# of Records - Guilty/Nolo Plea
# of Records - Trial
# of Penal Codes
% Misdemeanor p2/(p1+p2)
% Misdemeanor t2/(t1+t2)
# of Records
Misdemeanor (p2)
Misdemeanor (t2)
# County
Felony (p1)
Felony (t1)
1 Amador
7
182
36
135
78.9%
8
3
27.3%
2 Calaveras
4
44
19
21
52.5%
3
1
25.0%
3 El Dorado 37
1,029
414
518
55.6%
76
21
21.6%
4
Lassen
30
1,478
(No charge type data to support this comparison)
5 Modoc
21
441
109
296
73.1%
14
22
61.1%
6 Monterey 131 18,695
(No charge type data to support this comparison)
7 San Benito 19
519
152
342
69.2%
13
12
48.0%
8 Siskiyou
26
1,344
952
341
26.4%
43
8
15.7%
9 Ventura 208 62,104
12,571
48,123
79.3%
615
795
56.4%
483
14,253
49,776
77.7%
772
862
52.8%
2. Methodology for Identifying a Trial Penalty Using Sentencing Comparisons by Penal Code A significant subset of the data received by the Task Force allowed for an apples-to-apples comparison of the average sentences received by defendants charged under specific individual subsections of the California Penal Code. This means that the Task Force was able to calculate the average sentences received by defendants who pled guilty under specific penal code subsections and compare those average sentences to the average sentences received by defendants who went to trial and were convicted of the identical subsections. More specifically, the data made it possible to calculate an average sentence ratio for specific penal code subsections. An average sentence ratio equal to 1 indicates that the average sentence for individuals who went to trial and were convicted pursuant to a specific subsection was the same as the average sentence for individuals who pled guilty. An average sentence ratio of greater than 1 for a specific penal code subsection means that individuals convicted at trial on average received longer sentences than individuals charged pursuant to the same subsection who entered a guilty plea. Therefore, an average sentence ratio greater than 1 represented a trial penalty. An average sentence ratio less than 1 means that individuals who went to trial on average received shorter sentences than individuals charged pursuant to the same penal code subsection who entered guilty pleas. In other words, an average sentence ratio less than 1 reflected a trial sentencing benefit.
3. Statistical Analyses of Sentencing Duration Across Seven Counties
The datasets from seven counties contained sufficient information—including penal code subsection information for each count charged, whether the disposition for each charged count was via guilty plea or trial, and the sentence imposed for each charged count—to compare the sentence lengths for defendants charged under identical subsections that were associated with both guilty pleas and trials. Using that data, the Task Force was able to calculate the average sentence duration for cases resulting in guilty pleas and cases that went to trial. The Task Force then calculated the ratio of sentence durations across the two scenarios: guilty pleas and trial cases. For felony cases across the seven counties, the average sentence duration for a significant majority of trials ranged between 1 to 3 times longer than the average sentence duration for guilty pleas. These average sentencing calculations were derived from a large and statistically significant number of cases. There were 100 different penal code subsections in the aggregate datasets analyzed by the Task Force which exhibited a trial penalty, meaning the average sentence for trial cases was longer than the average sentence for plea cases. There were a total of 14,084 felony plea cases among those 100 code subsections and a total of 688 felony trial cases. 61
39
THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker