a Percentage

81.5%

3.6%

14.5%

0.3%

1. Probability of Misdemeanor Versus Felony Conviction For each penal code subsection associated with both guilty pleas and trials, the Task Force calculated the percentage of cases where defendants opted to enter a guilty plea and received a misdemeanor conviction rather than a felony conviction. Similarly, the Task Force calculated the number of cases where the defendant went to trial and was convicted of a misdemeanor rather than a felony. Among cases involving the same Penal Code, overall, over 77% of defendants who opted to enter a guilty plea received a misdemeanor conviction, compared to only 53% of those who opted for a trial. This suggests a higher likelihood of a misdemeanor conviction for individuals who chose to plead guilty, compared to individuals who chose to go to trial.

38

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker